Pizza Tonite

I ordered from here for the first time a medium pizza and wings for delivery through
. Delivery was fast (under 30) and food was hot.
The pizza was… alright. However, I ordered in the comments section extra tomato sauce and definitely didn’t get it. Also, I just wasn’t blown away with the taste or quality of ingredients.
The wings were also disappointing to me. For all that my pizza had no sauce, the wings were swimming in it! Not in a good way. I thought perhaps the restaurant had misinterpreted my comment but I see the pics here and all the wings look heavy on the sauce. They also seemed heavily breaded which didn’t work under all the sauce.
Overall, decent but I probably won’t be a repeat customer.

This is the best place for wings in town. Their pizza has gotten better over the years, and it’s no my go to for pizza as well. The variety of toppings, 4 per pizza, and the price point, in my mind makes this place unbeatable. The more you order the better the price gets, so it is a perfect place to order from for a party.
I have never had a problem with the service — always friendly even when they are jammed, food always done on time… What more can you want from your neighborhood wing and pizza place?

The food is fairly good but the service is awful. If there is an issue with your order that is 100% their fault they will be rude to you and not help you at all.
When I called them because anchovies were accidentally added to my order the woman automatically assumed I was someone else who called and placed an order earlier and told me how wrong I was due to specifically asking I’d they had anchovies. She said this in one of the most rude accusing tones I have ever encountered. There was no apology for this even when I informed her I ordered online.
Normally this would be a fair misunderstanding for me without much fuss, but the fact that residents at my address had already ordered from them twice in the past 2 days (others were impressed so we followed suit), and they forgot our wings in this order, I expected some form of customer service for our business.
I leave a one star because no business should be as disrespectful in their interactions with their paying customers, even though their food is quite good.
An attractive face — or tasty one in this case — can be ruined flat by a terrible personality.
Driver was nice and understanding. Once he returned with the wings he said he would get us a proper pizza. If he returns I will tell and give that champ props.

Love this place! Fantastic wings, great prices. The best — thanks for delivering to Hamilton and Highbury last night!!!

Great wings at great prices. The pizzas here are NEVER greasy (which I love) but the toppings aren’t of the highest quality (still better than Pizza Pizza) but the price is right! If you go in to pickup, check out the specials in the flyer and combo deals they are very reasonably priced with several offering pizza and wings. The wings are a must try and seperate Pizza Tonite from all its competitors.
They’re also open late enough that you can order wings after the bar… that’s how I discovered them…