New England Pizza

We were in from out of town for a night for a wedding. We had lunch here and we ate some of the best subs I’ve ever had. The bread was amazing. Service was great! The older woman who helped us was amazingly sweet. It was simple and easy which was just what we wanted!

Best Pizza ever! I go at least 2x a week! Stop in quick for a few slices to go when I’m on the run. Tried their homemade salad dressing

2.5. It has gone downhill with the new owner. I really only go there because it’s close. The salads are great though. The staff is often unfriendly and the tv shows are long appropriate for kids.

This is the world’s best pizza and the world’s best spot.
Ask anyone in Chatham that this is really the best around.
This place has been around my entire life — this is that kind of place and you will bring your families year after year.
I’m not sure what the other reviewers are talking about but New England Pizza regulars are many and will all tell you that this is worth the trip (don’t get delivery, come enjoy the AC after the beach and bring a quarter or two for your kids to play the arcade game)

This used to be one of my favorite places to grab something quick for dinner. I ordered a personal pizza that took half an hour to come out and was on a par with frozen Mamma Celeste with extra parm cheese on top. This place has lost it since new owners took over.

Medium pizza with meatball is the best thing you can order. I ate the whole thing for dinner. It was very fulfilling and came at a decent price. It is close to home and tastes amazing. They have some of the pizza around, and I highly recommend stopping for a bite if you can. This place is a go.

After trying this joint, I’d rather eat frozen pizza straight out of the freezer. Bland and over priced.

This is another Chatham establishment that is frozen in time.
It’s fun to come back here each summer and visit. Nothing much has changed in this pizza joint over the last few decades.
This isn’t NY pizza, it’s more of a Greek style. Pizza is just ok in my opinion, but I grew up eating here, so I am used to it.
Prices are a bit high, but not horribly overpriced. Service was acceptable.
This is a good family friendly place to take kids to.

I’ve been coming here since I was a teenager. Owners are great people, pizza is consistent, and the Greek salad is excellent. It was just recently renovated, and actually offers delivery which is nice because that’s hard to find around here!

We find this pizza good for kids. Really large squares good for feeding a crew. A bit of nostalgia for our family, so we get it still about once a summer. Get a Greek salad too.

Will not go there anymore. Used to go there all the time. Not fancy but reliable decent meal. But now that we have little kids the video games in the dining room are totally inappropriate. Games with guns attached that children shoot with. Terrible and inappropriate. Not at all family friendly.

When we went the pizza was very bland and below mediocre. There were no options for large bottles or pitchers of drinks like at most pizza places, so everyone in our large party got their own individual drinks. We had heard good recommendations, but nobody in our party enjoyed the food or experience. I’d recommend trying any other pizza place on the cape first.

Stopped in for dinner with my wife and daughter on a Thursday evening. We were all tired of fried foods and French fries and wanted a change. This restaurant doesn’t offer table service and you order at the counter and they’ll call you up when it’s ready. It’s a nice size restaurant that has big screen tv’s and alcohol.
We ordered a 10 inch pizza with eggplant and two orders of the spaghetti and meatballs. It took approximately 25 – 30 minutes to get our food. There was nobody else there other than people doing takeout. The pizza was disappointing. It was bland with no taste. There wasn’t much sauce on it which probably was the reason. I’m not a pizza snob and I’ve eaten bar pizzas, café pizzas, and frozen pizzas. This just didn’t make the cut. The spaghetti and meatballs was a healthy portion with a good amount of meatballs. However, it was very basic. I must admit the sauce on the spaghetti was tasty and made the dish worth eating. The 4 garlic rolls were good and not to garlicky.
The dining area was dirty. The tables were dirty as were the floors. Even the table we sat down at had crumbs all over the table. Somebody wasn’t doing their job. Worst yet, the restrooms were outside around back near the dumpsters. My daughter told me they were absolutely disgusting. Dead flies and bugs included. Once again, someone not doing their job.

Okay pizza. Expensive. Really, this is a middle of the road pizza place. You probably won’t be blown away but you are not likely to be crushed with disappointment either. Eh.

Really enjoy the pizza here. Sauce is semi sweet and not too much. Coming from New York my family is hard to please when it comes to pizza. Will be back.

Could find better, I hope. I’m spoiled being from NJ/​NYC when it comes to pizza. Their crust is sort of crunchy, somewhat sweet, all together not good. That said, I ate 5 slices, because pizza is pizza and it is rarely inedible.

I thought the place was okay; I’ve had better pizza and wings in the past. But, the atmosphere was great, as well as the staff!

buyer beware. this is coming from a: local.
sewing needle found in pizza today. pulled out of mouth. was serving to small children!
old band-​aid found in pizza.
big clump of hair in pizza. owner’s response: «if you don’t like it, go somewhere else»
simple as that. judge for yourself. i usually don’t post negative remarks but this was outright dangerous.

Classic Greek family-​owned pizza joint right down to old arcade games like pinball and a clucking chicken that spits out toy-​filled eggs. The lovely little owner Antigone went above and beyond to help us feel comfortable and make sure our needs were met.
Beer selection is very impressive, complete with a frosty mug. Though the place was empty when we rolled in on a Tuesday night in mid-​December, the fact that it quickly filled up speaks volumes about the quality of food and service.

Recently remodeled. Pizza is always great. If you want pizza it is hard to beat this place