Mr Cake

Thank you for making such a beautiful and delicious cake and on such short notice. My Goddaughter really loved it and so did all of the guests.

I usually get all my special occasion cakes from Mr.Cake. The cakes are super moist and delicious! My favorite is the chocolate wchocolate chip cake, mousse filling and whipped cream frosting. I definitely recommend Mr. Cake to anyone for any occasion.

My family has been getting birthday cakes from Mr. Cake for years. I just ordered my baby boy’s first birthday cake recently. This is the first time I’ve personally ordered a cake from them in several years. The cake was great – cute & delicious!
I’m deducting one star only because I think they overcharged me. I brought in a picture of a cake I wanted to replicate (which had several cartoon characters) and they told me it was going to take a lot of fondant work so their quote was a bit pricey. I was fine with that because I realized it would take some time & effort. However, when I picked up the cake, although still VERY CUTE, they did not do all the fondant work they quoted me for. They took a shortcut and printed the pictures of the characters onto candy pieces & stuck them on the cake. I was totally fine with that, and it made the job easier for them – but they did not adjust the cost whatsoever which I think would’ve been the fair thing to do. That’s all. But I will definitely order a cake from them again – next time I will ask more questions when getting the quote!

I have purchased the biggest cake they have since the baby shower I was attending had a guest list of 75 people. I spoke with the owner and told him what I wanted and what it should say. He gave me options of flavors and fruit fillings. I went with yellow cake and strawberries. This was my first time in this place so I was going off of other people’s Unilocal reviews. And when I walked in it smelled sooooo good in there! I ordered the cake 3 weeks in advance and when it was time to pick up the cake I was nervous. The colors, writing, presentation everything about it was amazing! I couldn’t wait to taste it and when I did get to try it I was very impressed. It was delicious and everyone loved it some people even helped their selves to seconds and took some home. I mad a call to the owner to give him my thanks and tell him how great everything was. I will be back!!! Thank you Mr Cake!

My family had been getting cakes from here for YEARS. My uncle is a good friend of one of the workers here.
My cousin had ordered a cake: chocolate, half strawberry, half banana with Ariel on one side and hello kitty on the other. The cake came out to 52 dollars!!! None of us have never paid that much EVER.
When we asked my cousin about it, he said that the girl on the phone was giving him all types of trouble, telling him if he got a picture on the cake, he couldn’t get lettering… When we’ve actually done BOTH for years. (He got both in the cake coz he told her this.) Obviously, someone decided to up charge us.
Most of us will not be coming back. At least not without my uncle being the one to order. 3 stars just because I have never left a review before and their cakes are good quality. Good luck!

Wonderful place and so talented! I brought in a picture of what I wanted the cake to look like and they created it beautifully. The cake tastes great too!

We ordered a few cakes from here. They were all good, in terms of décor and taste. They had very little variety when ir came to the fillings. Also the decorations were all very nice. I stopped because it was rather far.

Mr. Cake has the best cakes ever… The cakes are not frozen and the fillings are actual the fruit you order not sweet fillers. Plus the decoration you pick out really stands out and very talented…

If I could give this place 10 stars I would I love there cakes and how fresh they are I always get my cakes from mr cake from baby shower cakes to birthday cakes they also are great about last min orders I called them this morning around 10 am to place an order for my sons 3^rd bday and told them what I wanted on the cake and how I wanted it to look and when I went around 5 to pick it up I must say I was so pleased with how it came out my son loves ninja turtles that was the theme of his cake and it was amazing and taste amazing as well same thing last year for his 2^nd showed up same day order as well and they took there time to make sure it was perfect love how friendly they are and How affordable there prices are will deff keep going back and also will deff be recommending this place to friends and family. Mario the owner was the one who decorated the cake and he does an amazing job keep doing what you guys do my son was a happy camper today thanks Mario and staff…
Second cake this month from mr. Cake and I must say my sister was amazed by how Mario did her cake for her baby shower she came in with an idea and he fulfilled it he made the cake exactly how she asked and can i tell you the cake was amazing soft and just right thanks Mario and the staff at mr. Cake you guys are truly amazing will be back soon

So disappointed with the Crystal Lake location. Tried for several different occasions to order a cake and the shop was closed! Actually everytime I’ve tried going there they’ve been closed except once. Why even have a second location?

The cake was absolutely gorgeous. However, it was dry. I’ve ordered 2 other cakes from Mr. Cake within the last year and both of the other cakes tasted really good. Therefore, I am a bit disappointed. I also gave 3 stars this time because none of the graphics were edible. Not sure what happened but in the past all graphics have been edible. We had to actually remove the graphics from the cake which was a little inconvenient & made the cake unappealing. Also, when I originally ordered the cake, a woman assisted me. I showed her a few cakes & she stated that none of the cakes I showed could be made without fondant icing ($ 150). I asked if anything could be done with whipped cream she was hesitant but finally said they could do the simplest one with whip cream but wouldn’t be able to add the props. I called back to change the cake and spoke to Mario who was very helpful & explained that although they couldn’t make the cake identical to the picture because they weren’t using fondant, they make it as close as possible to the picture.

The Frozen Cake… was fluffy… the fruit was great… the kids loved it. The cake was ready on time… my daughter love the cake. they did a great job with the decorations and the details were Great… we will definely go back for my son’s birthday cake… I was very impressed with the staff that Mr. Cake has… and was super happy to find out. that if I bring a picture from another cake that I like… they will try to do it as similar or better than the one I want. looking forward to it.

I ordered a birthday cake for my husband at the Crystal Lake location and asked for traditional buttercream frosting and filling. As far as decorations, I requested balloons and confetti. When my son brought it home, it was totally sprayed blue with glazed strawberries on top which were oozing all over the buttercream frosting. Absolutely horrible looking. I called to complain and was told that «it’s not my fault, that’s how we decorate a man’s cake». I then spoke to «Mario» and was told I will get my money back; that doesn’t help me tonight with guests coming over. So very upset and disappointed.

Best cakes always recommending to friends and family. Mario is the BEST always makes the cakes I envision and never tells me No.
If your ever looking for a place to do something unique this is the place
Definitely will continue coming here

I love this place! This is the best place to get your any occasion cake. You will not regret it. The cakes are done fabulous and taste amazing. People that work there are really nice and very helpful. Awesome! Awesome! Awesome!

This place is awesome! After trying delicious cakes with my in laws from Mr. Cake, I decided to order one for my son’s baptism it turned out absolutely amazing!!! I loved the décor of the bible shape and his beautiful picture on one side. Besides being very pleased with the design the cake itself was really good with fresh fruit and the flavors were excellent. I will definitely be ordering my cakes from here for every special event. The person I spoke to over the phone took really good care of me and the prices are reasonable! I’m glad I gave this place a try!

Where do I start
Mr. cake by far is the best! when I say best I mean best!!! .
Thank you for all you do and for being a part of our kids birthdays. I will continue to do business with you for years to come. Again, thank you for the beautiful pokemon cake

Very professional and well done cake for an incredibly low price. I ordered my daughter’s first birthday cake here and asked if they had a «Frozen» theme (the Disney movie). They already had a «Frozen» cake layout that was ready to be made and picked up whenever I wanted. I asked for yellow cake with banana filling and asked for the smallest size (6 – 8 people) which came out to $ 20. I couldn’t believe it when I saw it! The cake was beautiful and definitely fit the «Frozen» theme perfectly. It looked amazing with her birthday pictures. And not only that, the cake was absolutely delicious. Not too sweet (which I like) and the cake was moist and the bananas were fresh. I would not hesitate to recommend this place to anyone wanting to find a professional birthday cake for their child’s party at an extremely affordable price — especially if the party has a theme!
I’ll admit it’s a bit of a trek to get over here, but it was more than worth it. :)

I attended a bday party for my cousin over the weekend and we had a blast watching little kids (including our own) run around the house like a bunch of wild maniacs!!! And thanks to Mr. Cake, there was plenty of fuel (sugar) to keep the kids going!!!
I wish I would have taken a picture of the cake but it was already delved into by the time we got there. Personally, I don’t even like cake all that much, as I’m more of a savory guy opting for 2^nd portions of the main course instead :) But Mr. Cake makes a mean cake, no doubt. I asked my wife’s aunt about Mr. Cake, she says they are super nice, you can order a cake to your specific customization and the prices are very reasonable.
It’s too bad I don’t live close to this area anymore, but I recommend anyone who lives in the area and has a kids bday or special occasion and is in need of a customized cake to try this place out for sure!

Idk why I haven’t written a review yet for mr. cakes
All I have to say is keep on the good job mr. Cakes your cakes never disappoint me they always are very tasty and a master piece. This last cake I order from them was for my goddaughters 5^th birthday and I showed the picture to the guy. And he said I’ll make it look nice when I came to pick it up. I did not expect my the cake to look so beautiful it had all these details. my goddaughter and all the friends and family loved it!
I recommend mr. Cakes you will not be disappointed!