I ordered a Marinara pie. I did not mind the high charge as long as it was good. When I got it home Was surprised. It was terrible. Big dough pie with sauce thrown on top. I have eaten a places were the Marinara was truly great. I did not even finish the 1 slice and threw the pie out. I will say there Brooklyn pizza is very good! I just ordered the wrong pie from Pauly.
James M.
Classificação do local: 2 Farmingville, NY
Food overall is disappointing, especially their bland garlic knots. Go to Primo Pizza instead in Farmingville, far above everything else in the area.
Anthony T.
Classificação do local: 1 Lewiston, ME
Disappointing, Disgusting, and Disrespectful. This place is the absolute worst. An overpriced mediocre pie, dirty floors, and dusty counters. Not to mention the obnoxious workers led by their racist manager. I came here with my girlfriend, only to hear degrading jokes and snickers out of the kitchen. Safe to say, this was the worst food establishment I have ever encountered.
Megan L.
Classificação do local: 4 Elmhurst, NY
One of my boyfriend’s coworkers placed an order from Paulys yesterday for four pies(two plain, one pepperoni, and one sausage), which came to a total of $ 75. His coworker lives relatively close to this establishment, but delivery took longer than the quoted time. However, the pizza was worth the wait! I only ate one plain slice but it was delicious. The other pizza slices looked delicious and everyone seemed to enjoy them. Overall, I would order from Paulys again, especially since they are open until 10PM!
Gary K.
Classificação do local: 5 Town of Brookhaven, Long Island, NY
Try the turkey pizza. It will be the best thing ya ever had. It weighs 12 lbs. Too bad it’s a seasonal item. It is everything you would have on an oversized Thanksgiving day plate. Delicious — incredible ! Get the turkey pie when you are having people over that you want to impress with perfectly cooked goodies all in one huge pie ! Don’t miss out !
Rollo T.
Classificação do local: 2 Holtsville, NY
Not impressed with any aspect of this pizza place. Average to below average pizza and service. The place appeared clean, however staffed with a few mutant like figures behind the counter bossing each other around who could care less what you say, and need everything repeated 3x when u order. A try was given, but 5 extra min down the road is Albert’s, and that’s the only pizza in the area worth driving for.
Jennifer M.
Classificação do local: 4 Bronx, NY
Pizza here is good! I ordered a pepperoni slice for my 3 year old, who freaked out over the oregano sprinkled on it. They were nice and accommodating in making me a new slice with pepperoni and no oregano. Very pleasant customer service and the food is good. Thanks Pauly!
Cari C.
Classificação do local: 5 Selden, NY
Awesome! The food here is just that, Awesome! So good that I now cater all of my events with the delicious foods from Pauly’s. Not only do they deliver my catering orders(for a nominal fee), the order is always correct! Never underestimate how important that is! When it comes to Italian specialties, I can’t find any other Pizza place in the area that even comes close. So many options! Their dish prices are very reasonable and the staff is just so nice. You can’t help but smile as you interact with them. But it’s the delicious food that has me going back so often. Give it a shot, you won’t regret it.
Jason C.
Classificação do local: 5 Farmingville, NY
OK, I’m trying to think of a way to put the wonder that is Paulys into words. This place is so indescribably good, I can only say that if the coolest guy around, me, felt like pizza, which I usually do, I make the trek to Paulys. They have SEVERAL different kinds of house pies, and even more if you opt for take out or delivery. The pasta, heros, and other Italian specialties are amazing. Everyone inside is friendly, service is always prompt and more importantly, CORRECT. Never had an order messed up here. This place has put other area pizza places out of business. Literally. Go try it. You won’t be disappointed. Oh, and try the lunch specials. TON of food, plus a salad an soda, for very cheap — 6 or 7 bucks.