Psycho Sisters

Such a groovy store. You’ll definitely find some unique goods here. They have costumes upstairs organized by decade. Perfect if you have a specific decade party to attend, and might I add that their 70’s rack is pretty cool!

Great selection of vintage costume attire. I came in search of a gaudy prom dress for a themed party and there were dozens to choose from. They have all different decades of costumes and different genres for pretty much any popular party theme. Costume accessories including wigs, tights, tutus, shoes and glasses. Prices were pretty average for most things, some others were a bit high. In the end, they were the only shop in the area that had what I was searching for so they are a winner in my book!

Open late around Halloween & employees were helpful in suggesting costumes. Tiny dressing room with mirror out in common area. Some items were really poor quality. In general, costumes are on the expensive end. Also, when I got home I realized I got overcharged by $ 8 for an item I didn’t purchase as 2 costumes came with headpieces and I bought 1 separate (charged for 2). Since I left town for Halloween, I haven’t bothered trying to go back. :-/

Love love love this store– such a great experience! They know their vintage and don’t lie just to sell. They have truly unique pieces that can perfect a closet! I highly recommend them to anyone who loves shopping and a good time!

Super fun eccentric shop! You can find pretty much any costume collaboration as well as a lot of awesome used clothes. They also do consignment so if you have any cool clothes to sell call ahead and make an appointment to bring them in. The service is great and everyone is very friendly and helpful.

I really like this store when you’re looking for something exceptional. It’s upsetting because like most stores at little five, there’s hardly any plus size clothes to choose from. I’m not very large it’s just top I straddled that fine line of top heavy and hour glass figure.

Love this place. I’ve found some real treasures in here over the years, particularly in the shoe section. I don’t think I’d be able to find leather Chuck Taylor’s from the 80’s at any other place. It’s also a great place to get inspired for Halloween costumes, stage outfits, etc. I have a friend who frequents this place for LARPing gear. Lots of neat stuff all around.

A fun little consignment shop, lots of cool vintage clothes but the racks are so full it is hard to find things.

Awesome store. The store seriously has anything cool that you may be looking for from a bow tie to a chief hat to a gorilla costume to a cute and trendy designer dress. Staff is always friendly and helpful!

If you like digging for treasure, you’ll love this store! While it has some amazing and authentic vintage clothes, you’ll definitely have to spend time «exploring» through all of the merchandise.
Reasonable prices, decent selection, and decent customer service. They’ll let you spend as much time in the store as you require to find exactly what you’re looking.
I’ve gotten some great finds and some otherwise just «cool stuff» here!

Psycho Sisters has been around for 22 years! The store reinvents itself as the trends begin to shift, always on the cutting edge of cool. As vintage bleeds into current style, Psycho Sisters buys sells and trades the most original signature clothing items and accessories to mix and match with your everyday wardrobe. You will find items here that are no where else.
Owner pays clients and vendors for these treasures, so prices as best as she can to get you the best that she can. Shades are only $ 10, earrings $ 3.
Its never boring, its always a great place to shop for those who like to dress out of the box, and need a social wardrobe for any festival, party or club.
Ask for a discount, you will get it. Psycho employees are your personal shoppers.

The employees here were very friendly and helpful. However, they started talking to me about ⁹⁄₁₁ and how it is a huge government conspiracy– that’s a little too friendly for me.
The reason I don’t give this place 5 stars is because a lot of their stuff is really overpriced. Ruffle panties for $ 15? Fingerless gloves for $ 15? Suspenders for $ 15? Seriously.
At the same time, what I’m going to say next contradicts my last paragraph: there are lots of cheap things too! They have lots of winter boots, both used and new, and surprisingly, some of them are really affordable.
I saw a pair of waterproof kangaroos that I really liked, priced at $ 23. For kicks, I looked them up online to see the retail price. $ 189. I purchased them immediately, needless to say.
Overall, this is a great place to browse and find unique things, but be prepared to be surprised (is that an oxymoron?) at their pricing method.

I must preface this review by stating for the record that with I came here with my teenage daughter and niece to give them a chance to have the Little 5 Points shopping experience, not because i was looking for a tutu and top hat for myself. (I did look marvelous!). A very friendly staff coupled with high prices told me right way this was no ordinary thrift store. They loaded up, and I went across the street to the Bank of America ATM to get more money.

I always stop in here if I’m walking through l5p and have some time to kill, and have on occasion come across some decent finds. But on the whole, they’re way overpriced for consignment. I’m not expecting thrift store prices or anything, but $ 20 for an already-​been-​owned shirt? Nope.
They do have a great selection of costume stuff that you probably won’t find elsewhere, but again, it’s mostly too expensive. Accessories are cheap but selection tends to be sparse/​picked over/​just plain tacky.
All in all, if you’re not pressed for time and not looking for something specific, it’s worth checking out, just in case. But don’t go in with high expectations.

I love going to consigment shops and finding one of a kind clothing with great pricing. They have a great variety of handbags, shoes and clothes however the pricing is a wee bit high.
Staff is friendly and helpful.

Thank Buddy Jesus for this place. I was looking everywhere for a freakin’ tutu for a costume, and after visiting two popular shops in L5P which will remain nameless trying to sell tutus for an obscenely high price, I thought of Psycho Sisters, and found all my batshit-​crazy costuming needs.
If you need it and it has vinyl, spandex, glitter, tulle, rubber, neon paint, or anything in-​between, this place’s got it. Jam-​packed to the brim with clothes, shoes, costume accessories, jewelry, scarves, whatever, this is the go-​to spot for the finishing touches, that are just as crazy as think it is.
Not to mention, the staff were hilarious, helpful, and just fun to talk to, to be honest.
The place is super tiny, but, if you can get past your claustrophobia, you’ll find what you need, more likely than not.

As much as I want to be a vintage, thrift shopper, its the stench of old clothes piled all in one tight little space that just sends me running.
The store proably fits 10 people comfortably and they have a wide assortment of STUFF, the thing is after about 5 minutes of being in here, the stentch of old clothes all piled together send me running.
You gotta have patience to seach the racks. They have certain days when they buy clothes.
The staff is super friendly, somewhat helpful, but the stench of old clothes piled up together… eewwww
Nowhere as neatly organized as their online pics show.

Thank goodness there was A/​C in the store this summer…
Return visits: staff members are still friendly and go out of their way to offer help, even in a cramped claustrophic space full of customers!
Upstairs area perfect for Costume Parties.
The handbags are cute and affordable. Products that are not secondhand can be a bit pricier than expected from this store, but nothing ludicrous… I visit for the secondhand pieces anyway!

Great selection! Cool Stuff! Awesome salespeople!
The salespeople at Junkman’s Daughter are too busy looking surly and talking to each other to actually serve a customer. So, walked out and went to Psycho Sisters.
What a great place! Huge selection of masks and some great 2^nd hand clothing. Salespeople are friendly and helpful. Will be back here! Plus everything is so reasonably priced!

Consignment gem in Little 5. A few things… it’s a bit cramped in the shop, especially when you go upstairs and you have to dig through A LOT of stuff (bins filled with head bands/​gloves, racks filled with jackets/​leggings/​etc). Also… prices go from great to pricey. When you come across something «new»…the price tag will most likely have you questioning if you’re even in a consignment store. :) BUT… there are a lot of deals too. You just have to put some time into finding them.
They have a nice selection of 70s through today costumes (even some stuff from the 20s and up, but mostly 70s and 80s) and a good amount of accessories to go with them. Great find for Halloween or a theme party.

Psycho Sisters is the first place I turn to for theme party costumes that aren’t your typical cheapie Party City Halloween-​type quality. Upstairs in this cramped, tiny store, you’ll find a great selection of tacky Prom dresses from every decade, especially the 80’s. There’s also some hippie stuff from the 70’s and Roaring 20’s dresses and accessories. Since there’s not a ton to choose from in every single size, you do need a bit of luck to find what you’re looking for. Prices aren’t bad; the two dresses I’ve gotten have been under $ 30.
I can’t speak for the rest of the store since I’ve only gone here on a mission for something from their crazy upstairs section, but it seems like they have a lot of cool vintage stuff on the main floor. The space is really tight, stuffy, with creaky floors and lots of carpet, and it’s hard to get around even if there’s just a handful of people shopping at the same time.
It’s worth checking out if you’re in Little 5, and you should definitely make the trip if you have an 80’s party coming up!