Ficarella’s Pizzeria

We were trying to mix up our weekly Friday pizza order by ordering from Ficarellas. This pizza was ok not as good as others in town. I also ordered a Greek salad and found out they do not have Greek dressing to accompany it. I was sadly disappointed, but was able to make a quick dressing when I got home. The building was super clean when I went to pick it up and the staff was very friendly.

Figarella is the Italian version of Barbarella. Instead of having Jane Fonda get naked in a spaceship, they have her writhing around in a tub of figs. It’s every Sicilians dream come true, really, isn’t it. If you know any Sicilians you know what I mean. Mi scusi.
I wasn’t a fan of the pizza here. I had it just after Mark’s and Main St Pizza, and those were good, and amazing, respectively. This one wasn’t even average… it was lacking something and also tasted very old, like it had been sitting around all day. Maybe they weren’t so busy so they didn’t make pies on a regular basis. It also had the kind of pepperoni I’m not crazy about (more like salami) and was a little sloppy.
There is another one out in LeRoy, I have heard. I wish nothing but the best for both places.
I’ll go back sometime and try something fresh, hopefully. But certainly this slice did nothing for me, although I’ll give a solid 3 stars to support a family business. I’d rather eat 1 slice from here than 1,000 free pizzas from Pizza Hut all year long.

This place sells your average pizza pie. It’s delicious and hot and fresh and cheap and everything you need in a slice. Nothing fancy, just good pizza.
They serve slices in a «slice bag» that conveniently absorbs most of the grease off the top.

Chicken finger subs! I feel like this is a great western New York tradition and everyone should try this sandwich at least once! I got mine with BBQ sauce and ranch. Indulgence!
The slice of pepperoni pizza isn’t what you expect in New York City– the dough is thicker, like Dominos pizza, but the ingredients aren’t as «processed» as Dominoes.

We had a party of 10 and the sitting was a little tight but the guys that waited on us were fantastic! They made sure we felt at home. Pizza and wings were awesome! Pepperoni shaped like a cup too

Careful when ordering food for delivery from this place. As a long time customer that always raved about how good the food was to friends, one day I had a salami sub delivered late one night. The sub was *off* — probably the salami was starting to go rancid and I called the next day when they opened. I was given the runaround and finally told nothing was going to be done because the owner believed I was trying to scam them. I’m a 50+ yr old disabled lady and was totally offended. Took my business elsewhere from then on & quite a few of my friends did as well. I make sure I let newcomers to the area know to stay away from there less they are they are called liars. I guess the owner does NOT stand behind his product. With all the pizza/​sub places in Batavia he’s a fool.