Garden Pizza Ice Cream & Cafe

i love this place
not just for the friendly staff that you know is making your food with love and care
or the daily lunch specials that go on all day that are great value (ask)
but for the day to day simple and good food that comes out there kitchen everyday
maybe some other italian restaurants have specialty dish they really good at
but here everyday taste good i never ordered something i did not like
its right here in carlstadt, food is delivered hotter, cause im local
so laugh if you want i’m crazy nuts for the place and the folks there
i think most would like it for day to day food don’t compare it with $ 50 a plate restaurant, this is simply good food so if your not a snob or fussy rich person i bet you like it.
try it if you can
local carlstadt resident

This place is OK, nothing special. It’s located in a strip mall and they offer a few tables and booths to sit at. I’ve been here a couple of times now, I prefer their subs to their pizza and they have some pretty good lunch specials. You can order a nice pasta dish at a good price during lunch if you’re hungry. The pizza is just OK, if I were in a pinch I would order from there, but I prefer to order pizza elsewhere.
The staff is somewhat friendly, not the most welcoming but that’s fine, I am just here to order and bounce most of the time. I noticed that there is a sign by the 2 booths now that demand 3 or more people sit at them. OK. Is it really that big a deal if 2 people sit there? How often are people staying to eat in? Maybe it warrants that sign, but it’s just a little off putting.

Now that they have increased the price of their large (not so large) pie by $ 2+ I will be going else where. The only reason I patronized Garden Pizza was because of their reasonable price. The pie is average tasting at best.

Got around to trying their pizza and it’s pretty good! Honestly, it doesn’t look all that appetizing, but had a few slices and they were better than expected. The crust is nice and crispy and not all that oily. Still have to try their lunch specials for only 4 bucks!

Restaurant is clean. Pizza is ok. Staff seemed friendly. I came is after getting my nails done for a quick snack. I just got a slice of pizza with pepperoni on it. I ordered the slice to stay. The staff brought my slice to the table for me. The pizza is kind of bland flavored and greasy but ok. Prices were a little high for the area. There is a 5 dollar minimum on credit cards; which is fair. Booth chairs are showing some age and the walls could use a fresh coat of paint. Overall not too bad, I will return if I am looking for a snack when I am in the area.

Great tasting food, moderately priced. Clean seating and generous portions. The staff is very pleasant and really make you feel at home! I loved it and most of all, my kids did too!

Their price points are now at $ 3.95 for generous portions on their ‘all day’ lunch menu, about 12 choices in all. So if you want to have cheap take out dinner, it’s still $ 3.95!!! Everything is reasonably priced, I can’t believe more people aren’t taking advantage of these affordable prices.