Campitelli Cookies & Sandwiches

I’m beyond impressed with this place. The little girl behind the counter with the glasses is also amazing

Best cookies I’ve ever eaten!
I love the seasonal cookies and the sandwiches are pretty good. I’ve only tried the egg salad sandwich and I enjoyed it.
My daughter always enjoys a cookie or two!

Shame on me…
Seriously, shame on me for passing this place countless times and never going in. Now that I live practically within walking distance, I decided to do the right thing. And I was not disappointed. Once I had that first taste of the butter toffee cookie, I knew this place would be a problem.
There seems to be some divisive reviews for this place, which I find kind of surprising. The cookies are pretty perfect — they have the perfect amount of chew. I got a half dozen to take home and sample. Some were better than others, but that’s all preference. Nothing was bad. There’s something about them that reminds me of cookies you’d get when you were younger at school. I don’t know exactly what, but there’s something nostalgic with them. I definitely want to try the other menu options next.
It is a little pricy for a dozen cookies, but that doesn’t mean they’re not worth it — just a little on the expensive side. But maybe that’s a good thing? I need a reason not come back as frequently as I want.

I didn’t come in here expecting much. But I was impressed. The place is small. But the staff is extra friendly and you can tell they put effort into everything they do and they use high qualify ingredients. I ordered the half sandwich half salad with a drink combo for about $ 10.50 I got the peppered turkey sandwich on sourdough

The cookies here are amazing. the day old broken cookies are still amazing. The cookie bars are delicious. Their sandwiches are so simple and I’m not sure why they taste so good. The cookies aren’t cheap but worth your money. good for potlucks if you want to say «I’m trying care about this get together but not enough to wait for my oven to heat up».
Located in a strip mall, not super obvi but not hidden either. Plenty of parking, indoor and outdoor seating. There is a large selection of cookies and also holiday themed cookies. They will do a custom order if you put in for it. My favorite is peanut butter cookie with chocolate chips but trust… all the cookies are really good. I see people buy by the dozen all the time so they may not have what you are looking for if you come late. Holidays are also a busy time. I always get a turkey sandwich which looks like something I could make at home but I think all their ingredients are super fresh.
The place is also very involved in the community and is family run which gives the establishment a homely mom and pop feel. The quality of product here should be enough for you though. Support local businesses and spend your cash here but lay off my cookies lol

This place has excellent sandwiches and every time you walk in you smell all the wonderful cookies.
I really like the Genoa Salami sandwich. It’s amazing. The Salami is wonderful and it is sliced nice and thin. They give a surprisingly generous portion of the salami in the sandwich.

Everyone has mentioned the cookies, because they really are spectacular. I enjoy their sandwiches, particularly the turkey ones!

I’ve taste tested cookies all over Orange County– yes I’ve done a chocolate chip cookie crawl, because that’s how committed I was to finding the best cookies — and Campitelli has hands down the best cookies in OC! Their texture and flavor is beyond what you could ever dream of in a cookie. Their seasonal pumpkin cream cheese cookies melt in your mouth. And they sell «misfit» bags of broken or day old cookies at half the price that taste just as good! If you can snag one of those you are winning haha!

Delicious! I usually only come to Campitelli’s for cookies, which are always fresh and delicious! But today I tried one of their «Build Your Own» sandwiches. It was moist and delicious and puts other sandwich shops to shame. I highly recommend Campitelli’s cookies and sandwiches!

The cookies are decent at best, way too salty and full of flour, definitely not sweet. The sandwiches are okay, but overpriced in my opinion. I probably eat here once every few months and am satisfied with my sandwich. I always skip the cookie and go for the chips instead, at least they are supposed to be salty.

When ever I’m in the area I try to stop in for half a dozen of some of the best cookies around. I picked up one of their Italian sandwiches with Mortadella what a treat. I would of given them 5 stars but their really proud of their cookies $$$ I would of picked up a dozen but I also make great homemade cookies at a fraction of the price.

The cookies are amazing, but very discouraged on the service.
I ordered cookies at the last minute for Christmas, I was told I would be able to get my order in by the owner. Was told to call by 9. I called at nine and the owner told me, «I told you to call at 9:30» Kind of surprised by her aggressive answer but I waited and called at 9:30 and the answering machine was on, I left a message. I didn’t hear back and became nervous because it was last minute so I called again, and again all I got was the answering machine. I called for the 4^th time and they disconnected the line because all I heard after that was a busy signal. Why would they say they would accept my order? No more cookies for me!

Most already know that Campitelli cookies are absolutely delicious, but so are their sandwiches! Campitelli’s is my favorite spot for lunch in Anaheim Hills.
* * * * * Yum!

Their cookies are amazing but their pricing is a bit deceiving. Their website,
, advertises $ 15 for a dozen but fails to state that any cookies with nuts is additional $ 0.25/cookie. Their Misfit Bag is $ 4.25 that comes with 6 cookies = $ 0.71/cookie. It’s better to go for $ 1.50/cookie that’s freshly baked and you get to pick which 1 you want.

Ordered half cheese sandwich and side salad. Both were good. But honestly, the cookies are the real reason to come. Chocolate chip for us and they were so sinful!

WOW! DANGEROUSLY DELICIOUS!
I’m a self-​proclaimed cookie connoisseur so this place was right up my alley, and upon my first visit I struck gold!
Bought 6 cookies (came out to $ 8.50) so I could try a variety and here’s my verdict. The cookies were thick, hearty, moist/​chewy in the center. If you are a thin & crispy cookie lover, this place isn’t for you. But if love a melt-​in-​your-​mouth cookie, stop by this place!
BEST I’VE EVER HAD:
White chocolate chip
White chocolate chip w/​macadamia nuts
Chocolate chip pecan
SKIP IT:
Sugar
Cinnamon sugar (snickerdoodle lovers like myself will be disappointed by this shortbread tasting cookie)
Super chip (too many flavor profiles)
Overall, I found some real gems so a visit to this place is worth your time and $!

Cookies from heaven! Delicious cookies. They were amazing at catering our daughters wedding. 15 dozen cookies all perfectly baked and as one guest stated decadent!

I think they put crack in their cookies! It’s so addictingly delicious. I feel like a kid in a candy store every time I come in here. Though there are a variety of cookies, my fave will always be chocolate chip. It’s just the perfect blend of salty and sweet. I don’t like to eat the cookies right out of the store. It’s too soft for me. Instead, I like to eat it when it’s a day old. This way, the cookie is just the right amount of soft on the inside, with a fine layer of crisp on the outside. For me, no other cookies compare to Campitelli!

Cookies have good flavor but they are all way too sweet for me. So far I tried Oatmeal Raisin, Chocolate Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Chip Walnut, and Peanut Butter. Oatmeal Raisin was my favorite out of the four. It was moist, chewy, and had plump raisins. Chocolate Chocolate Chip was quite rich and decadent, but again, way too sweet.
This place would easily be four stars if the sweetness was cut in half, but that’s just my personal preference. I’m sure it’s fine for most people.
Skip the coffee.

When you walk in, you feel like you’re transported back into simpler times where cellphones didn’t exist and all you needed to make you feel better was a cookie. :)
Their cookie display case is mouthwatering, and there are a lot of choices!
Since it was my first time, I dived straight to the «discounted» area where you can get a bag of «Misfits» for $ 3 (6 random cookies).
Usually these are day-​old or broken cookies. My bag didn’t have any broken ones though, and it was mostly chocolate chip with 1 Snickerdoodle, and 1 Macadamia White Choco Chip.
THEY WERE SOO GOOOD.
I LOVE CHEWEY cookies, and these were SO CHEWY and MOIST!
Regularly priced cookies are $ 1.25 each and they’re decently sized.
But if there are Misfit bags available, grab them!
I wish they are open on Sundays, because that’s usually when I go to the theater nearby! :(