Vincenza’s Pizzeria

One of our favorite pizza places in the area. The décor is simple but the pizzas are terrific. We always order Meatlover Supreme Pizza. It’s a little pricey compared to other meat lover pizzas. It takes about 20 minutes to make but worth every minute. You must try the garlic rolls. They are the best I’ve ever had. Don’t let the location fool you. The owners are great and the employees seem to be family or treated like one.

A little hard to find and get too but worth the effort. It’s next to the Chevron at the intersection.
I was going to order a slice of cheese but the meat lovers was only .50 more. I’m glad I did.
The lady asked if I wanted it heated and in a few minutes had a piping hot slice with pepperoni, Italian sausage, and slice meat balls.
The crust was firm, chewy, and crisp. The sauce was tangy without overpowering the excellent toppings.
I will be back to try the fried garlic knots!

What a big disappointment– should stick to making bagels. Pizza was just a step up from Riverside but the big disaster was their mozzarella en correzza. I was so excited to see this on menu and what I got was severely burnt grilled cheese. I’m sure Nona Enza wouldn’t approve.

This place is a good find. Looking for the best NY style pizza in Atlanta. Well my canoli’s make sure you stop by for a slice. Not NY pizza but close.
Location: outside terrible in a gas station and next to a an empty boarded up location.
Décor: Inside looks good and not run down. Three booths makes it limited to sit down with a family but the high top bar with three big tvs makes it easy to sit down with kids and have a meal in peace:)
Menu: limited. Garlic knots are good but a little too much oil. Make sure to ask them not to drench them in oil.
Price: a little high for location which can be missed due to construction.
Food: nice big slices which i love, except pizza dough could have been more crusty.
Summary: if you live nearby then try it for sure. Is it NY style? Close, probably top three closest in ATL.

Eh. Overrated. Their bagel store across the street is excellent. Pizza, notsomuch. (Says this NYer.)

Awesome pizza! Crust is just the right size. Easy to gold with just enough yummie grease! You want a little of that! The meatball on the slice tasted home made and the pepperoni was thin but larger than most. 4 slices and comes for the 2 of us came in around $ 17. Decent I felt.

Just had lunch here: two of us shared a chicken parm baked roll. It was really good! They give you a generous helping of sauce with it, and their sauce is delicicious!
Highly reccommended.

I’ve been here a couple of times and gotten the Pizza, both traditional and Sicilian. I was please with both. Decent quality NY Style pizza. I tried the Meatball roll today and was very pleased. Thinly carved meatball slices with high quality cheese. Only complaints were that they brushed the outside with oil/​butter, making it greasy and the sauce was a bit on the acidic side.

Great location nice people, good atmosphere. We ordered a calzone and it was pretty bad. The pizza is just average and overpriced.

Best pizza around, and yes I think it’s better than Antico’s which isn’t far either.
I am not a big pizza eater, but I couldn’t resist once when we ordered one from this place. I assumed it would be good as we frequent BB’s Bagels across the street a lot, but I didn’t think it would be this good.
The mozzarella sticks they offer as an appetizer might be one of the best appetizers I have ever had. The large pizza can easily feed a family of 4 or 5 people and still have leftovers.
Lucky this place is close by as I am looking forward to trying more stuff from this place.

Excellent pizza deep fried garlic knots probably their best appetizer friendly staff a little pricele but well worth it if you are a pizza lover

The pizza is delicious. The place is clean. The employees are fast and friendly. Overall positive experience. If I had one suggestion, it would be nicer if it were a place with a waiter/​waitress. But that’s not a star killer.

Have never dined at the restaurant but have picked up their delicious pizza’s several times. Thin crust, the right amount of cheese and delicious toppings — vegetarian or not, Vincenza’s has the best pizza. It’s literally a 5 minute drive from my place and the service is top notch!

Reminds me of the pizza I would get back home in NJ. Been there 3 times now and it has been great. I especially like their mozzarella appetizer that is fried garlic bread or something.

Vincenzas pizza is the best pizza I ever had. The knots are fried to perfection. (I should know) and the staff are very kind. You want good pizza, then come drop by.

Im not gonna lie, I was really hesitant to try this place because it was a connected to a gas station and but because it is so close to my workplace, the good reviews, and prices I had to try this place at least once and I am glad I did. The inside is small but clean and cozy yet a fun sports bar feel at the same time with the big tvs. It seems to be family run (I heard its owned by the same family with owns the bagel place across the street). I tried the cheese pizza and garlic rolls for lunch (I brushed my teeth after and where I work I dont see customers in person so not a big deal). Both were cheap and delicious. It is a lot of food for under $ 8! I had enough for a two meals. This is going to be one of my new additions to lunch options for me as there are not a lot of on exit 12.

1^st time here, so here’s my first impression:
Cute and clean, but don’t come after the game with a big party and plan to sit together.
Pizza and knots pretty darn good and marinara a big cut above average. Bit on the pricey side for sure, but probably worth it.

Excellent pie. The meat lovers supreme is outstanding. These are the same folks that own BB’s across the street. Definitely cleaner looking than BB’s and the staff that I spoke to were very nice! Will be back for sure!

[TL;DR] Best Sicilian pizza I’ve experienced so far in the Alpharetta ‘burbs… in fact, in Georgia. All pizzas were great by the slice — 2.99+.
/​BACKGROUND (read: part you can skip.)
Several Unilocalers have probably already commented this place is owned/​operated by the same folks who bring you BB Bagels. That’s why I hadn’t planned to go. I love BB Bagels, but their health rating problems have forced me to stay away.
The good news is Vincenza’s rating is 100! In fact, I heard one of the owners coaching someone about making sure the freezer stays closed. Sounds like they’re serious about keeping that score.
The place is nothing like the BB Bagels caboose restaurant. It’s clean, airy, and modern. It’s located directly across the street in a strip mall that has Chevron as its anchor store. It’s right next to VIP Sauna — you know the kind with the blacked-​out windows.
From what I was reading on Roots in Alpharetta, the owners (Eddie and Anna Siino) opened up this place because they «didn’t like any of the pizza around here.» Uh, get out more. That’s what I say. Alpharetta is home to a lot of good pizzerias. I won’t complain if another opens up.
/​FOOD
The reason I like this place is the pizza by the slice option is fresh and pretty quick. I think I sat down after getting my drink for a couple of minutes and had it at my table. Typically, I hate pizza by the slice because it just tastes warmed over. This was good. I threw down a slice of Sicilian, a Meat Lover’s, and a white pizza. They were all different and all very good. The slices are large and greasy and run around 2.99 to 3.49 each. Tomato sauce was pretty good. Crust was good. Ovens are gas.
While the place is designed with sitting down and eating in mind, it’s not designed for dining. You get paper plates — the kind that you have to triple or your gravy runs through. It’s fine though for me. I don’t care. The salad we ordered came in a take-​out container. Again, whatevs. It was enormous and pretty fresh.
Pizzas come in sizes 12″, 14″, and 20″. YEAH 20″! That’s a monster! I saw them rooting something out of the freezer, which came in a box. I presume it was something you fry. I guess that’s not homemade.
/​EXTRAS
By the way, don’t show up expecting southern hospitality. This ain’t Folks. I mean, they’re nice and all, but they’re not the type to hang around while you lollygag and hem and haw about what you want. Step aside, grab a menu, sort it out, then go up and order.

For sure one of the best pizza places around Atlanta. You have to appreciate traditional thin crust! I am pretty happy it is close to work for lunches!