Fatman’s Pizza & BBQ

No lack of food here! Super cheesey and true Chicago deep pan. Very friendly staff. Bring cash but they do have an ATM. Prices are very reasonable! Good deep pan takes about 45 min so plan ahead. Yum!

Yuuuuummy! A group of us came here after a movie Saturday night. None of us had ever tried Fatman’s, but it sounded better than any of the other options and after our experience we will definitely be coming back. When you go [and I suggest you give them a try!!} get ready for some delicious Chicago style pizza BBQ.
My husband and I ordered a thin crust pepperoni pizza, a gyros, beef tips, and 4 meatballs on the side. Other members of our group ordered a deep dish (ham and garlic), thin meat lovers, and pizza pockets as an appetizer. Everything was wonderful. The owner came out and spoke with us to verify our orders and we always had a full drink. When your check is over a certain amount you get to spin a wheel and get free stuff — we scored some BBQ wings! I can’t believe this hidden gem is all the way in AJ! But we will be back soon and are excited to try some new things.
This locally owned business has a great environment, it’s not too fancy or over the top. I loved the décor and the façade. It’s cash only, but they have an ATM if you don’t carry cash. Come give it a try!