Holtzmann’s

I went to Holtzmann’s on a recommendation from a friend to have a ring resized. I CANNOT express enough how wonderful these people are. I met Michael, Pat, and Pam and each of them was equally as helpful, informative, and kind. I had misunderstood when they told me my ring would be ready on a Tuesday. When I arrived, they told me it would be ready to pickup in about an hour. Long story short, I wasn’t able to pick up the ring for the rest of the week. They offered to bring it to my work because of the miscommunication (which again was not their fault at all). I was just so impressed by their sincere generosity to help me out. My fiancé and I will DEFINITELY be heading here to get our wedding bands in a few months!

Highly recommend. They went above and beyond for my wife and I — our engagement rings and wedding bands were all custom made and they are so very special. The Holtzmanns could not be nicer people or have more beautiful jewelry.

Highly recommended for diamonds. They are trustworthy. Michael is great to work with and is super friendly. Customer service miles better than Sydel & Sydel.

The folks at Holtzmann’s are fantastic to work with! They helped my finace create a custom, red gold engagement ring that was absolutely perfect and we just picked up our wedding bands from them. They’re creative, down-​to-​earth and clearly love what they do… always met with a smile and helpful advise… never pushy! We will be coming back here the next time a bauble is in store for us. Our experience was nothing shy of perfect and we can’t wait to work with them again!

The Holtzmann’s crew was exceptional to work with. Michael specifically helped us from beginning to end but Patrick and Pamela were there to assist along the way as well. When we first went in looking for an engagement ring, my fiancé had something very specific in mind. After going to several other jewelers in Chicago most only halfheartedly attempted to show us something along the lines of what she wanted. From the minute we walked in and told Michael what she wanted he fell in love with the idea and from beginning to end made sure it was perfect. They held to our budget and she is overwhelmed with compliments on the rings everyday. I honestly couldn’t have dreamt of a better jeweler to work with. Thank you Holtzmann’s!

I have been in here a few times with my husband looking for a wedding band to match my original ring. I wanted to wait until I had experienced their customer service, selection and special orders to write a complete review.
For starters, I walked by the storefront every week and looked at all the sparkly things thinking to myself «this is a really nice place in Lincoln Park, I probably can not afford one thing in there.» Or maybe I thought that because I am not dressed like a business woman that they wouldn’t take me seriously. If you think that when you walk by, please step in and say hello. The couple that owns/​works here are so open and friendly and they both helped me try on many rings and talk about some options. There was no pressure, they wanted me to be happy.
They worked with our budget and gave us a good price on a beautiful delicate silver band that looks great with my original ring. I also got my original ring cleaned and polished, it came back in only a few days and it looks like new. The special order for the band came in a timely fashion and I am so happy. My whole experience was positive and you can’t ask for more than that.

We couldn’t have been happier with our experience at Holtzmann’s! We worked mainly with Michael, but both men in the store were great to work with. They helped me customize my existing engagement ring by adding a halo around the center stone. The finished product was better than I could have imagined. I knew I was in good hands, given how beautiful all of the pieces in the store are… but they managed to exceed my expectations! We felt like we got an excellent price as well.
My husband now has a «go to» place for any and all future jewelry purchases!

I found my way to Holtzmann’s by way of Furrer-​Jacot (FJ). My fiancée and I fell in love with one of the FJ wedding bands and then checked for local U.S. dealers. We live in Indianapolis, but were not impressed with our local dealer, so we ended up traveling to Holtzmann’s in Chicago. Patrick has been fantastic to work with through this process. The store is in a nice area of town and is a beautiful jewelry boutique. You won’t have the experience found in Chicago’s Diamond District where people are pushing products on you. Instead, you will find a comfortable environment near quaint shops and great eateries. The service is laid back yet attentive. They carry lots of higher end and niche jewelry with pricing better than you will find elsewhere. Also, I really can’t stress enough the wonderful service we received from Holtzmann’s. We will shop again in the future and recommend Holtzmann’s to any discerning customers considering a jewelry purchase.

I love this place. Patrick and Michael are so friendly and helpful!
We’ve had two really great experiences with them getting custom jewelry made. My husband stole an old diamond ring out of my jewelry box and took it to Holtzmann’s to see if they could match the stone and make some earrings for me as a surprise. I don’t know all of the details that went into it, but I know that my husband was very happy with the process and I am extremely happy with my new beautiful diamond earrings.
So when I decided to have a necklace made with a stone my father had given me, I knew I was going to Holtzmann’s. I thought I knew what I wanted, but I ended up changing my mind about the design twice, and they stuck with me through the whole thing. Even when I made a change at the very last minute, they were totally understanding.
We will definitely be back for all of our jewelry needs. As a matter of fact, they have a ring in their case right now that I’ve had my eye on. Maybe my husband will see this and get it for me…

I am a big fan of Patrick and Michael there. My wife used to work down the street and had been «shopping» there for years So when it came time to pop the question, it was an easy pick.
What I was surprised by was their pricing was very competitive. We also ended up buying our wedding bands from there as well.
When the wedding day came around, they really went the extra mile for us. I will not go into details, but they were really great. So much so that when we left the church on a rickshaw, we stopped by to say a quick hi.
I don’t suspect I will be making any big jewelry purchases anytime soon, but when I do, I will pay Holtzmann’s a visit.

Holtzmann’s saved my life! :) I was in search of the perfect engagement ring and thought I had found it… had it shipped in from New York. God was I WRONG. Needless to say, I shipped it right back.
I was turned on to Holtzmann’s by a dear friend. I described, to them, what I wanted… they beyond surpassed my expectations! Pamela & Patrick first found me the perfect 2ct diamond that I wanted, then the setting. I went in, looked at them both and was blown away.
They had it set for me in no time… done deal.
They really listened & were quite quick to respond. They made my job easy :) My now fiancé LOVES her ring. We’ll be headed back to pick out our bands soon!
Yay…thanks guys!

Holtzmann’s is fantastic! They are a small family owned jewelry store. My husband’s family has been going there for years so this is where he went to purchase my engagement ring. We went back there to purchase our wedding rings as well. We received friendly, attentive service and excellent value each time.
I couldn’t find a wedding band in their store that I specifically liked, and they did everything to help me get a better idea. Pat even let me try on his wife’s wedding bands to see if I liked that! After doing some searching on my own, I found another style elsewhere which they were able to custom make for me. The ring is gorgeous!
The BEST part is that for my wedding day, I was able to borrow a few beautiful pieces from the store! It made me feel even more special on my wedding day. It was like being a celebrity!
We will definitely go back to Holtzmann’s. It is a wonderful family business with superb service and quality.

Few places have true class and elegance any more and Holtzmann’s does it. I really feel i was treated with honesty and respect. The Jewelry is modern, unique, and fantastic. They set the trends not follow them. I feel i got an excellent value and am excited to shop there again

My husband found the perfect ring with just the right amount of help from the store owners. He knew I wanted to be surprised. Since then we’ve gotten more jewelry from them. They work with the client and are incredibly nice and all their work is tasteful.
If only they weren’t in Lincoln Park… but I think many people would see the location as a plus!

We found a phenomenal engagement ring here. The ring was quite unique compared to the many other stores we visited. The owners — two brothers– were more focused on helping us find something tasteful than large /​expensive. I’d definitely recommend paying these guys a visit if you want something tasteful and maybe a bit different.

Holtzmann’s Jewelry store is cozy & intimate place to shop. The store is tastefully laidout to make jewelry shopping a dream. It is located in heart of Chicago’s Lincoln Park.
If you are looking for jewelry that will get noticed you have to step into this shop. Tasteful and distinctive are the two words that best describe there inventory.
The Holtzmann Family has even made parking easy. (see the website for details).