Nueva Italy Pizzeria

First time ordering was today. New FAVORITE place for thin crust pizza. Butter crust is very tasty. Order delivered hot and the delivery person was very polite. Even held a short conversation other than just asking for money (always a nice touch). Kudos folks! You have earned a customer.

Love their butter crust pizza. Fast delivery, order is always hot. Definitely my new go-​to neighborhood pizza place!

Seriously amazing and surprising find! A group of us ordered and loved the thin crust supreme, the cheeseburgers, the fries and their deep dish pizza *with buttercrust* (make sure to ask for it!) is comparable to Lou Malnati’s! It might even be better!!! I had a deep dish with garlic and green pepper and it was divine. We have since ordered from them on grubhub about 20 million times. Amazing every time! If I can suggest an improvement, the only possible even better thing would be fresh made desserts.

Chicago Deep Dish
open late
fountain drinks and cans

I wish the prices were a little lower buy the food is very good. We ordered butter-​crust deep dish for when a group of friends came over and when ever we invite them again they ask if we’re going to order it again. (The buttercrust is really what makes their pizza stick out). We plan to go back again for sure.

In town for the evening… delivery was quicker than they told us when we ordered. Deep dish butter crust was delicious… there was something missing in the flavor somewhere though… definitely not bland but not complete… the sauce is yummy… Would probably opt for another choice the next round.

I wasn’t super impressed with Nueva Italy. I moved further north so I was giving everywhere a shot to find my new regular place. I didn’t get the butter crust — full disclosure. The pizza wasn’t really that flavorful. I was really let down by the regular crust and the lack of flavor in the cheese. Delivery wasn’t fast either; my pizza wasn’t hot (warm, just not fresh-​hot).

Three years ago my favorite pizza delivery placed closed. After ordering from them for 15 years, I had to begin the hunt for a replacement that would satisfy my thin crust cravings. After maaaaaaaaaaany different pizzas, I finally found THE ONE!
THE ONE with a delectably crispy and buttery crust that crunches and then melts in your mouth.
THE ONE with fresh ingredients and ample sausage.
THE ONE with a perfectly tangy, seasoned and slightly rich sauce.
THE ONE that my heart, soul and stomach yearned for! It took over three years, but. Yes! Yes! Yes!!! I found it!!!
And to top it off, one day they accidentally sent me a deep dish pizza. I’ve lived my whole life in Chicago and the ONLY deep dish I ever really enjoyed was Uno/Due/Malnati’s/Gino’s East. BUT now I can add one more pizzeria to that list. Their deep dish is AMAZING!!!
Also, the woman who answers the phone is amazingly sweet, friendly and helpful. She makes ordering a pizza a delight! (wait is that possible? Umm, yeah I guess so).
DEFINITELY try this pizza. You too many find that it is THE ONE for you!

It’s been said that there really is no such thing as bad pizza. Wrong! The deep dish pizza we ordered had all the qualities of a good pizza except flavor. Had I been blindfolded & fed a bite of it, I don’t believe I would have been able to guess what it was.

The pizza had absolutely no flavor. Had to add salt and garlic powder just to taste something, anything. Really surprising considering the Unilocal reviews were mostly good.

There pizza is actually pretty good I haven’t tried anything else but when I do I will edit thus review based on their quality. They are affordable and delivery is alright. For a small newly established pizzeria it clinging on against other well known pizzerias.

Just had a delivery & these guys were quick
I ordered a personal sized deep dish and my fiancé ordered the Gyro sandwich. The pizza was cute & Delish Had a yummy butter crust. While the Gyro was a little skimpy on meat & fries it was delicious as well We will order from here again

I’ve ordered pizza a couple of times now from them. I’ve only had the thin crust. It is a solid «good». It is worth it to pay extra for the butter crust, it really does give more flavor. I would probably rate this a star higher if the sauce had a bit more flavor. It is a little bland, but I would pick this place any day over a large chain pizza place, you know who I mean.

First time ordering from here.
I ordered a 6″ personal veggie deep dish pizza (with butter crust) and a pre packaged slice of original cheesecake.
The delivery was faster than most places that make deep dishes and the delivery guy was super nice! I mixed up the delivery address but he still came through without any complaints! Thank you for that.
As for the taste. It looks and smells like a delicious veggie pizza topped with spinach, mushrooms, green peppers, and tomatoes. The ingredients taste very fresh. The pizza was not soggy at all considering all the other places that I’ve ordered from. They nicely wrap the pizza in some type of wax paper and put inside the box! Sure this place isn’t like any of the fancier end deep dished places but there is something about the pizza that was both satisfying but also lacking some flavor.
Nonetheless! The prices are unbeatable and I’m sure I’ll be back to try their thin crust cheese pizza and perhaps even pasta. Super adorable and I ordered through eat24.

Ordered on line from EAT 24. Waited an hour and a half for delivery! Call the restaurant they assured me my order was on its way. Was not happy! But then the restaurant called me and said they were crediting my account and how sorry they were. No that’s good business! We will try them again!

OMG, The Best Pizza Ever. We always get the thin crust with the BUTTER CRUST. Fabulous!!! They have amazing sausage, We also love the garden salad with their homemade dressing.
I will not get pizza anywhere else, except here. We just get delivery, though they have place to sit don.

Pizza is an art… you have to have the right sauce, the right crust, and it has to be cooked just right (not over and not under). It’s tough to find a good pizza place, despite the fact that most every place claims they’re «world famous.»
Nueva Italy is actually pretty awesome. It’s not the best you’ll ever have, but it’s pretty damn good. It’s delicious upon delivery, it’s great reheated, and best of all — they always beat their delivery estimate.
Is it the best pizza I’ve ever had? No. Will I order it again and again and again? Definitely.

Decided to try them for delivery the other day. And boy am I glad I did. Their butter crust thin crust is amazing and I’m *that* guy who has had like 100 different kinds of pizza in this area.
Light, buttery, delicious, reheats well AND they beat the delivery estimate significantly and the delivery guy was friendly. Pizza arrived hot and I was offered extra parm and peppers at my door.
This will be a staple. But get the butter crust. And cheaper and better than Lou’s. Can’t wait to try a deep dish after I gym off the holiday…

Ordered a deep dish pizza delivery and was very disappointed. The pizza had rested at an incline for probably the duration of its travel, and arrived lopsided with all the cheese and toppings slid to one very soggy side (it had even begun to soak through the box). This was unfortunate because the flavor was very good, and the nonsoggy side had a lovely crispy crust. Also, unlike traditional Chicago deep dish (layered crust, cheese, crust, sauce) this pizza lacked the 2^nd later of crust, which may have contributed to its misshapen sogginess.

Located on clark and touhy, this small pizza place has the best thin crust pizza. 20 $ covers a pizza for two and fries. I honestly love this place and have been a proud customer since 2013 of December. :) if youre looking for a friday night meal this is the place. Befriend the delivery guy theyre the best!
I also ordered during the polar vortex and the delivary guy was so nice to walk out in the darn cold and hand over my order. Humble hard working people. :D