Anthony’s Pizza

Hit or miss, spent $ 21.00 for a 3 subs that was on day old bread. STAY away, its a gamble every time good or crap. Manager would not even take the time for my phone call about the stale bread

After a hard day of traveling from Miami to Orlando to handle some personal matters, this place saved my day.
First of all, don’t expect a fancy entrance or anything that makes this restaurant to «pop». It is located inside a shopping center next to Publix.
We walked in hoping for a «ok» dinner because we were too tired to try to find another place. Not only my dinner was delicious, but I was happily surprised with the service and their variety of items jn the menu. We ordered fried calamari (it comes w two different sauces and both are pretty good) and a medium pizza (we were able to change get it in thin crust).
Our server was super friendly, knowledgeable, and provided us a great service (my glass of water was never empty thank you) I wish I could remember her name.
In sum, check this place out!

Great service and food! Will definitely be coming back to try other items on the menu.

We’ve been coming here a couple of times a month for over 10 years. Love it, always great pizza, they always cook it to our specs, good salad, yummy house dressing. Italian wedding soup my son L-​O-​V-​E-​S. Cold Beer and good wings. Not thrilled they no longer have normal fries, ick, but I think I’m the only one who doesn’t like them.
Note: Not open til 11pm ever, only 10pm.

Best Pizza in Seminole County. Been going for years and this place is a family staple!

It’s okay as fuck. Didn’t receive the menu items as advertised. I ordered the chicken florentine with pasta, and on the menu it said I would receive assorted veggies with it. I only received spinach with cheese on it. I wouldn’t go out of my way to go there again. It was way overpriced.

Great pizza… been coming here for years, nothing fancy just pizza done right consistently

Da muss man um die beste Pizza der Welt zu essen, nach Florida kommen !! Wahnsinns Pizza, super Garlic Knots.
So you have to eat the best pizza in the world, come to Florida !! Madness Pizza, super Garlic Knots.

I just started working in the area and didn’t know where to get a good pizza. My boss suggested Anthony’s. The food and staff were amazing! I’ve been back 3 times this week alone and haven’t been disappointed once! If you’re in the area drop in and grab a slice you won’t regret it!

Great pizza! One of the best in the area!
Been here more than 5 times an quality
Of food never goes down!
If you want good pizza and you’re close to here just stop here won’t regret.

Got here around 1:30 for a large pizza it’s now 12:17 still no pizza the worst experience ever will not return to this place. And the worst part they didn’t even say sorry for the wait.

For pizza is expensive, that out of the way we normally get a pizza from Anthony’s about once a week. So for us the expense is worth it.
No delivery, just take out or dine in. It’s family owned/​run. Anthony’s has other dishes on the menu but I can’t speak on those as I’ve never had anything but the pizza. I’m originally from New York City so I’ve grown up eating lots of pizza. I’m disappointed when I go to visit my family in NYC since I now prefer Anthony’s Pizza to pizza in NYC.
Service is quick, not always super friendly but I’ll take that for good pizza. There are a couple of other locations but this one is the one we visit.
The pizza is oven baked, not put on a conveyor and worth the extra money. I’ll edit this post if I try anything else on the menu but I’m a pretty good Italian food cook myself so don’t expect anything to change here.

When I walked in the first thing I noticed was a slightly dirty smell. As if the rug at the entrance hadn’t been cleaned. I walk up to the counter and wait about 10 seconds before I was recognized. I was greeted with a, «be right with you.» She wasn’t busy, wasn’t on the phone and there was only two tables and the whole restaurant. I suggested that the word «hi» goes a long way, and that she should greet her customers. I was given a little bit of a stink eye and a smirk in return, and still no hello. I only got a single slice to go, and the cook handed it to me. I said thank you. He said nothing. I said thank you again. I know he heard me, he said nothing.
I can get pizza anywhere, Jack, your customer service makes a difference and theirs sucks. Too bad, the pizzas pretty good.

Best pizza since leaving NY. hot hero are really good as are the garlic knots. It just reminds me of the little family pizza joints from back home. The zeppole and cannoli are good too.

Oh man! The best pizza in Orlando. Lots of choices from the classics: Anthony’s Special to the unusual, white pizza with eggplant. The calamari was the best we’ve had too, crispy, tender, light, with two sauces and lemon. Well be back! I can’t wait to try the calzone which looked completely distracting when it went by.

I have not been to Anthony’s since 2005 but did have their pizza many times. My Mother had a condo on Tahoe Circle for many years. At least once a month I would pickup a Pizza and a large antipasto salad. These meals still are some of the best meals I have ever had. Go pick up a pizza and take it home to your mother and have dinner with her. You will not regret having dinner with her but you will regret not spending time with her when she id gone.

Absolutely pure Italian feel … The pizza was great and the service was even better …

Though I’ve just come around to reviewing Anthony’s pizza in 2015, I have been ordering pizza, pasta, and subs from this establishment for many many years while living in Castleberry. prices are always fair, food is always delicious, service is always friendly. in terms of pizza, I would argue that it remains one of the better establishments in the area. Whether dining in or ordering out, the food is always freshly prepared and consistent.
In terms of pizza, you can order by the slice or various size pies. Pastas include all the typical italian dishes. Baked ziti, shells, ect. Each comes served in a large portion. They have several hot and cold subs, and I would recommend the meatball if you are choosing this avenue. There is some beer and wine, though I wish they would upgrade from bud light and peroni. Seating is plentiful, although you can expect short waits on Friday and Saturday nights.
Highly highly recommend visiting in anthonys for pizza and italian. It’s is a family owned establishment that has been around for a longtime, a true testament to its quality and customer service.

Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had! Fast service, reasonable prices, and their crust is delicious. They’re a bit pricier than some of the chain pizza places, but definitely worth the cost. This is the only place I order from when I’ve got a craving for pizza!

When I went to Anthony’s I was under the impression that it was my first time. However, my wife let me know that we have in fact been there before. I’m guessing my first visit wasn’t very memorable.
This second time (I think) was alright. We ordered an 18″ cheese pizza and some of the garlic knots (which other Unilocalers recommended). The knots were a bit of a let down (based on other reviews), they weren’t bad, but I was expecting something amazing, and they weren’t. The pizza however was rather tasty, that I did enjoy. There was a decent balance of cheese and sauce, and it was cooked well.
The restaurant itself was alright. I feel like there were maybe a few too many tables, but hey, you gotta make that money. Our server also seemed preoccupied, like she was just going through the motions. They weren’t especially busy so I’m not sure what that was about.
Regardless, if I was ever in the area and wanted some pizza (but only pizza), I’d give them another go.

On my trip down memory lane on my recent visit to Florida, I stopped in here for a slice of bianca pizza, with extra garlic. Was still the delicious pizza I compare all the other pizzas too!

What a hidden Gem! This is my new favorite neighborhood Italian restaurant.
This place has been here as long as I can remember (15+ years). I’ve been here a handful of times in that time, but it had been a few years since my last visit.
My husband and I came in on Friday night after work. This place was PACKED. there was one seat left open which we quickly grabbed. Between customers dining in and filling the lobby to pick up to-​go orders, this place was well beyond capacity. They only have about 15 – 20 tables so space is limited.
The waitresses were great, friendly and attentive, though a little overwhelmed with the crowd. Our waitress did a pretty decent job keeping up, though.
I ordered the Gnocchi with Vodka sauce and a side Caesar salad. My husband had a regular size Veggie Stromboli with a side salad.
My Caesar salad was one of the best I’ve ever had. It was huge, the size of an entrée salad even though it was just a side. There was something on the salad, not sure if it was the fresh shaved cheese, home made croutons or the dressing, but it had a delicious earthy smokey flavor that I had never tasted before on a Caesar. In my opinion it took it to the next level making it hard to stop eating!
My Gnocchi — little doughy pillows from Heaven. They were perfect density, with the creamy bright sauce and bursts of garlic. Again, so delicious it was hard to stop eating even after I was full.
My husband’s Regular size stromboli was huge, enough for him to take half home, which is unusual for him. He said it was insanely good as well.
The only reason I give 4 instead of 5 stars, is because they don’t deliver!