My Little Pizzeria

Great pizza if you’re looking for basic pizza. We were craving it night and this hit the spot! Basic half cheese half pepperoni. Definitely a go to place after a long day or don’t feel like cooking and want some food delivered to your door.
Also, note that there is one size and it’s only $ 20– BONUS!

Great pizza shop and what I like best is that always have Sicilian slices ready. There is a very nice seating area in the front, further in the back and outdoor garden area with trees to keep you cool in the summertime. At one time there were a few good choices for a good slice, Downtown Brooklyn. Then they were gone and the choices were down to 99 cent slices, and one or two ok spots. To me, it’s worth the hike to Court St. They lines are ling, but they move quickly. There is also a little Gelato area in the back. If you are in the area check them out, next time I am going gir Grandma slice!.

I have been coming here since as long as I can think back to my earliest memories. My family and I used to always stop by here coming back from mass on what is now closed the ST. Peter St. Paul church. This is the only pizza I am able to eat plain. I typically don’t like plain pizza and always prefer pepperoni. I am picky when it comes to eating pizza. The sauce of My little pizzeria pizza contains flavor, not too over powering of seasoning but just right. I am glad it still tastes the same after so many years, and so glad it has remained open. I now bring my daughter here along with my husband whenever we are shopping around downtown. They both love it as much as I did/​do !

Lapin and I came here while waiting for our movie to start. The slices are on par to every other pizzerias. The staff is friendly and relatively quick.

This place, PRE-​2015, at THAT time, had the BEST plain slices I have EVER had and that counts probably over 100 different places. I had been going here for over 10 years.
Unfortunately, after not being in the area in a while, I came back in December 2015 and the pizza had not enough salt and the crust was much thinner. The cheese also does not seem as good. Whatever perfect balance they used to have pre-​2015 is not GONE. What the hell happened???
I am 99% sure they are using different ingredients. The tomato sauce tastes like it now has sugar added to it and the slices now do not have enough sauce. The cheese is lesser quality than it was. INEXPLICABLE! Also, the slices are also now thin-​crust. And the slices are more expensive.
As far as the QUALITY goes: Up until 2015: Best plain slices in history of mankind: A+
As of December 2015: AVERAGE PIZZA: B or B+… WHAT HAPPENED!!!

OMG these reviews are hilarious. Of course the service is rude. Of course the cups are cheap. There is ZERO ambiance. It’s a NYC pizzeria, not a restaurant!
Get the Supreme fresh mozzarella pizza, and get it in the store. Eat immediately. To die for. The rest of it is perfectly fine pizza, but nothing to swoon over. You’re welcome.

Pizza is here good the salad on the other hand could use more work on it. A little on the dry side but pizza hit the spot. Many many choices with a big sitting area which is great

You’ve got to love their pizza. It is superb. I can hardly begin to describe the wonder as you put it into your mouth, hot, oily, cheesy and perfect. Best pizza in Brooklyn.

We just ordered a large pizza with 4 toppings.
THE CRUST WAS SO STALE! It was dense, dull and without flavor. But WHY? Is it hard to make fresh pizza crust?

I’ve been coming to My Little Pizzeria since I was old enough to chew.
And this, my friends, is pretty solid New York pizza. It’s cheesy, greasy, evenly saucy and crunchy in all the right places.
Only thing is, it’s nearly indistinguishable from every other decent NY pizza shop.
In sum, it’s exactly what you want and expect from your pizza — no more, no less. And after a long day, there’s simply nothing better than 2 slices of cheese pizza and a Diet Coke to wash it all down.

Very average pizzeria. I’m sure my mistake was ordering the white pizza. The only reason I ordered the white pizza is because I was in a bit of a rush and didn’t see anything else available. I’d definitely return to give another regular slice a try.
The real saving grace for this place was the coffee and ice cream/​gelato in the back. I ordered an iced coffee which got my through the rest of my afternoon. The ice cream flavors looked absolutely scrumptious and worth trying.

They are a 3.5 but because of today’s visit, I decided to round down. I have been coming here for years and I always thought their pizza and garlic knots were excellent. However, I did have a few issues, such as, the employees often engage in personal conversation and may take a but to get to you, the pizza is often scolding hot and burns your mouth. Lastly, they have a $ 14 minimum for cards. which I believe is a bit fight for a pizza shop.
Anyhow, I came into for a slice and the line was pretty long and we were all clustered like sardines, I’m next and the guy skips me and goes to the next guy. I clearly had been waiting patiently in line, I’m a rather tall guy, point being, I’m hard not to notice. I finally get my pizza and notice they are seemingly under a cost cutting initiative. As I proceded to eat my slice, I notice it’s much thinner, doesn’t have much cheese and I’m left a bit confused and flustered.
Hopefully some loyal customers complain and things go back to the way they used to be!

Checked the reviews on this location and it seemed like and Ok place to catch a bite. I ordered Three pepperoni Slices for me and my mother to share. One thing to be acknowledged it they only take cash. If you try to use and debit or credit card the limit has to be above $ 14. Once i received the pizza i sat down with my mother i went to take a bite of the slice and all the cheese and pepperoni fell complete off the crust. which is fine cause i have no problems eating with a fork and knife. I would give it an average rate, the pizza was ok i’ve had better. the back of the store lay out is pretty nice, did really get to take much of a peak.

I’ve only had the fresh mozzarella slice but it is fantastic. Their sauce is right up my alley: not too bland, not too sweet. For whatever reason the staff seemed a little ‘distracted’ both times I’ve been in there i.e. not rushing to attend to new customers, but maybe it was just a misunderstanding.

Pizza is good. Staff are terrible. Rude. Total mess in there waited 5 min to order a slice and there was 2 other people In front of me. Main guy taking orders is a jerk. I know it’s NYC but c’mon be at least mildly pleasant. And they gave me a tiny slice.

Ok slice of pizza. They were sitting out I think a little bite. I asked for one garlic knot and the dude flips out on me. «We don’t sell ONE garlic knot! you order 4 or 8.» I was taken back. But I just came out of the movies and saw mission impossible rogue. So I put on my best Ethan hunt voice and said you won’t sell me one garlic knot? He cowered and said for you I give you one. Just for you. I thanked him.
The garlic knot wasn’t good.

The first time I went I tried the plain pizza, which was fine. The next time I went in I tried a slice of white and it was awful. It was very rubebry. I must have gone on an off day becuase everyone else seems to have great reviews. Or maybe I’m just picky with my white pizza… regardless of its proximity to my apartment, I will not be stopping by again.

The service sucks, long wait just for grilled chicken salad. I had to ask for dressing and the portion size dressing barely can you taste it on the salad. Never again smh

One of the best pizza spots in Brooklyn. Delivery is usually very prompt and the pizza has the right amount of sauce and cheese. This pizza does its job and has affordable prices.
It has plenty of places to sit and the back patio is pleasant.
Overall, a solid spot.

All quality slices. Sicilians are usually just thick enough, but the real stars are the slices; the white and the fresh mozzarella.
Nice little outdoor space/​café in the back as well.