Tasty Pizza

This place is way over priced for what they charge there. They charged us 21.50 for a 12 inch 2 topping pizza. Save your money and go somewhere less expensive and better than them.

Was told this pizza was the same as old Musarras Tasty Pizza in Garfield Hts. Not even close, what a disappointment. Could not get waited on by lone employee, my son finally brought home what he thought would be a treat. What we got was a burned, dry, sauce less pizza with a hard tough crust. Tasty? Not even close

My favorite Pizza in Cleveland! I have been going to this place since I have been little! I always get spinach and onion pizza and the salad. If I am feeling really wild I get the fried mac and cheese bites. Also, it is always fun eating there and picking out a pop from the huge cooler with so much to choose from!

I called to order and the guy who answered gave me an attitude and was rude and hung up on me when I had to cancel my order because he said his delivery driver couldn’t drive to my house which is only a few minutes away. I have ordered from here before and they were able to deliver to my house.

Tasty Pizza is a throwback that’s for sure. Even though they’re a throwback, still also offer gluten free pizza. You walk in and order at the counter, grab your drinks from the coolers and then have a seat in the dining room. If you ordered anything other than pizza and drinks, a person come around to give you the extras but you’ll have to flag them down.

Tasty’s has been around forever! I’ve been going my entire life. The laid-​back atmosphere and help yourself fridge of beverages brings back great memories of a mom and pop shop.
I highly recommend the salad and hot Italian sub.
This is always on my list of places I must go to when I am back in town visiting!

Called the delivery line and managed to get a high school drop out that didn’t understand anything. Had to keep asking someone if they could deliver etc. When they found out I was not calling from a residence they informed me that they couldn’t deliver. I found that strange since the website said that they delivered to Beachwood. Customer service doesn’t seem to be important to these folks.

Great old school pizza shop. With a really good selection of beer. Everyone is friendly and the place is very kid friendly you don’t have to worry about your kids being themselves and or quite.

This locally owned pizza place makes you feel at home. The pizza is down right great. Owner always there with a smile and a how are you today. If you have not stopped by you better soon. Why would you stop at a chain when you have a great local pizza place that makes all dough and sauce from scratch. Stop on and say hi to your next home away from home.

I ducked in here to grab a pizza when visiting a friend who lives in Lyndhurst. I loved it!
It’s like going back in time at Tasty Pizza, and that’s what I liked about it. This is a classic, «old-​school», neighborhood pizza place — good people, simple menu, quality ingredients, etc. Their selection of toppings is ample and thus has something for everyone. The price was a little on the high side, but that’s to be expected from a non-​chain like Tasty’s. Totally worth it!
The location is pretty low-​key, on the end in a nondescript strip mall, with limited parking. They have a surprising amount of space, though.
I went in on a Wednesday and they had my pizza done in about 20 minutes.
I’d go back.

Great local spot. delicious non chain pizza, with crushed red pepper shakers and Parmesan cheese on every table. grab your own beer and wine out of the cooler and drink as many you want without waiting for service. I know they’re probably counting but it still feels like the buddy system on how many you drank. something great about that. stare at the years of accumulated beer signs, iconic pictures and Cleveland sports posters and eat pizza and drink beer. great place. I offer the guy who owns the place money for his Wilt Chamberlain laying down and drinking colt 45 poster after about the 3^rd beer every time.

You either like the sauce… Or you don’t. I will come back to that in a second. I LOVE the old school setup of this place. Place your order at the counter, take a seat in the back, and your food is delivered to you. You are responsible for getting your own eating utensils and plates. Back to the food… Garlic bread with cheese is killer good. Did I mention how good the garlic bread is? Don’t you dare miss it. The pizza? Hard to describe the sauce as I think it is an acquired taste. It is thick and less garlicky and tomatoey and more oregano and basil than most places. Suburbia-​wise around here I think it is tough to beat the sauce at Tommy V’s. Crust is very good on its own. Underneath the sauce and toppings it gets lost taste– wise but on its own dddddaaaammmnnnn it is good.

Go on Mondays for the buy one get one free pasta. The Cavatelli with meatball is the belle of the ball. You get a side salad with some pretty legit Italian dressing (we take the extras home and put it in the fridge). Nothing fancy. No frills. Just about the best damn bargain I’ve found in the East side of Cleveland. Love this place.

Great local hangout and ambiance. The first impression is a place for families and friends. Lots of regulars on a Friday night. Small, cozy, with a fun self-​serve and honor system for cashing out. Fast service. The salad was a typical honeymoon style (lettuce alone — an old spouse joke) with lots of cheese and a pepper. The pizza is cheesy, a crunchy crust, slightly sweet, flaky. A bit doughy but that is typical I find for the Midwest. Toppings were plentiful. Very good. A place to go for a casual good pizza. I recommend highly. Say hi to joe!

I was on my way home from work and my wife wanted me to bring home a pizza. She asked me about this place and told her I have never ordered from Tasty’s before. I called placed the order for a large one topping pizza. When I got there the store looked a little dirty but I probably got there after the dinner rush so that wasn’t a huge deal. The reason I’m giving two stars is because the pizza was $ 16 !!! With all the pizza places around this has to be the most expensive place in the area. The pizza was decent but not worth the $ 16 price tag. There are much better local places for a pizza and you’ll pay way less. The owner needs to wake up and see what other places are charging.

It’s hard to review food when I never got a chance to eat. I went in starving and I left starving as the guy behind the counter spent 2 min. yelling to the back of restaurant about something that didn’t have anything to do with restaurant service. I stood there and he never acknowledged me once.

I must admit I love Tasty’s. A nice family run Pizza and then some restaurant. When
I saw they have artichokes I knew I would love it here and come back again and again.
Now they have whole wheat and even glutten free crust that is delicious and really
nutritious. May I please suggest Kalmata Olives they pair nicely with artichokes and
garlic white sauce and I’d be honored to order vegetarian and vegan cheese
options. All I can say is Yum Good work Tasty
All The Best,
Sandy

The pizza and sandwiches are fantastic!

Simple, cozy and delicious.
Their sausage, either on pizza or the baked subs, is something special. Pair that with their sauce that’s well balanced and seasoned and consistently baked crust — perfect.
Great informal dining experience if that’s what you like.
Best pizza for the money. Everything on the menu is great.

Compola’s Tasty Pizza is a Lyndhurst institution. A 50+ year staple of family, tradition and honor.
If you eat in, you tell Joe at the counter what type of pie you’ll be having. When it’s ready, he’ll bring it to your table. If you want a drink, help yourself to a cold one from the cooler. If you want a salad or soup, go through the saloon-​style swinging doors and back to the kitchen to tell Edith. She’ll serve you up right there. At the end of the night, tell Joe what you had throughout the night and he’ll ring you out. No checks or invoices are kept. It’s all done on an honor system. At Tasty, you’re a part of the family and this is one of the main reasons why it’s so comfortable to dine here.
Tasty Pizza is a rare kind of place. A throwback to a more trustworthy era; a simpler time when family gatherings around the dinner table and sharing good food was commonplace. Places like this make me proud to support the Mom & Pops over the competing chains.
Long live Tasty!