Anthony’s Eatalian

Chicken parm you taste so good.
And so does the calamari.
This place is a little on the slow side, which kind of makes me think it could be family run and they don’t have a chef with a lot of experience and a sense of urgency. But the food is good. I’ve never dined in. I always get their food to go. And I hope they survive because I would like to keep eating their take out. It’s probably the best Italian food in the immediate area. And by «immediate area,» I mean the area between 35 and the tollway and 635 and NW Highway.

Stopped by to have lunch. First time there and absolutely loved it. I was skeptical at first because of no other customers in there. But man oh man. the pizza slices were a great size and delicious! No doubts I will be back!

I think they have been there more than a year but I just noticed it about three months ago and have been there four or five times over the last three months. I had their vodka flavored pasta dish and it was fine though nothing to write home about. What I have ordered several times is the 20 inch Tony’s special pizza. It is huge and with lots of meats and veggies. Plenty left over to take home. Three of the four times I ordered it it was excellent with slightly crispy crust and lots of toppings. The most recent order, which was for pickup, was noticeably undercooked. I’m glad it was a pickup order since I could stick it in the oven and turn the limp crust into something that was hot and crispy. I admit I always add oregano, crushed red pepper and Parmesan cheese to give it a flavor bump. Be sure to ask for those little packets if it is a take-​out order. On the occasions I ate in the store, the service was fine — reasonably attentive and pleasant. It’s a fairly small place — perhaps 10 tables — so it isn’t too hard to get the attention of the staff when needed. Since this place is convenient to where I live and I have not had the service or quality problems other reviewers report, I’m sure to go back.

The place looks cute enough. However, I can’t decide which was worse, the food or the service. When we expressed our concerns to the staff, there were no attempts to provide any type of customer service. There is no good reason to come to this restaurant with so many great Italian places around.

Bummed. Called to order two Large pizzas for pickup. Was told it would be 15 minutes. I show up and they have two slices in a box for me. Because they misheard me over the phone. And it’s too late for them to fix the order. I am certain that I will NEVER waste my time or money here again.

My staff and I ate lunch there at least 3 times. 1^st time was an awful experience with a waiter– very slow and just did not need to be waiting on people. Not a people person. Food is very good and their lunch specials are great price. Reason for 3 stars is one of my staff members found hair in their food two times. The first time they gave her meal for free. The second time the manager was out and the waitress just asked her if she wanted another one. Of course she wants another one — but one without the hair. Then she gave her the bill for the full amount and nothing off. I asked to speak to the manager and she said she was not there and then I explained I used to work in the food services and its customary when you find something in your food to just go ahead and take that off the receipt. She then explained she has never done that and does not have the authority to do this. Finally I asked for her to call the manager and then she said «thats fine, I will take it off» like she was doing me a favor. I was just shocked. I really like the food (slow to get your food but good) but the staff is just awful. The waitress spilled salad dressing all over me and the floor and didnt even clean it up– just went to go do something else while I cleaned it up and off myself. She didn’t even apologize.
If you want food– grab it to go– pizza and salads are great! also the fettuccine Alfredo was pretty good.
hope you have a better experience than us!

Have eaten here twice and unfortunately it may be my last. We ordered baked ziti and also spaghetti and meatballs. Relatively slow, pleasant but inattentive service. The Ziti arrived Luke warm, not what you usually get with baked ziti. I asked them to heat it up for me and they took it away, sprinkled more cheese on the top and melted the cheese but it returned as Cold or colder than before. When the waitress said she would tell the manager, no one returned to offer to heat it more or to even discuss it with me. The check was simply placed on our table. This tells me the manager was wishing me good riddance. Too bad. Consistency is so important for a restaurant and not addressing customer issues is starting to impacting this place.

Just so yummy!!! Pizza was great. Good prices. Nice neighborhood spot. Hope they stick around.

Placed an order for delivery a couple nights a go and service was ON POINT!!! The woman who took my order was fast, efficient, and let me know about a special they had that was similar to the order I placed. Delivery guy was great, too; no more fumbling for the pizza box! So happy!!!

Enjoyed our dinner here very much. Came for the first time tonight after my 4 yr olds soccer practice; pizza wasn’t as crispy as I like my pizza, but my little loved it and I really enjoyed my dinner salad and chicken primavera pasta. Fresh and clean place and really good service. Definitely a great addition to the neighborhood and deserves a try!

Decide for yourself.
— Ordered Eggplant Parmesan. Wife ordered Philly Steak Sandwich
— Received Beef Lasagna. Table next to us got the eggplant. The server quickly realized the mistake, and went running to the kitchen to try to make it right.
40 minutes later, still no Eggplant, wife finished eating a long time ago, and the table next to us happily eating their corrected meal.
— Asked for the check and a to-​go box for the eggplant, it still was not there. 10 minutes later explained to the server that unfortunately I could not provide any gratuity. I cannot pay extra for that. Told her the kitchen had cost her tip.
Owner/​Manager looked at me and said «have a nice day». I told her simply I would be providing my review on Unilocal.She did comp the eggplant meal. I paid the remainder of the bill, with no gratuity, and left professionally. There was no scene from the Anthony’s or from me.
I will not go back under any circumstances, and recommend that everyone else go to the other Italian restaurant that is close by instead.
Good luck to this place, in this neighborhood you will need it.

Really nice place. Clean. Friendly. Cold beer. Their pizza is the best. The service is excellent. Our waitress was super sweet.

My friend and I came here for dinner Saturday afternoon after reading all the great reviews. I will have to suppose that their stellar reviews come from their pizza, because our pasta dishes were subpar. I had the salmon primavera and the fish was over-​cooked and the sauce has no flavor. My friend’s chicken Francese also had over-​cooked. However, the salad greens were very fresh and the roll was tasty!
On another note, the waitress was very sweet and helpful. If we ever come again, we hope to have a better experience.

This is a new restaurants in our neighborhood and we tried it and thought it was great!
I had a house salad with the house dressing and I loved their dressing and a really fresh salad, we shared some fried zucchini which was REALLLY GOOD and I had the calzone.
The calzone was really good except it was cold in the center for some reason. The waitress asked how our food was and I told her and she promptly took it away and said she was take care of it for me. It came back 10 minutes later piping hot and perfection. I could only eat half of it so I took the rest home.
The wait staff was exceptionally friendly and accommodating and welcoming. My only real complaint is that their AC was one of those roll around units that you pipe out the ceiling or window rather than true centra AC and I was pretty humid in their considering the heat outside. Maybe their AC was temporarily broken I don’t know but I was very hot in there.
Overall well priced and good service and really good Italian food! We’ll be going back!

The pizza was wonderful. The ‘Eatalian’ is still young and hiring a fun waitstaff. Eager to try other menu items as the pizza set the foundation for a return visit. The atmosphere is pleasant, clean, with pop background music and sports on the mounted TV screens. Lunch and carry out specials are reasonable.

My husband and I love Italian food and we figured well let’s give this new place a try we were a bit hesitant at first since it’s a small restaurant and from the outside it gives you more of a bar type feel even when you walk in looks more like a place that serves burgers … (so I didn’t think it was going to be great) It was empty when we got there but not long after they started getting busy but let me tell you I was wrong. The service was awesome and the food was very delicious we got the chicken Alfredo and the lasagna not what I expected at all even the presentation of the food very nice. We will definitely be coming back to visit.

Great atmosphere, fantastic wait staff, I had a calzone and it was authentic Italian, which is hard to find in Dallas!
Definitely my new hangout!

The food was very good and of large proportion. They have been only open for 4 weeks and to me the service was good. Just got to keep in mind it’s a new place and the waitstaff is still learning. It is a nice place to go and hang out for a bit. If you’re in a rush it’s not the best place to be. So I recommend you go when you have time to enjoy great food and talk with some of your friends. I will be back for sure.

Really great pizza close to home. Huge slices, good cheese and good sauce! The large pizza was a good size for three smallish people
The Italian ice was really good — we got lemon and cherry. Go with the lemon for something refreshing with just the right amount of sweet.
The place was fairly empty — so not sure how a busy night would be — but we had great service! Really attentive and helpful

Disclosure– This review is based on FOOD only.
We ordered a pizza for delivery after hearing some good reviews on
. So we had no experience with service, which sounds line it may be a huge issue. However I will add that it took almost an hour to get our pizza, and we only live about two blocks away from the restaurant. So order ahead of your hunger pains! Anyways, the pizza itself was great! We ordered the meaty pie. Great flavor. The only complaint was that the meatball pieces seemed a little bit overkill. They were big, and kind of took away from the flavor of the rest of the pizza. I got one bite that was a bit saucey, and the sauce was very good. We’ll be ordering from them again, but I think we’ll stick to delivery only until the service issues are straightened out!