Infinito’s Pizza Buffet

We just happened upon this place on a road trip and were very pleasantly surprised. If you’ve been to cici’s, very similar concept. But I’d rate this place higher because they are doing a couple things better. First, the salad bar is WAY better. Not huge but a decent variety, and everything was fresh and of good quality. They even had feta! Second, you can request a specific pizza for the buffet and they’ll bake it for you. Not sure if cici’s does this, but if they do, I’ve never seen it.
The pizza varies; the cheese was really blah, as was the Alfredo, but the margarita was surprisingly good. They also have breadsticks, which were fine (similar to what you’d get at any pizza chain place). Didn’t try the dessert pizzas, but husband enjoyed a cinnamon roll.
I don’t live in the area but would return if I did. The value for the price is excellent and you can keep it healthy if you sample a couple slices and fill up on salad.

York seems to have a problem with pizza buffets staying in business. We used to hit up Stevie B’s back in college and the other pizza chains that took over the market street location as it changed management and finally went out of business. Then it was on to Cici’s for us. We were disappointed to see it had closed this year, luckily we found this Infinito’s right off 83.
Food wise, it’s buffet quality pizza which was perfect for us. We just need a quick stop to eat on the way home from Baltimore. They refreshed/​restocked the pizza at a decent rate and the salad bar was well maintained. The seating area was clean and the staff were very friendly. The location to 83 is great too. Easy on and easy off.
A great place to stop if you need a break from traveling on 83 for a quick bite to eat.

They used to be decent until CiCis closed now they could care less and it shows! They used to make pizza now they defrost one. Try ordering anything not already on buffet and they laugh and refuse. It can only be one of the premade items. You cannot add or remove toppings its against the new policy. As well they dont care when i asked why they said too bad you cant do that unless you get it to go and no you cannot eat it here once you order to go means you must leave immediately.
I tried talking to a manager and he refused to talk. So save your money and go to the grocery to get a cookie cutter premade pizza.

if it is busy this place is horrible if not then not so bad. people will fight over a piece of pizza since staff cant keep up with demand when busy. talked to management he said we should try again when not so busy.

Interesting little place in York that is similar to a Cici’s pizza buffet, only this place is a bit better in scope.
Value for the money? You’ll definitely get it here. Two AYCE pizza/​pasta/​salad buffets and unlimited drinks didn’t even come to 17 dollars, so this is a GREAT place to take the kids if you don’t feel like cooking and you want to get your money’s worth. Plenty of items to choose from, as well.
The salad was probably the most impressive part here, which seems like an odd statement — but the ingredients were plentiful and VERY fresh. Good variety, too. Lots of dressings to choose from and they do have «on the side» cups, which is convenient if you don’t want to drown your salad in dressing. Pizzas ranged from «so-​so» to «freaking awesome» — the best one, for me, was oddly just plain old cheese, but it came hot and FRESH out of the oven, and I think that’s what made the difference here. Alfredo pizza was also good. Wasn’t impressed with the Tuscan Taco — the cheddar didn’t really taste «right» with the sauce. But it definitely makes a huge difference if you get it fresh, so try to wait until they bring new ones out before you partake.
Pasta was just «okay» — nothing to write home about and I’d probably skip it next go-​round.
Drinks are unlimited and plentiful in choice — three kinds of tea, Pepsi products (diet caff-​free? Thank you from this pregnant lady, lol!), juices, and coffee. Lots of choice, so very much worth it.
The dessert pizzas seem to be where they shine. I had a small slice of S’mores pizza and I can tell you what — this ish is SWEET. I didn’t need more than one slice of that because the sugar explosion was insane. I wanted a slice of cherry pie pizza, but my husband ended up getting the last of that and they never made a new one. Boo! Sure looked great, though.
Now, with all of this said, there are some downsides to Infinito’s —
The bathrooms weren’t real great. The toilet was running in the ladies room constantly and I had a lot of trouble trying to take care of my business, so that needs a bit of work. It’s not the worst restroom in the world, but it needs attending to. At least it did when I was there.
Some of the food wasn’t stellar, as mentioned above. Pasta was probably the worst of the lot. Dried out in some spots and the sauce (Alfredo) was pretty tasteless, so I wouldn’t bother with that again.
Staff was pleasant enough, though the counter guy seemed a little «spacey».
As mentioned in previous reviews, the music is unobtrusive and pleasant, and the staff was very busy constantly cleaning, so there’s that. HUGE place, too — lots of space. I could see bringing a lot of people in at once — even for parties.
I’d be more likely to give this place a 4, my husband says a 3 — so we’re compromising with 3.5. But rounding down for the bathrooms (Hubs sez the men’s room was really awful). If they step up their game on that, I could definitely see this place shining a lot brighter.
We’d come back, though.

Great Pizza at the right price. Service was good and the food was high quality. Would go back again and again.

Pizza is horrible… I mean it’s seriously a step or two above school lunch. But what do you expect for the price.
But all these type of places (CiCi’s, etc) suffer that same status. But there is decent to be had if you’re here with a group. What I like about Infinito’s is that they have a simple pasta bar. Usually some sort of sphaghetti and a penne style pasta along with an alfredo sauce and a tomato sauce.
I’ve found that a plate of the pasta with a mix of the alfredo and red sauce plus some red pepper shake and grated cheese makes for a reasonably tasting dish.
Lastly, the one place the pizza excels is on the dessert side of things. They often have a couple dessert pizzas similar to cinammon roles. These are quite tasty.
Between the two you can have a pretty good meal for the price.

We live in the Baltimore area but were in York for the day. We had a buy 1 get 1 free coupon (from the Entertainment book) so we thought we’d give it a shot for a simple and inexpensive dinner. Boy, was it inexpensive! (After the coupon, something like $ 7.50 for two buffets, one soda and one water)
The only thing we can compare this to, is Cici’s and Infinito’s is 500 000 000% better! The décor is very nice, lots of tables, music that wasn’t too loud and a very helpful staff. When we arrived, the cashier heard me tell my gf I wanted water and not a soda before we got to the register and she said «so, two buffets, one soda and one water?» I thought that was cool. We told her we’d never been there before and she explained the concept for us. It was nice to know that if you wanted a pizza that wasn’t there, to let her know and they’d make it. Nice touch!
Is this the world’s best pizza and salad bar? No. Is it good? Yes. The salad bar was very fresh, with a much better selection than Cici’s. I was impressed by the sugar snap peas. They also had a little recipe displayed to make an Asian inspired salad, which was nice. Even though it was kept under heat lamps, the pizza stayed warm an didn’t get soggy. I did see them through away a few random pieces of older pizza that remained when a new pizza came out. The bbq chicken and rose pizzas were my favorites.
We stopped in at the height of dinner on a Sunday, so they were pretty busy. It got a little congested at the pizza bar, waiting for pizzas to be cooked (they had a hard time keeping up!) and fighting off kids who insisted on butting in line.
There was an employee continuously walking around picking up used plates… it was nice to not have them stack up on the table.
We finished our meal with dessert– cinnamon roll type bites, apple pizza that tasted like apple pie and this super sweet but yummy chocolate chip pizza.
Even without another coupon, I will come back when I’m in the area. Great bang for your buck!

I came into this place expecting to get what I paid for (a $ 4.99 buffet) but I left feeling sick and still hungry since I couldn’t get down any food.
I knew it would be a mistake trying the salad first, but I did anyway and I only put lettuce and onions on my plate as most of the other ingredients were out or gross-​looking. The lettuce certainly wasn’t fresh and I got about half of it down before giving up.
I tried a bit of pasta and pizza next. I had a few bites of the pasta and it was straight up terrible. The slice of the BBQ chicken pizza was not good, but it was certainly the «highlight» of the stop. I would’ve considered getting more but I was already feeling sick from the salad and pasta (with gross marinara sauce) so I figured it was time to get out of there as quickly as possible

Not your average pizza buffet. First, the restaurant is so clean; the staff are constantly clearing, straightening, replenishing. The pizza is delicious and there are lots of varieties from which to choose. The salad bar has spinach!!! And the desserts are wonderful!

Cute décor but the pizza was nothing to write home about (2.5 stars)

I love this Infinitos! The people who make the food come out and clean your table, talk to you (if you’re a regular), and are constantly making fresh food. The atmosphere is traditional. I prefer booths over tables but it’s no big deal. The best pizza to get is the Alfredo! I go there almost once a week because the food is so good. I like this one over the other Infinitos over by west York.