Crust is too thick, burned. I’ve tried this place several times hoping that it would redeem itself. Not good pizza in my opinion.
Jake S.
Classificação do local: 5 Lincoln Park, NJ
I’ve come here every time when returning from Sandy Hook and they have never disappointed with the food quality. They will accompany larger groups
D g.
Classificação do local: 4 Elizabeth, NJ
Not cheap but pretty good. $ 13 for a turkey and cheese sub… but it’s bigger than most places. Definitely big enough for 2 people. We’ve been here a few times and will return.
Mike W.
Classificação do local: 1 Red Bank, NJ
i am housesitting for my mother, and figured i would order pizza and make it an easy sunday night. WORSTIDEAEVER!!! After an hour I called and someone got on the phone and said the oven were not working. Does that really happen? you’re a pizza place? He said it was leaving in 5 minutes. After another 45 minutes I called and they said he left 10 minutes ago he should be there soon. SO after another 30 minutes the pizza show up cold and not worth 5 bucks much less the 38 $ they charged. If you order from this place you are in for a very expensive and disappointing experience. Save yourself the trouble. Worst restaurant in New Jersey.
David H.
Classificação do local: 5 Rumson, NJ
Wonderful local pizza place where you always get great food and excellent service. Whether it’s pizza or dinner. They have it. The veal parmigiana is the best I ever had. The desserts are tremendous.
Steve R.
Classificação do local: 5 Middletown, NJ
I see that there are a few reviews regarding prices, but I’ve been eating from Chiafullo’s since it was red bank pizza. Almost anything on the menu comes in such a large portion that almost any 2 people can enjoy and be completely full by the time they finish eating.(And they don’t charge to share plates) The specials are changed very frequently and seem to get better and better(try the cheesesteak spring rolls!) and they also have the quickest delivery service I’ve seen in a long time. Two big thumbs up to Chiafullo’s. Extremely welcoming people! Always leave with a smile!
James N.
Classificação do local: 2 Staten Island, NY
I stopped in here for a quick slice and ordered 2 slices… the girl said $ 5.00… WOW… that was a lot of money for a salty slice of pizza… not worth the money. I wish I would have read Unilocal before wasting my money.
Mike S.
Classificação do local: 3 Highlands, NJ
Stick to the pizza and get it well done. The pasta dishes are not worth it.
Marlene A.
Classificação do local: 4 Middletown, NJ
BYOB Love them! And here at CHiafullo’s you get freshly made breads, salads, soups, dinners, pizzas, sandwiches, and desserts. It’s a win — win situation. And their catered food retains the same quality. Just recently I was there and there was a couple who just relocated from Colts Neck. All I overheard were praises and how they were so glad to live so close.
Tressi J.
Classificação do local: 4 Highlands, NJ
I’ve never had the pizza here, but the dinners are very good. Last night, I had the best restaurant burger ever here. It was huge and flavorful… I have also had the cheesesteak, and their chili… both had me licking my lips. I am very glad I live near this place! It’s great!
Trey E.
Classificação do local: 5 Alamo Heights, TX
Fantastic thin-crust pies with fresh ingredients. I’ve ordered whole pies here three times and each was perfect. The meatball has a great hearty flavour and goes well with the sauce. The roni and mushroom is a bit lacking in the mushroom department but the earthy taste pops in your mouth when you get one in a bite. Pepper and onions on the other hand, had plenty of toppings. The service is quick, the employees couldn’t be more inviting, and to top things off, it’s BYOB. Win.
Jennifer S.
Classificação do local: 2 Highlands, NJ
I have to agree with the other reviews. I just ordered pizza from there tonight and it was undercooked. The cheese was all over the place — even up over the crust– sauce went over the crust and in the box… made it very messy to cut. I tried to cut the pieces and the cheese and toppings came off with it. I had to cook the pizza since it was not hot. I tried 1st ave pizza too and that was not much better– I should stick to cooking my own pizza– which is a scary thought.
Jason F.
Classificação do local: 3 Atlantic Highlands, NJ
Their dinners are excellent… The chicken chiafullo is amazing! I’m not a fan of their pizza though, in my several experiences it tends to be very salty. If you want a great Italian dinner(although very pricey) chiafullos is a great choice… For a good pizza, I’d go elsewhere.
Gibbs F.
Middletown, NJ
Ordered a delivery, order was wrong. Food was not only cold, but bad. Garlic knots looked and tasted like they had been setting around for hours. Not impressive.