JT’s Pizza & Pub

This is our third time coming here since they bought out the Bier Stube. We absolutely love it! The chicken bacon ranch pizza is phenomenal! Highly recommend the the ultimate garlic bread it was so delicious as well! The parking is limited on the weekend, but they do a complimentary valet to accommodate that. Just a basic pepperoni you can’t go wrong either. Tonight we are trying the Greg sauce wings, which is basically a combination of all kinds of wing sauce mixed together. Prices are good for what you get and the ambience is very low key. Definitely five stars!

Always been a fan of this roadside pub/​grill etc. great food and average service for the most part (exceptional service when you get the right individuals waiting on you) mediocre just lately. Great food… we have always been more than satisfied with the food here until last night. Don’t make the mistake of ordering the chef salad. The menu talks this up as a mixture of romaine and iceberg lettuces coupled with ham, turkey and a variety of cheeses. I would have been better off ordering a salad from Wendy’s! Not only did I pay almost $ 8 for this joke of a salad, but there was no romaine and extremely little ham, turkey or cheese; the ham and turkey were obviously thin sliced packaged products similar to what you find in the lunch meat isle of the grocery. Highly disappointed. JT’s needs to do it right or pull it from the menu.

Well done JT’s.
Wife loves the pizza and it’s super close to us so it’s become a favorite for those nights when whatever hunk of meat being defrosted doesn’t look too appetizing (or heaven forbid it’s a salad).
Have done the bar once and it was loud, but they do have trivia night on Wednesday which seemed fun if you are into that. And you can win stuff!
Overall we always get a consistent pizza here (pepperoni with a garlic parm crust) that is warm and tasty and we keep coming back.

Great food and atmosphere. Stopped by here on a Wednesday for trivia night and had a sandwhich with loaded fries and it was great ! Highly recommend.

Good pizza for thin crust lovers. One of the 4 places we like to order from. The sausage and mushroom is our favorite at JTs.

This place was great! I was stopping by for a party and had the pleasure of getting to experience JT’s pizza and Pub. The food was incredible. The wings and the pizza were both delicious. They had great drink specials even on a Friday! The bar is very classy for a sports bar. Lots of flat screens and it is very clean. Great bar for some drinks on a Friday, or some good pizza for any night. Looking forward to stopping in the next time i’m in town.

JT’s pizza is the best pizza I have had in a long time. They have the perfect blend of sauce and spices on their pizzas. Delivery was quick. Great

I’m confused. I counted on Unilocal to guide me to the perfect pizza… for this evening anyway. My 80+ mom suggested pizza for dinner, and I talked her out of national chain trash. She likes thin crust, so I went on Unilocal to find the best thin crust nearby. If you are reading this, you have, no doubt, seen the glowing reviews for JT’s. I’m shaking my head in wonder.
The service was perfect. The staff was friendly, attentive, and our soda glasses were never empty. They earned their tip and then some. They made us feel very welcome.
I was negligent in failing to take note of the fact that this was a sports bar. Neither of us have any interest in sports at all, so the multiple screens held no interest for us. The noise level was deafening. My mom and I had to shout at one another to be understood. I have tinnitus, and as I write this, my ears are ringing at twice the normal level from the din. Again, I failed to note the fact that this is a sports bar, so I offer this only in an advisory capacity, and not necessarily as criticism. My bad.
The only seating where our feet wouldn’t dangle in empty space was right next to a humongous screen displaying basketball, and just downwind from the unisex bathroom. I shut the door so I wouldn’t have to look at a commode while eating, and to keep the odor away. The door didn’t stay shut for long. Yuck!
Sadly, the pizza was horrible. Honestly, I have had better frozen pizza. It was bland, almost devoid of tomato sauce, and even though the menu said hand crafted, I suspect the crust came frozen in a box from some distant factory. If it was made on location, they need to work on the recipe. Honest to God, it tasted just like three dollar frozen pizza that I put some extra toppings on at home in an attempt to make it less boring. I can’t recall having less pleasing pizza in a restaurant.
I gives me no pleasure to offer this review. I am not a hard natured person. If bland uninspired pizza in a loud sports bar is what you seek, this is the place for you.

I order once a week at least. Especially when I have friends over I want to show off JTS pizza. I started joking around about them giving me a free t shirt and tonight they surprised me with one with my order (the one night I don’t give them crap about not bringing me a shirt). Honestly it’s not the shirt-it’s that the night I didn’t mention it-​they remembered who I was on a rough night and brought me some love. I don’t think I’ll ever get sick of them, but regardless-​this shows that they love their people. I am one happy customer!

I have never had a bad pizza from JT’s Pizza! Always hot and fresh. Plus everything I have tried so far has been super yummy. Pizza, wings, subs — ALL very GOOD!
They have become the first place I call for pizza.

A friend of mine ordered from JT’s at my insistence. The photos of the pizza looked incredible. He got a Big Al’s — the crust was perfect and the sauce was unique — maybe a little bit sweet? But the sausage was a bit sparse. If you’re a sausage fan definitely request extra. The star of tonight’s show? The jalapeño poppers! Cream cheese filled, crunchy, and deliciously hot. Food was delivered in the allotted time and all came hot, and ordering online was very easy. Would definitely recommend trying the pizza — and might swing by for a burger and what look like really decent happy hour specials next time I’m in Columbus!

I’ve been working my way through the menu for a few years now, and have yet to be disappointed, even a little. Ingredients, freshness, variety, flavor and customer service have all been superb!
Pizza is unique, burgers are delicious, sandwiches are crammed with flavor, (especially the Whoppo,)
wings are my favorite anywhere, and the calzones are blue ribbon! The salads, and the fries are fresh and plentiful.
Since I introduced them, my fellow employees order from there at least once a week, and when family is in town they ask which night we’re going!
Now that the brains of the restaurant has taken over the attached bar, formerly Bier Stube North, the building is experiencing a makeover and facelift. It’s always been great food, and now it will be a great place!
Tim Court
Columbus

JT’s is a great bar experience with good food, friendly people, and good atmosphere.
The food is your basic bar food; wings, burgers, fries. But go for the pizza. It’s dynamite. Waffle fries are another favorite. If you want to have wings then I recommend the «Greg’s sauce.» I don’t know what’s in it but it’s really good. On top of that, their entire menu is available for delivery.
The bartenders know how to have fun and will happily hand over the shot ski to you and your friends to help you over the hump. There are a lot of events that JT’S hosts, like after kick ball parties, so they keep the place pretty busy.
Finally, this bar is a destination in the warm weather months. They have a large outdoor seating area complete with corn hole boards and a long cement bar for the biggest games of flipcup ever. Indoors has a lot of TV’s and they are happy to turn on whatever game is happening. Don’t be «that guy» and turn off the Buckeye game.
Five stars because it is what I think of when I think of a bar.

I love JT’s! I work nearby, so it’s the usual go-​to when we get pizza for the company, and everyone is always excited. The pizza is hot, fresh, and flavorful, not overly greasy, and they have a wide variety of toppings and crust flavors to choose from. I’ve only had the wings once or twice, but they were superb. Keep up the awesomeness, guys!

I love the meatball sandwich. It’s like a meatball sub made with garlic bread. I haven’t had a bad meal at this place.

JT JT JT!
I was staying at a hotel over in Dublin and they wouldn’t deliver that far so I made the decision to pick up my pizza. The pizza is thin style and it was good. They had a check-​in special but I didn’t realize until I left. I would recommend this place.
They should have some type of promotion in relation to the performance of JT Barrett. I wonder if JT has ever had JT’s pizza.

This is the best pizza ever!!! I’ve been ordering here since I moved into the neighborhood 10 months ago. Always fresh vegetables and meats. The wings are outstanding as well. I haven’t tried their sandwiches yet but something tells me I wouldn’t be disappointed.
I highly recommend JT’s pizza to anyone who craves a true authentic well made pizza!

JT’s Pizza is a great little shop along a fast-​changing strip of 161 between Worthington and Dublin. They’re always energetic and friendly no matter how busy they are — they’ve always been busy when I’ve stopped in. This time I even got to try their food — I usually pick up pizza for people who are meeting nearby. They do have delivery as well as pickup — no inside seating here, but you can likely head to Bier Stube North next door to enjoy your food nearby.
Their pizza is solid, with a fresh crust, good sauce, and the right amount of toppings and cheese — Crispy on the bottom, chewy in the middle. Just right. Since I’m in the area often, I’ll be adding JT’s to our take-​home repertoire.

After reading the reviews and seeing all the photos of food that looked delicious, I decided to try this place. I ordered two pizzas and 6 wings for a friend and myself on Saturday night. My friend had a meat lovers and I had chicken and cheese. We split the 6 parmesan wings. After driving 10 minutes to JTs and 10 minutes back, we settled in to watch a movie and eat. Well, the movie was good, JTs, not so much. Both of the pizzas were dry, over cooked and the crust was waaayyy too hard. The meat lovers was kinda dark on top and the toppings were all dried and crunchy. The chicken pizza had one tiny piece of chicken on each slice of pizza, but you couldn’t tell because it was too dried out to notice. Both pizzas had very little sauce and most of that was dried up around the edges. When we bit into the crust, it tasted like we were eating a hard pretzel.
The wings were not very well covered in flavor. In fact, they were mostly fried with a spritz of sauce to glaze them. Oh, but wait… there was a TON of sauce sitting in the corner of the container. Maybe we were supposed to dip the wings in that! I don’t know if they were slacking because it was so late in the evening, or they just didn’t care. It wasn’t worth calling about it since we won’t be going there again. Oh yeah, I almost forgot, the one star is for the free 2 liter that I got for using Unilocal to check in. JTs gets zero.

JT’s offers a plethora of pizza choices — with multiple sauce and crust flavor selections. The options left me like a deer in the headlights. Do I do the basic pep and shroom or add some flare? Being a huge fan of spicy sauces, I inquired about that option. I was told it was the basic tomato sauce mixed with a hot sauce. Sounds yummy to me, so I went with that option and the garlic parmesan crust option as well.
Well, I guess I had invisioned mixing in more of a tabasco sauce (something that wouldn’t interfere too much with the tomatoey tasty goodness). Instead, the hot sauce turned out to be buffalo-​style sauce. Well, that just made for a bad combo.
Bad combo aside, the other toppings were great. The shrooms were fresh and thinly sliced. The peps were also very decent. The sauce ruined my taste buds, so the garlic parmesan crust didn’t really shine through the way I had hoped. The pizza was also a bit overcooked (very brown crust…very crispy.…very thin).
At the end of the day, my pizza was probably a 2 star, but I’ll chalk the sauce selection up to user error on my part. Put a regular sauce on there and take it out of the oven a minute earlier and we could be talking 4 stars with these great toppings. Hopefully I’ll get the chance to revisit, as I really do like all the options JT’s offers.