Goodfello’s Pizza Pasta & Grille

I come here fairly often with some of my coworkers. It’s a small bar/​pizza and sub shop in Zelienople. They have recently remodeled the inside and have done a good job making the most use of the small space adding in some bench seating along the walls. It has a nice pizza shop feel to it and is very clean inside. The bar itself is rather small, maybe 4 or 5 seats at most.
The staff here has always been friendly. They run a really good lunch special if you are someone who likes to get something other than water with your meal. Their subs are very large and they have some great homemade potato chips to go with it! Probably my favorite is getting their junior pizza lunch special with a topping of bacon. It is plenty of food to eat and their pizza is for sure above average. I have seen their lunch special salads and would stay away from them. Really not enough food for lunch and to say the least it was disappointing.
I enjoy coming to Goodfello’s for a longer lunch break. Zelienople is a nice small town to visit and the service is always friendly and fairly quick. This is one of our staples for lunch and we’ll continue to come back here for a fun cheap meal.

Have eaten there probably 100 times over the past decade and have enjoyed each visit, some more than others and settled on their Rigatoni Casserole and salad dinner now up to $ 8.95 plus tax. Wonderful meal, friendly staff and their new remodeled interior is very nice. Nero sub is also excellent!

I’ve only eaten here once and will probably not go back. Ate here with a group and everyone in the party had something wrong with their order. The food was under cooked or over cooked.

I stopped by here a couple of Fridays ago with four coworkers for lunch. Whenever we arrived the dining room was probably 70% full and they only seemed to have spread out 4-​top tables with no open ones next to each other. So they ended up sitting us in a tiny booth that reminded me of the booths I used to sit in for high school lunches. With a chair at the open end of the table we had an extremely crowded table for the five of us. In addition to the tables mentioned the restaurant also had a bar in one corner of the establishment and then a display refrigerator near the front through which you could see a homemade pie.
For my lunch entrée I decided to go with a large cheese pizza. As with all pizza, it can be broken down into its three major components: cheese, sauce and crust. The crust of this pizza was fairly thin and reminded me of New York style pizza. It’s cheese was the best of the three components in my opinion and had some good flavor. The sauce was there although I can’t remember any distinguishing features for it.
The bottom line for me is that I might head back here again in the future. I can’t say that this would be my first choice in places to go to but it was a-​ok and I wouldn’t object to heading back.

Nice to go to a good NON Franchise place. Mo had a kids cheeseburger meal with fries that was to much for her to finish, my bite was very good! Kat had the bbq chicken salad on a scale of 1 to 10 she gave it an 8 it looked appealing. I had the Nero Italian 6″ sub. I would order again it was on a good roll and was baked just right. We ordered a white pizza to take home and end up eating half of it. Kat loved the crust. Finally we ended sharing a piece of homemade pumpkin cheesecake — REALLY GOOD!

Hella Grody pie bruh! Very plain pizza, crappy cheap cheese and iralian sub was. Like a soggy diaper! Nevr eat there again and staff looked like dopers. Not worth the price.

Service can be slow, but they are friendly. Food is very good if you’re looking for some unhealthy bar food/​italian bites. It’s loud which somewhat makes it kid friendly.

Not a big fan of this place. Living in a small town like this u don’t have many options so I have been there quite a few times. Every time I have I have either gotten sick from there food or it’s just not good. Haven’t got a salad there without brown lettuce very disappointed with everything else to. Even there frozen fried food is horrible. How do you mess up frying something from a bag is my question. Won’t be going back again for sure!!!

I usually get take out and I have never been disappointed. The King Kong fries are a favorite in my house. Good for take out, but not sure if I’d eat in as I’ve seen other reviews that say it’s kind of loud.

My favorite and about 3 blocks from the house! I recommend the «Original Calzone» my favorite, but everything I have had here has been delicious! My family eats here about once every 2 weeks, good times!

Today was my lucky day because my grandma, mom, and I were going to a jazz concert. Before it begun, we chose to go get something to eat because we were an hour and a half early. Originally we were planning to go to Log Cabin Inn, but it didn’t seem close enough and might take to long to get food. That is when I remembered Good Fello’s. So our plans changed to getting a bite at Good Fello’s. Instead we were shoving food down our mouths!
All the food was SO good! Sadly, when we first got there, to my disappointment, a man was standing in the very front smoking which is never a welcome sight or SMELL! But as soon as we entered the building the aroma of fresh baking pizza filled our senses! A gigantic crowd of at least fifteen people were standing at the bar, waitresses were running around, and nobody was ready to seat us. Thankfully, after less than three minutes of waiting the a woman came and graciously seated us in a cute little booth in the corner. From that angle we could see everything in the restaurant: the entrance to the kitchen, the TV, and all the other diners. As soon as we sat down the group of fifteen was seated at a long alignment of tables in the middle of the restaurant. After a little bit of time of glancing at the menu, a waitress quickly came over in a rush to take our drink orders. She was very frantic, but it was understandable because the group of fifteen had quickly grown to over twenty. I asked for my favorite drink, milk, and she replied with a smile and scurried off to take care of other things.
After looking at the menu more, I grew even more hungry! There were so many choices in the appetizer section alone. I couldn’t decide if I should have breadsticks, garlic toast, or French fries to start off. Then for the main meal, it was tough choosing between pasta or pizza. I asked my mother what she thought and she couldn’t decide either! When the waitress came back with the drinks, we asked if we could take our appetizer orders at the same time as our entrees because we were in such a rush. She kindly allowed it. So, in the end I ordered breadsticks, garlic toast, French fries, and a junior pizza all to share with my mom and grandma. My grandma also got a pulled pork sandwich with homemade chips on the side.
We had a while after that to just sit and talk while she was busy with the large party group. It was nice and quaint. During that time, I did notice the dark entry way into what looked like the employee bathroom behind me, but I didn’t really mind.
Finally, our food arrived. First, she placed down the breadsticks, French fries, and pulled pork. She said she would be back in a second with the pizza and that’s exactly what happened. Then, she told us she’d come back as soon as the garlic toast was done.
When she left we dug in. The breadsticks were in a pile of at least six with some kind of sauce on the side. I just had them plain, but my mom and grandma were addicted to it. They seemed a little oddly shaped to me, but that’s just because the only breadsticks I’ve ever really had we’re from Olive Garden. Yet, they were extremely delicious, and I don’t think they even had olive oil on them!
Next, I tried the French fries. I mainly like mine overly greasy, but these seemed baked (not a French fry expert.) At the same time the salt complimented them, adding a lot a taste. So, they were very enjoyable.
My grandma offered to share her chips, and they looked very delectable, so I did. They are the best potato chips ever! I wanted them all, but they were really my grandma’s so wanted to make sure she got as many as she wanted before I stole the rest.
My nose then turned me toward the pizza! It was probably only six inches wide, but that’s just because I ordered the smallest one possible due to all the other food I ordered. The first bite was heaven after I got over how burning hot it was! Originally, we were going to split it into two slices for each of us, but I ended up eaten five and my mom one. Just a side note: I scraped the cheese off my pizza and my mom placed it on her breadsticks.
Finally, the garlic toast arrived. There were only three slices, but then again this was originally meant for an appetizer. It seemed like too much butter to me, but I loved it anyways. Grandma said it had too much Parmesan cheese, but I didn’t even realize it had Parmesan on it!
I would come back anytime, and raid the kitchen if I could. I ate so much I gained two pounds! If I had too choose a meal that didn’t have so many calories, I’d have breadsticks as an appetizer to share with at least two other people, a junior pizza just for me with a side of chips, and of course milk. All that would probably cost five dollars because the meal we ordered today was less than twenty-​five dollars!
I love you Good Fello’s! You deserve way more than five stars! I should probably take one off though because of the smoker in the front, but your food is too good to be true!!!

Great food. Everything on the menu is a home run. And the homemade desserts are a grand slam.

Good food, good price, fast service. Solid value for comfort food. Their Buffalo Chicken Salad is my favorite. Followed closely by the original calzone.
You won’t walk away amazed, but you won’t walk away disappointed either. Solid 3 to 3.5 stars

I order delivery from here often. I have known Gabe most of my life. The pizza here is good as I am a fan of Pizza Roma in Cranberry. Though sometimes inconsistent, you can tell when Benny or Gabe made the pizza over someone else in the kitchen. I also enjoy the buffalo chicken pizza and sandwiches. All in all its a nice place to enjoy some pizza, some chicken, cheese sticks, and other dishes for a cheap price.
They also cater parties and I feel that their menu is great for that, especially with the BBQ menu with the addition to their 3^rd partner who specializes in those meals. I enjoy this place over some major chains that are well known in the area.

I’ve only had their pizza (carry out) and it was a decent pie at a fair price. I would consider eating there again and sitting down inside. I probably won’t get the pizza there again as I’ve had a better. Check them out the location was once the great Chubby Chucks.