Abby Girl Sweets Cupcakery

I’m from out of town so I knew nothing about this store before I went in for my red velvet cupcake. All I can say is that I want to bring them home with me. It was probably the most delicious cupcake I’ve ever had. It was fresh and light. I normally push most of the icing off since it’s too heavy and sweet but not on this cupcake. It was light and fluffy and I ate every last bit. I might even get another today before I go back to Philly! A+++++++++

My boyfriend and I wanted to do gender reveal cupcakes and they agreed to do them.
The staff was so genuinely excited to do these for us and couldn’t wait to know details on when the reveal was going to take place.
Not only did they do a wonderful job making sure the secret was kept, but the cupcakes were beautiful and absolutely delicious. Our families could not get enough and I’m sure you guys gained a few more customers because of it!
Jerry and I really appreciate it!

Pretty good cupcakes were super moist brought a dozen to a baby shower i co-​hosted and they were a hit!

You absolutely MUST stop and try this cupcakery. We actually stumbled upon it trying to find another store and wanted to treat ourselves. I had heard of Abby Girl many times but had never been given the chance to try it.
We decided to «split one cupcake between the two of us,» which means we left with two for me and two for him. I opted for a New York cheesecake and a double trouble cupcake, my boyfriend got a peanut butter cup cupcake and a cookies and cream cupcake.
First of all, my cheesecake was absolutely mind blowing. Seriously some of the best that I’ve ever had and the fact that it’s able to be eaten without a fork makes it an A+ in my book. I haven’t tried to double trouble yet, but it was recommended by the cashier above all of the other cupcakes so I feel positive that it’s going to that I’m going to be satisfied.
My boyfriend already ate both of his and liked both of them so much that he was making borderline inappropriate noises. He says that Abby Girl are the cupcakes he’s ever had. And he went ahead and repeated this three or four times on the way, in case I didn’t hear him the first time.
As for me, I am INSANELY partial to The Bonbonerie as I want to take a dive into the opera cream … But Abby Girl probably ties with Bonbonerie. Seriously.
Go. If you happen to pass this shop or if you’re like me and will willingly drive forever away for a fanastic cupcake, go to Abby Girl.

I cannot begin to describe the AWESOME that is Abby Girl!!! There is no word for how delicious the Cupcakes are. I am utterly addicted. You MUST stop what you are doing, leave, and go straight to Abby Girl. If you do not, you will look back on this day as a complete waste, even if you are receiving a Noble Peace Prize at this exact moment. Have the Peanut Butter Cup, because it is like Baby Jesus made it from delicious pb and chocolate flavored rainbows. The cheesecakes, ohhhh the cheesecakes… I can’t tell you how creamy, sweet, amazing, wonderful, and incredible they are. I am literally eating one for lunch right now! I have never had the key lime, but the plain, and especially the cherry are to die for. Go, NOW, seriously.

You might think that a small cupcake shop in a slightly inaccessible suburban strip mall would be a bad idea. You might think it’d be deserted. You might think cupcakes are so over since the trend subsided years ago. You would be wrong.
Every time I go here there’s a constant flow of traffic. People gotta have their cupcakes, man. And they’re almost always out of my favorite kind, double trouble. Please make more double trouble.
And cheesecakes. Once again, when you think about cupcake-​sized cheese cakes you may be transported to memories of elementary school bake sales with tiny, dried out, canned cherry-​on-​top confections. But these scaled-​down cheesecakes are the real deal. Great texture, moisture content, flavor and darn it, I love the sour cream topping on the original flavor.
Abby Girl makes many flavors (perhaps too many. On my last visit there were 3 separate strawberry choices), but I’ve found the traditional varieties are the stand outs. Ingredients seem high-​quality and fresh. They’ve definitely proven that a well-​made treat doesn’t have to be a flash in the pan.

I am sitting here, licking leftover frosting from my fingers and humming Ode to Joy, I am so happy! For quite some time, cupcakes were so en vogue. Shops popped up all over the place, even in the heart of the midwest. However, most never seemed to get it quite right. Dry & crumbly (unacceptable if cupcakes are all you do!), crammed full of too much stuff or waaaay too much frosting. Sprinkles seemed to be the bar I held every shop to and most fell short. And as the «trend» waned, most of the shops shuttered. However, a few stuck it out and Abby Girl definitely rose from the rubble! These cupcakes are amazing!
I snagged a 4-​pack one Saturday: classic vanilla bean, cookies & cream, triple chocolate & strawberry with cream cheese frosting. The more simple vanilla bean & chocolate were intended for my niece and nephew who can be picky and my husband had gotten a bit of a different cake for his birthday at another bakery. Thankfully, the little ones actually ended up liking the birthday cake so that left all of the cupcakes for me! I ate the strawberry that evening, after everyone had left the party and grinned after my first bite. Nice balance between the perfectly flavored strawberry cake and the rich cream cheese frosting, wonderfully moist even several hours after pick-​up. The remaining 3 camped out in the fridge overnight since most of the frosting had cream cheese/​butter. This usually spells death for most cupcakes… they tend to dry out and need a generous amount of milk to go along with them. Not these… still perfectly moist the next day. Sprinkles is still my favorite, but this shop is a very, very close second and much, much closer. Granted, that may be a bad thing…

I’ve been a fan of Abby Girl Sweets Cupcakery for years, even before they opened this location. Unfortunately, I’ve moved out of town but I make sure to grab a box of cupcakes or two every time I visit Cincinnati. They’re easily rank as one of best cupcakes I’ve ever had, and trust me I’ve had plenty! Abby Girl’s cupcakes are light, moist, and original. It’s easy to tell that they use fresh ingredients to make their cupcakes. There’s always a huge variety to choose from and everyone visiting is bound to find something they like. However, their flavored change every day so if you want something specific be sure to check their Facebook page which is updated every morning. My personal favorite is the strawberry delight and I love how you can still see the strawberry seeds that was blended into the cupcake. I’ve grown up a little these past few years and lost most of my sweet tooth but I’ll never say no to one of Abby Girl’s cupcakes.
The only downside is that they try make just enough cupcakes in the morning to sell through the day so try to come during the earlier hours when everything’s still available!

The cupcakes here are truly delicious and unique.
But the favorite thing of mine at this restaurant is the cheesecakes.
It is truly the best cheesecake I ever had!
the cost is relatively affordable. $ 3.50 for a individual cheesecake

Seriously one of the best cupcakes that I have ever ate! I had the Reese cupcake and it was D-​E-​L-​I-​C-​I-​O-​U-​S! It was heaven in my mouth:) I will definitely be going back to try the Double Trouble and Red Velvet cupcakes.

Abby girl sweets is amazing! They have so many flavors to choose from and every single cupcake is delicious. My favorites are the Red Velvet, Golden Oreo, Sugar baby and the cheesecakes. If you are looking for a certain flavor you can always call ahead to make sure they aren’t sold out for the day. Abby girl sweets bakes fresh every day and you can certainly tell! I recommend going to the Blue Ash location 1. Because it’s easier to park. 2. The staff is much friendlier. Charity, works at blue ash and is always so helpful! She’s my girl! She greets you when you walk in and is so sweet! Plus she’s always so happy to see you!
Now the cupcakes are the best cupcakes I have ever had! I have been to DC cupcakes and these are so much better!
Get to Abby girl sweets today! You’re missing out.

Awesome cupcakes! Very cute and clean establishment also. We went to the Blue Ash location. Very friendly staff also. The cake was super moist and the icing was amazing! We will definitely visit here again on our next trip!

I came to Cincinnati for a family reunion this weekend and found Abby’s on Unilocal!I ordered a dozen assorted cupcakes and let the bakery choose which ones. That box was BEAUTIFUL! Every one was DELICIOUS!
I further commend the staff for putting up with my being late, letting my sister-​in-​law come pick them up at the very last minute, and having to take my calls and having to call me several times in the process!
Y’all did a FANTASTIC job!!!

These cupcakes are so ridiculous. I was with 8 other people, we got several flavors and everyone raved about each one. The strawberry cake is my favorite. This place blows other cupcake places out of the water.

Not a huge cupcake fan, never understood the craze, so my review comes from a place of unbiased opinion. These were SO tasty! What made these a step above the designer cupcakes I’ve had in the past was the light toppings. So many of the designer cupcakes are absolutely swimming in icing and toppings, making them too heavy. These were a great balance, with fresh tasting cake and fluffy icing. Highly recommend!

This gal has an inner fat kid that will never say no to a cupcake! No surprise that while in Cincinnati for work my sweet tooth kicked in. Thanks to Unilocal I discovered this cute little cupcakery very close to my hotel (dangerous!). After picking up dinner I made my way to this place. It is located in a shopping center with plenty of parking. There was not anyone else in the store when I went. The lady working (who I might guess was the owner) was nice but not overly friendly which was fine. I ended up getting the peanut butter cup and sugar baby.
The cupcakes (yes I ate them both… do not judge me!) were pretty good and not dry at all. There was a good amount of icing but not overload. The flavor was pretty good and basic which was fine but I’ve had better.
Overall I’d definitely go back to this cupcakery. They do close what I consider to be early (6pm) so if you get an after dinner sweet treats craving there won’t be any stopping at this place. Plan ahead for that sweet tooth craving.

I keep coming back for more. I keep saying I won’t, but I do. I found myself looking for excuses to walk in and order the chocolate-​covered strawberry cupcake. Valentine’s Day? Why not? Long week? Of course! «Just because» to surprise the spouse? SURE!

Love Abby Girl! Their cupcakes are so moist and all the flavors that I have tried are good. I have tried the Red Velvet, the Strawberry Delight, the Strawberry Cake with Cream Cheese Icing, & Cookies & Cream.

Went here for dessert to bring to a small gathering. First time here! I went later on a Saturday afternoon, so the selection was dwindling. Snagged the last red velvet cupcake: o) Also selected the double chocolate and triple chocolate, the sea salt caramel, peanut butter and chocolate, cookies and cream, and one that looked like a Hostess cupcake! Everyone at the gathering loved them: o) We cut them in half so that we could sample a few. I tried the red velvet and double chocolate. Both were moist and not overly sweet. DELICIOUS! The Hostess cupcake look alike was also a fav among tasters, as was the double and triple chocolate.
The reason I subtracted a star was I started driving away and realized that I did not know how to keep them until the party. Did I need to refrigerate? So I had to turn of the engine and run back in.

Around my birthday, I started dropping some hints to my husband that some fancy cupcakes would really hit the spot. Well, he took the hint, and showed up for lunch with two boxes full of Abby Girl Cupcakes! He picked out a variety of flavors, including Strawberry Delight, Strawberry Frosting, Cookies N Cream, Peanut Butter Cup, etc. As much as I love fancy cupcakes, it seems like they are always just too sweet to really enjoy. NOT the case here! The icing was perfect — not too sweet and not hard or flaky. The cupcakes themselves were moist and delish! I would definitely return and have more cupcakes!
To be fair, I haven’t visited the location myself yet… although perhaps that is safer for my waistline. ;-)