Three Guys And A Grill

Stopped for dinner on the way to our weekend destination. My boyfriend had the Reuben with fries — I don’t like Reuben anything but I thought it was pretty good! (I always steal a bite). I had the broasted chicken with a baked potato and a side salad.
The baked potato seemed to be a big deal. My first choice is always mashed potatoes, but they didn’t have them. Second choice is a baked potato (because I can turn it into a mashed potato.) I was told like three times that it was an option, and I could have it but it takes a long time and they basically don’t like to do it. The guy dishing up the food was visibly out of sorts about it.
Overall the food was good, the service alright. We would go back, but it wasn’t anything that blew us out of the water.

We’d rate this somewhere in the range of 3 – 4. We stopped in for lunch while we were exploring the area. The restaurant was very clean and friendly for an out-​of-​the way location. Lunch sandwiches were solid — nothing fancy. Broasted chicken was tasty. Service a little slow during the lunch rush.

This place is great if you are camping here. The food is pretty average, but it’s so convenient and the people are nice. Looking forward to returning.

After Lolas on the lake bungled our reservation we were looking for something good and tasty and found it here at Three Guys and a Grill
This is a very casual but good restaurant/​bar that is in a recreation area a couple of miles out of downtown Elkhart lake. Their meat is pretty high quality from Miesfields in Sheboygan. My wife and I each had the large T-​bone and it was a thinner but very tasty steak. The subtle accent the wood fired grill added with a well seasoned steak made this meal.
The warm potato salad was a really good side as were the fries. Lots of interesting choices on the menu.

Have been here twice and we really like the place. We usually get burgers or fried fish. Menu has a lot of good selections and the prices are reasonable. After we eat, the kids love climbing the nearby lookout tower.

As described on their website, this supper club is in the Marsh Park area and specializes in grilled hardwood charcoal cooking.
Here is a short summary of what you need to know… Surprisingly good food (and good prices) for an «off the beaten trail» location. Try anything (and everything!) that is grilled!!!
And here are a few more details of my experience…
Today, for lunch, my wife had a grilled beef tenderloin steak sandwich and I had a grilled prime rib sandwich. Both of them were exceptional, but I plan to order the tenderloin steak sandwich next time! Seriously, the flavor was wonderful. So was the texture. Her meat must have been marinated before it was grilled; spices, even with special grilling, could not have accomplished this!
Hey! Have you ever had grilled alligator meat? I hadn’t. Until today, that is. We ordered an $ 8 appetizer plate of conveniently-​sized pieces that would have been plenty for four people. It came with a special sauce that was a perfect accompaniment. We probably won’t ever order alligator meat again, but the appetizer was prepared very well and we are glad that we experienced it!
When you have finished eating and are leaving the restaurant, consider crossing the road and climbing the stairs of the Sheboygan County Marsh Tower, the tallest wooden observation tower in Wisconsin.