Vinnies Mulberry Street Pizzeria

Simply the best… everything is unbelievable… The service is incredible and the dishes are exquisite … This rivals the best Italian from Arthur Ave.

Standard Italian fare. Really great service. The restaurant is split in half where the front of the house is the restaurant and the back was the pizzeria. The front restaurant was very loud and hard to hear. Nicely decorated and very clean.
Complimentary bread and pizza-​bread when you are first seated. Odd flow as the dinner salad is served before appetizers. So you order a salad before you even know what you want. What if you want a salad as an entrée? Do you eat two salads? Lol. The salad was a little watery and the blue cheese dressing was very bland. It was odd that it had chunks of blue cheese that tasted like nothing.
Tomato mozzarella app was really yummy with the balsamic sauce as was the clams casino… Although they were sooo tiny but packed full of flavor. The entrees were huge and came out nice and hot.

Food is decent but kinda expensive for pizza. A large cheese pie and cheese bread was $ 30.00.

I love this restaurant, but I’m fucking drunk and I ordered tartufo to-​go, but they gave us 2 cannolis instead. FML! I’m pissed. Didn’t find out until I came home.

This restaurant has the worst reservation skills! I called 3 weeks before valentines day and they said they weren’t taking any. I called a week before and i made my reservation for valentines day at which i made it for 6. I call today (valentines day) to confirm my reservation and supposedly im not on the list. After speaking with Vinny who is the rudest man told me he could not accommodate and that i was pretty much shit out of luck! now i have to scramble to find something because of a poor reservation system or no reservation system, maybe they should get open table. Sad to say i love their food but this service turns me off ill be sure to spread the word.

Not bad but nothing special. I had the chicken portabello. Lots of cheese and oil. Chicken was tasty and nicely cooked. Not a lot of veggies despite the menu’s description. It came with pasta. I ordered angel hair, they gave me regular spaghetti… Next time i’ll just get a salad and some slices. Their pizza looked stellar.

My Birthday dinner was delicious. Starting with the host to the server and including the busboy. Mom, dad & Val. had veal. I had a cheese tortellini with vegetables. We all had salad, bread mmm… mmm… a caprese salad and also the meat eaters shared calamari that they said was cooked perfectly. Dessert was decedent… 7 layer Choc. cake, a made to order Cannoli and New York cheesecake. OMG :-)
The next nite we had veggie pizza which was fantastic as we watched Thursday nite football.
I’ve dribbled on enough.

Came for a quick Saturday night dinner.
Mulberry is a step above your local pizza place and a step below a fine-​dining destination. Good for families with children looking for a nice meal at a reasonable price.
Entrees are very large and salads are complimentary. I tried their unconstructed lasagna which could have been a best ever. Just terrific.
Other people at my table of 4 were also pleased. We tried chicken, seafood, and pasta dishes — all winners.
If it weren’t for the stale tasting Italian bread served with our meal Mulberry St. would have reached 5 star status. Tough to do in this ultra competitive category.

Got the gnocchi and shrimp risotto to go.
Both were delicious. Wish they gave a bit more bread with the entrees.

If you’re in Long Island this has to be one of the best Italian restaurants in the area. When you walk in, you enter the bar section but to the left is a relaxing dining area with mood lighting and a modern design. The service was attentive, knowledgable and quick. I ordered Chicken & Eggplant Marsala, with a side of spaghetti bolognese which had some of the best sauce I’ve ever had on a pasta. The Marsala sauce was also the perfect amount of sweet to add to the flavor the the chicken, which paired nicely with the eggplant. As a desert my girlfriend and I shared a Tartufo which was very easy to share (my family actually shared it between 5 people) and it had to be one of my top 3 favorite ice cream dishes, topped with whipped cream and a drizzle of raspberry sauced underneath. The food wasn’t too expensive (about 17.00 a meal) and there is certainly enough food for you to be full mid-​meal that you’ll want to bring it home to have the next day.

This place is delicious! Good sized menu with awesome sandwiches, pizza, pasta, and garlic knots that I can’t shove in my mouth fast enough. Nice bar and dining area with a separate counter for take out orders.

I usually don’t write reviews but I have to do it this time. I popped in there for a slice and a drink while in the neighbourhood. This slice (plain no toppings) was one of the best slices I have had in years. Starting with the crust. Perfectly crisp not overly cooked not soggy. Added bonus none of the cornmeal that I have been seeing these last few years all over the place. The sauce not overly sweet and just the right amount of acidity. The cheese not stingy not overly placed. Quite frankly I live no where near here and whenever I am in Suffolk and want a slice I have a place to go to and get one. Bravo.

I went last night to celebrate my birthday with a friend and thought about their baked shell pasta with sliced sausage and ala vodka sauce all day at work! What a high calorie splurge that was well worth it! My friend felt that her shrimp parmigiana tasted «funny» and called over the manager/​maître D/​owner? and he was extremely accommodating and handled it with humor! Great personality! The atmosphere in the dining room is very professional and comfortable. I feel the pricing is extremely reasonable for the quality of food you receive — would highly recommend to anyone.

GREAT pizza! Won’t order from anywhere else in the neighborhood.
The dining room menu is delicious too! This place is always busy :)

Went Wednesday evening at 6 and it was very busy. Food was delicious and plentiful.
We had Lasagna; perfect; a special of boneless short ribs with Rigatoni that was fantastic and a Pappardelle Bolognese, also delicious with fresh pappardelle and tons of meat, however, as delicious as it was it was NOT Bolognese. It was simply, meat sauce and I have to say that I really resent them not making this dish properly since its not that complicated. Just add the darn cream, carrots and a bit of celery and it would have been correct and what I expected. When I jokingly brought this to the attention of the manager as she was asking my friend if she wanted cream for her coffee; «Oh so you have cream», I said «so why isn’t it in the Bolognese as it should have been?»; her answer really bothered me more then the missing ingredients. «Oh the Chef used to make it that way but patrons complained» About what? If they didn’t want the cream they could order Meat Sauce, NO”? You ruin a recipe for a few complainers and I don’t really believe her anyway. As I said to her, If you ordered a steak and they brought you the most delicious pork chop, would that be acceptable?
Also, despite the owner standing in the foyer, my water glass was not filled the entire meal. Tasty Focaccia in the bread basket and a nice salad came with the entrée.
I will definitely go back. (not for their ‘Bolognese ‘though. lol)

Awesome italian food! Been following them since there days in islip terrace… pizza is always spot on! Never a disappointment and plenty to choose from. The restaurant is small so get there early… enjoy!

Typical Mulberry Street, predictable menu and that is not a bad thing at all. I’ve eaten there several times with family and couples and my Uncle Enzo from Bensonhurst rides all the way out here on a Vespa to eat here. He loves the garlic knots, hey what can I say!
The wait staff is usually very good, and attentive. I have never had a problem there.
Pizza is very good, whenever we have parties we order all pizza from here. You may pay a little more but for me and my family we don’t mind.
Hope this helps

Ok here it is. I eat here often the food is good and consistent the pizza is very good I like the broccoli Rabe & sausage pizza. The place is very clean. Here’s what annoys me many times I come here and the dining room is closed in the middle of the day. Also the waitresses are pretty good some have unhappy unfriendly personalities. Bus boys are good. The hostesses always make you feel a little uncomfortable and not welcome as if you are bothering them. Very strange for the hospitality industry. It’s tolerable because of the food. Would have given more stars if it wasn’t for that. And it happens often. Been here about 50 times or more.

Nice ppl nice place. Wine list needs some adjustments to match the food broccoli rave n sausage was in an excellent broth. Meatballs were tasty. Would like the chicken parm pounded thinner, but tasty.

You can always count on Mulberry street for some good old fashion Italian food.
I love to get spaghetti and meatballs here!
Nothing is as good as Mom’s but their meatballs are delic!