Tony’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

can’t go wrong here! pizza is great! always fast and always fresh. We love stopping here on our way to cape may!

Stopped in last week for a late lunch-​ordered a chicken cheese steak with mushrooms-​this was the best chicken cheese steak sandwich I have ever had-​my boyfriend really enjoyed his cheese steak too:)

Excellent cheese and pepperoni pizza in a fast, clean, and friendly restaurant. My daughter declared it «the best pizza I ever had!» I think this is a terrific place for a family to have dinner. The menu is wide-​ranging with seafoods, pastas, and sandwiches all at very reasonable prices.

Popped in for a quick slice before renting jet ski. Great NY thin sliced pizza. Pleasant staff and owner. Wish I had time for dinner!

The pizza was greasy and very average. We ordered a topping, which was no where to be found. I can not speak for the other items on the menu other than the pizza, but the pizza was very average and I would never go out of my way to dine here. Another major concern: the place looked absolutely filthy. Dirty floor, dirty tables, chairs, everything was run down and after looking around and seeing the unsanitary conditions, it also made me regret ordering the pizza. I am confused about the ⁴⁄₅ star reviews but perhaps there aren’t many choices for pizza around Cape May.

Very friendly people and really good pizza. The crust is too thin, so I docked ‘em one star for that, but the topping is tasty. A little expensive – we’re not used to paying $ 17 for a pizza. I would order from them again.

Great pizzas. Sounds crazy but I love ordering a big pie for a boat trip. Unconventional but always a big hit!
This is always a great place to pick up from if you have a ton of guests over. They are fast and the pizza is to die for!

Stopped in for a qik bite of pizza… will definitely dine here again next time I’m in the area. Food was great and the owner and his staff are top shelf.

They guys at this shop are a pleasure to do business with. This pizza place is down the street from my parent’s boat and whenever we need pies they drive them over, no matter how many. They are responsive and kind and their pizzas are consistently good. A nice balance of cheese to sauce ratio. They also make a respectable cheesesteak (and I’ve lived in Philadelphia for 8 years since growing up in CM and I still think theirs are pretty great). Their eggplant parm and other italian meals options are all of good quality at low prices.
It might not be a fancy place to eat, but it is a great place for families or for carry out. The guys who work here are honest, nice guys, just trying to provide good pizza.

I can only speak for the quality of the pizza here, seeing as I have yet to try anything else, but it is definitely worth reviewing.
It is a thin pie. Average, but not great, consistent, but not leave an impression good. My family and I order a Tony’s cheese pizza at least once while we are vacationing in Cape May, and we have truly never been let down. It is your typical greasy Jersey pizza, but not necessarily your run-​of-​the-​mill vaca slice. It fits better in a central– north Jersey setting. It is surely worth giving a shot if you’re trying to get away from the fluff of Cape May for a night.