Vintage Cafe & City Deli

Not sure why this place has less than 5 stars. Such a cute little café serving super fresh food that you can tell is made with love. Prices can’t be beat either. I would skip all the rest of the cafes in Cedarburg and head straight for this joint the next time I visit. I ordered the tomato soup and pasta salad and my husband had the dill havarti sandwich (which he still can’t stop talking about.). Sooo good.

We phoned in a to go order and were told it would be ready in 30 minutes. When my friend got there to pick it up, she first was told that no one had phoned in an order (though she could see it sitting on the counter) and then when she pointed that out, was yelled at that they were expecting her to pick it up 45 minutes ago. Ummm no, I’m very certain about the time I called, the time they told me to come for it, and the time we got there to pick it up! Needless to say the hot orders were all cold. When we unpacked the order and split the bill later, we also realized we had been overcharged compared to their online menu for one of the items.

Stopped by on a whim. Found this to be very good basic fare. Salads, sandwich, all very good. French onion soup was outstanding. Will go back.

So other than the charge card policy I did love this place. We called on ¹¹⁄₄ to ask what time they were open to, was told 4pm. Took a 30 minute drive to the vintage arrived at 346 pm and the door was locked. Upset went looking for another place to eat. Found the Out and out. It was great and they take charge cards for any amount. Will not be back to the vintage.

Nice place, lovely England accent from the owner (?). Sandwiches here are light taste, I mean they are not heavily seasoned like other places. The salad is awesome, we love it so much!

Great service.
Food is okay. my roma poo anini was flavorful, but the tomatoes where no where near ripe. That wrecked it for me.
My friends ordered salmon salad. Three fish seemed pre packaged. The greens where good though. They where not thrilled.
The atmosphere is lovely.
I’d porobably just come for coffee next time.

Was walking by and decided to stop in for lunch. Great food and friendly service in a clean comfortable atmosphere. Can’t ask for more than that.

Wonderful atmosphere and dishes. The owner was super accommodating and the soup was tasty. Our favorite place for a quiet lunch.

Nice respite for a quiet lunch. Sandwiches, soups and salads were decent, a bit bland and unremarkable; good if you have a sensitive stomach maybe. Summer on the patio is delightful!

Pure zen. Delicious sandwiches. A fun cute rustic atmosphere that fits perfectly with Cedarburg. I love coming here!

Forgettable tourist-​strip food — nothing terrible, just lackluster.
The «Cowboy» roast-​beef sandwich was fine; freshly-​sliced meats, but freshly-​sliced off an over-​cooked Hormel beef.
The salmon salad had fine fish and fine lettuce, but was a little heavy on the dressing for my taste.
Neither had been our first choice — the three dishes we tried to order first were all out for the day.
No especially interesting beers to be had; the pinot grigio was fine.
Ultimately: Forgettable.

The staff at this cute underground café are top notch. However, we thought the food was a bit overpriced. We ordered two bowls of soup, and split a panini. The portions were large and the soup was homemade and served hot. Nothing to complain about, but also nothing to write home about either. If we visited again, we would give the deli sandwiches a shot.

Enjoyed a delicious portabella and roasted vegetable wrap. A little on the messy side but well worth it. Looking forward to trying additional sandwiches!

Cedarburg is a lot like Door County for me, only a lot closer to home. What is it about quaint-​ness that makes me spend money? All that peaceful charm just makes me break out the wallet. Obviously it’s all justified by all the strolling along you do and the heavy lifting as a result of the purchasing. But all that buying and exercising makes me hungry!
Anyways, we asked a couple of shop owners where to eat and all of them said Vintage had tasty snacks. They were right.
We arrived about noon and there was a significant line at the counter. We ordered the chicken dumpling soup, some pasta salad, a PB&J panini, and a Cuban panini. It was all rather expensive, but see my earlier notes about breaking out the wallet. I’m not about to be cheap with bags dripping off my arms.
We found spots out back by the river with the other diners and the food arrived lickety split! We didn’t realize how good sitting down after all that walking would feel and it was quite pleasant on their patio.
The soup and pasta salads were very good. The PB & J sandwich (it’s a hot panini) was super yummy, and almost more like dessert because it was all melty. The Cuban panini was exceptional. It wasn’t quite the classic recipe, but who cares, it was freakin delicious!
The staff were all very nice and I watched a server come out and take an elderly couple’s order from their table instead of making them stand in line to order up front with the rest of us. That was nice of them.
If you need a quick tasty bite in Cedarburg, Vintage would be a great choice!

Overall it’s pretty «meh». You’re not going to get a bad meal. But it’s not going to be great either. And for two kids and two adults who got water, $ 45 was pretty pricey for the experience.

Love this place, but don’t seem to find myself there too often. I am in Cedarburg weekly, but always forget to pop in. Have said that, they have great fresh sandwiches with awesome outside seating in back near the river. Perfect for the warmer months.
Cool atmosphere and definitely worth stopping in for lunch.

Bombing around Cedarburg we stopped in here for lunch. My wife had the Roma which was very good, nice fresh bread with good tomatoes and fresh lettuce, not a lot to the sandwich but really well put together. We shared the Chicken Nacho Soup which was awesome! I had «The Cuban» (Ham & Pork) on a panini. I really liked the sandwich however it could of used just a little bit of something else, maybe another sauce other than mustard, don’t get me wrong the sandwich was very good, but not five stars good!!!