Jersey Mike’s Subs

I ordered a regular Club Supreme on wheat: quality roast beef, turkey, swiss, tomato, shredded lettuce, sliced onions, oil & vinegar. While my sub tasted fresh and well-​constructed, the portion size for a regular was a bit disappointing: the regular size is a 7 – 9 inch half-​roll which runs $ 6.60 to $ 8.80 (post tax) depending on the type of sandwich. Online ordering advertises «regular» as enough for 1 — 2 people, but my regular-​sized sub was only 60% filling for me: more of a large snack than a full meal. Subway and Wawa offer full 10-​inch sandwiches at the same price point that Jersey Mike’s charges for a premium «mini”-sized sub. Compared to local competitors, Jersey Mike’s comes out ahead in quality but not in quantity.
The main dining area features two upholstered booths, four bar-​height tables, a mounted flat-​screen TV, and shore-​themed print art, which can also be found in the two single-​occupancy restrooms.

Good cheese steak and good cold subs. Need to watch who is chopping the cooking cheese steak. Sometimes they don’t chop philly style and get a bit lazy. A good Italian deli can beat this sub hands down but if your looking for a decent NJ sub, hoagie etc. this is a good place to start.

Really great and tasty subs better than subway! U can choose your own or take one of their choices which all also look very good just wish i didnt choose to put oil and vinegar on my sandwhich it made it soggy they probably put too much

Best Sub around. With places like wawa, subway and Riddle and Martin all in competition, you can’t beat it

Subs are ON-​point!!! It will be a difficult task to stay away from here. I know there are tons of sandwich places popping up by this place has the GOODS mastered. I’ll follow up soon as I try different subs.

Best sub I’ve had in a long time. Cold cuts are delicious and so is the bread. Pretty expensive but worth it once in a while :-)

Great bread meats oil and vinegar mix and it’s easy on a major road lots of people pass by home from work it tastes great and I like the people that work there it’s just a little expensive

Great chicken cheesesteak and hoagies overall. oil and vinegar mix taste great and not salty like other places. Really pricey considering the limited amount of meat they place on the subs. Considering the nearest Primo’s is a hike for me, Mike’s still does a nice job satisfying the random once in a blue moon hoagie cravings.

I’m originally from the area. When visiting, it’s great to have a Jersey style Italian sub. This place does a fantastic job. Fast friendly service and the subs taste great.
I have to say though, the marketing of «Mike’s Way» (adding lettuce, tomato, onion, salt, pepper, oil and vinegar) is smart but obnoxious. It’s a common combo request at any sub shop, so hearing one shop market it as their own invention or something is odd to me.

I drop by every so often on the way home from work. Always find the place to be bright and clean. The staff has been uniformly friendly. The subs are impeccably made. You really get the feeling these folks care about what they do. It’s a weird location – a hard right off the highway – but definitely worth going out of your way.

Great service and amazing subs. The best roast beef ever! I recommend the #9 it’s my favorite.

I tried this place twice now, ordering different subs, this place has a very delicious subs. The seating area is okay and staff are nice. I would definitely come back. My only complain is price; I find it a bit pricy.

I really liked it! Food was good and fresh, I got the club sub. I would say it costs a little bit more than competitors but not so much it broke my wallet. I would definitely come back

Om nom nom nom. Huge subs. Lots of meat. Get the cherry pepper relish. Eat it with a spoon.

I give them a 4 star because their food is fresh, the environment is clean, the store has parking, the food portion is a good amount of size .
But they lost one star for pricing. There’s not one time I eat here and not spend less than 15 bucks for 1 person. They need to work on their prices. I go to a competitive sub shop in South River that offers more meat/​cheese in the sandwich for less than what this place charges me.
Overall I recommend them but don’t be surprised when you see the bill.

Was in the area and needed to pick something quick for lunch. This place was big, clean and the staff were nothing but nice, they even mentioned that my brake light was out. The sandwich was stackkedd. I ordered a mini Turkey and provolone and it was fresh and more than enough for a lunch meal. I was impressed and I’m only upset that I’ve drive past this place so many times without stopping in.

Great subs — my favorite is the #13 Italian sub with lots of vinegar.

There are so many good sub shops in New Jersey that the bar is set super-​high. In many other places, Jersey Mike’s would likely be a 5-​star sub shop. But up against local non-​chain heavyweights like Riddle & Martin and Carluccio’s, it’s hard to see Jersey Mike’s as anything more than an upscale Subway.
Let me be clear, though, Jersey Mike’s is very good and I would never have a problem eating a sub here if that was my only option. But having never been to one before and then hearing all the hype when they moved into town, I had to finally try it. So in my wife and I went for lunch.
As much as I’m trying to be good and stick to my Vegan/​vegetarian thing, there is only one sub in my mind for which to judge all sub shops: the Italian sub. That means, at minimum, salami and pepperoni in my book.
Although the shop was virtually empty when we arrived, the dude in front of us pulled out a sheet of paper and ordered what seemed like 1,000 subs for everyone back at his office. I wanted to cry. We were starving. And we now knew it was going to take awhile to get our subs. (About 15 minutes to be exact.)
The bread at Jersey Mike’s is good. It’s the right combination of crunchy on the outside, but light and fluffy on the inside. This means it can hold up under lots of stuffing and dressing, but doesn’t dominate the sandwich or hurt your mouth when you bite in. The whole wheat option was appreciated.
My sub was dressed nicely with lettuce, tomato, white onion, jalapeños, oil, vinegar, salt, pepper, oregano, and a schmear of mayo. The bread formed a U-​shaped crater that held everything in really nicely. My only complaint was that for all of these ingredients, it tasted like Subway. There was nothing standout from a flavor perspective, especially the cold cuts. Good, name brand, quality salami and pepperoni from the right place is going to really stand out. This is a reminder that you are eating in a chain restaurant, much like when I pass Jersey Mike’s when I am working in Fort Worth, Texas.
But as far as mass produced subs go, Jersey Mikes is A-​OK. I still prefer Jimmy John’s if I’m going to do the chain thing, but the differences are slight. I just can’t see any reason why I would eat here when I get can get the real deal not too far away.

Their subs here are not stingy at all. They pile on the meat and toppings just like an old school deli shop would. Nothing like a subway where you only get two-​three thin slices of meat.
Ordered the Chipotle Cheesesteak and the Club Supreme. Had to wait for the hot sandwich to be made but that wasn’t long. The sizes are very reasonable since they give you so much in the sub. The cheesesteak was beyond delicious. It had so much cheese oh my gosh. It was super flavorful as well. I have to get another one soon! The club supreme was good. I didn’t get to try it but it looked delicious.
Prices are reasonable too. I didn’t understand the fact that the card machine asks for a tip when you swipe. It’s a fast food type place, so it surprised me. I mean it’s not wrong to ask.
Stop by if you’re in the area.

Any of my Unilocal followers know that I love me some Jersey Mike’s. This newer location (opened in June) has excellent visibility along 18 although the co-​tenancy in the shopping center leaves a little to be desired.
As usual, my sandwich was on point made exactly the way I wanted in spite of multiple customizations and delicious. The service was cheerful, friendly, and helpful.
However, Jersey Mike’s lost a star because, even though it was off peak (4pm), I was the only one in the store, and there were 4 people behind the counter, every table in the restaurant was dirty. I asked for my table to be wiped and the attendant came out with what appeared to be a dry towel and no sanitizer. I then discovered that my table had no napkins. No effort was made to refill the napkins or sanitize the other tables which were also dirty
Go for the sandwiches, but you may want to get your order to go.