Ferndale Pizza

Quite good. The eggplant parmesan sandwich was a thing of beauty, with three wonderful slices of deliciously fried eggplant. Everyone in our party enjoyed their food. Friendly waitstaff. Comfortable.

The pizza here is good. Not the best, but quite good and generous with toppings. But that’s it. The 2 sandwiches I’ve had were awful. The turkey sandwich was warmed turkey cold cuts and prepackaged super-​fine shredded lettuce (like eating lettuce-​flavored hair). Gross.
The pastrami was ordered with everything on it and… was *very* stingey on the meat and was mostly hair lettuce. No onion, no vinaigrette (or so little you can’t taste it) no mustard. The sandwiches were made with absolutely no damns given. So, I’d stick to the pizza which they do seem to care about.

Great place and amazing pizza! Shared a large between 3 adults and we still have 2 slices left over. Just wish the service was a little better. Was fresh and amazing best part is the amazing crust. I am not a crust person and I ate 2 slices crust and all

We live here in Ferndale and eat here about 3 – 4 months. The service is always great and everyone has the wonderful small town friendliness. We love their pizza, all scratch made and delicious ! If you find the pizza heavy on the cheese, can ask for light cheese and they will be happy to oblige. Their lasagna is also really tasty and Awesome sandwiches. They also have a nice salad bar. They are happy to do takeout on all their orders, as well as take and bake pizzas.

This Pizza is the absolute best. Tangy and not so sweet Pizza sauce, garlic cheese bread was great as well. Service was on point too! Don’t forget to tip!

One of the best pizza places I have ever experienced.
5 stars for overall food quality. However my only con is that the cheese is so thick and heavy, it doesn’t hold to the pizza crust and can slip right off the top — taking all of your toppings with it!
If you can live with the sometimes messy presentation of your meal, this is a must stop while in Ferndale!

Delicious pizza with a decent little salad bar served by nice people.
We ordered a cheese pizza with mushrooms on half — they put the toppings under the cheese so it’s a little hard to see which side is delicious to me and poison to my husband.
The beer selection could be more delicious but all in all a good pizza place.

Absolutely great pizza. If you’re in Ferndale you should definitely stop and get something to eat here.

EXCELLENT pizza place in a tiny town that could get away with crappy pizza! Hubby and I spent three evenings in Ferndale and chowed down on pizza after he ran a local marathon… he was ready for some hearty pizza and we found it!
The salad bar was an extra treat to make us feel a bit less guilty about the pizza… very nicely done.
The service was very friendly and locals come here mostly for pick up but that’s always a good sign…
We highly recommend Ferndale Pizza and hope to be back when the weather is more friendly to eat on the cute patio!

Came here for dinner based on the top quality Unilocal reviews we seen. The place was quite busy but we were seated promptly. Our server was excellent very friendly and very accommodating. My wife had the eggplant Parmesan. And I ordered a pizza. We left very satisfied with the fine Italian meal. There seems to be many quality dining options in this very quaint town. Ferndale pizza can hold their own in the competition there. We highly recommend this place if you’re in the area.

Our favorite pizza joint on the north coast. We visit every year from Minneapolis and always stop for pasta dinner, pizza, or sandwiches. Great local beer and service too!

Great place to find in a small town. Great pizza, and friendly people, loved it. Great salad bar too. Give ‘em a try, you won’t be disappointed.

The family loved the pizza here (and we know pizza). I loved the eggplant parmigiana. Next time we visit Ferndale, we will for sure eat here again.

We were not planning on having pizza but after passing it so many times this week we couldn’t help ourselves.
It wasn’t too crowded so we were seated right away by a very friendly young woman. We opted for the Cowboy Pizza and it was incredible! The sauce was great and there was tons of cheese and meats. It was a great pizza.
They also have a salad bar, nothing extraordinary there, but let’s be honest we only eat the salad to justify the calories of the pizza
If you’re in need for something tasty be sure to stop by, you will be glad you did.

My wife and I eat here often. The food is good, reasonably priced and a good size portion. I prefer the pastas or sandwiches. They also have a small salad bar that is usually well stocked. Very consistent with their menu and food quality. Have never left pizza co hungry or not satisfied. I recommend them and take out of town visitors and family without hesitations.

The cheesiest pizza I’ve ever had.
If you like TONS of cheese, this is your place.
No-​one in our group liked it (even the kids), but if you love cheese. This is the place to go.

I live in Humboldt. I drive out of my way to go to this place. Great pizza for reasonable prices and cool atmosphere. Salads are great (from what girls tell me) and you won’t find a better meatball sub. Ravioli’s are great, too. The only way I’d like it better is if it were walking distance from my house.
I’m pretty sure they’re open Sundays! Closed Monday’s, though.

A solid 4 stars! Food is a tad expensive compared to what us city folk are used to but par for the area. Service is an ez 5 stars! Pizza was all fresh ingredients and cooked perfectly. Garlic cheese bread was an awesome starter. We filled up after just two slices each. The salad bar looks very good but only one trip allowed makes it a no go for me cuz I don’t like piling it so high it falls off my plate
Otherwise if you need good food on your trip up the 99 stop in this Mayberry little town and enjoy. This town is the hometown of guy fieri so the food must be all good :)

We tried this place right when we moved to Humboldt about a year and a half ago on the recommendation of a local. It was just OK. definitely not «the best pizza ever» like our friend said it was. We later found Babes pizza near our house and it’s really good pizza. We tried it again recently and it was better this time. We like Babes but it’s a different style of pizza so you really cant compare them. Pizza Co isn’t bad, it’s just not what I prefer for pizza. PIzza Co pizza has good flavor but its a little more flat and soggy than I like.
The salad bar options were a bit scarce too. I personally dont like salad dressing so I appreciate a good salad bar with lots of topping choices so I was stuck with a boring lettuce cheese and olive salad.
I’m not saying dont go here, but I’m hardly ever in Ferndale and wouldnt make a special trip for Pizza Co. If you’re there and want pizza, it’s the place to go despite Guy Fieri skipping it.

This review is solely from a phone call: I asked «do you have personal pizzas?» Because I didn’t see them on the menu here on Unilocal.The lady says «yes, but I can only do one per tag» so what you are saying is that you will make 4 personal pizzas for 4 strangers, but you won’t make 4 personal pizzas for 4 friends? That’s the dumbest policy I know. Here… Swipe my card 4 times then!
Regardless… I just wanted one– so it’s beyond the point. So I said «ok, I just want one» then she says ok and takes my order. Here’s your total. Oh, and we don’t open for 45 minutes– so that personal pizza will take an hour… Might have been a good thing to say BEFORE I placed my order.
Anyways– long story short: stupid people, stupid policies, lost my business. Went to west side pizza in fortuna. Great choice, good pizza, $ 4 for 2 slices and a soda. (And she would have let me order more, too…)