AJ’s Stone Oven American Pizzeria

So far this is my favorite pizza place in town. The garlic knots were the plate clean delicious and the pizza was absolutely delicious, full of flavor and I loved the crust. I spent a certain dollar amount and walked out with a free 2 liter. That is the right way to make me a repeat customer. The owner was very friendly and made sure we were well taken care of we will be back.

If you can overlook the heavy oven smoke, the uncleared dishes on the counter, the dark ambience and shopping mall mien, then you are in for a treat. The regular crust is nice thin and tasty. The plain classic is one of the best pies I’ve had. These guys are real pro’s. Only knock is too few staff for the line out the door.

Got kicked out of our seats and waited for a long time for our food. If you have low expectations and can’t find any other place to eat, this place is for you.

Scrumptious!!! Some of the best Pizza I have ever had! The crust is thin, loaded with toppings. Plenty of beer choices. Skipped the brews, because it was only lunch & we didnt have a lot of time. Super Nice, they even made a special dessert for my son’s BIRTHDAY.

By far the best pizza in Woodland Park. I have eaten there since they opened and continue to do so every Friday. The crust is great and the toppings are quality. The only downside is they can sometimes be a little slow. Not because of poor staff… the staff is GREAT… but because they get slammed all the time. Most every time I go in on a weekend for dinner it is hard to find an empty table and there is a line for the counter.
The garlic knots and cheesy garlic bread are fantastic. Their sandwiches and pastas are good but not quite as good as the pizza. We order sandwiches regularly and the bread is great. The meats are pizza toppings and this is my only complaint. I wish they had regular deli meat and the sandwiches would be awesome.

It’s awesome the pizza is the best I tasted yet and
If you have kids they can play with pizza dough
And the bread sticks are good and the music is too!

Stopped at this place after exploring florissant fossil beds national monument. We were two adults and a nearly one year old ate a 10″ pizza, which hit the spot. Very good pizza and friendly staff. We recommend this place. Easy access from Rt. 24.

Love this place! Any time we make a trip to this area we stop in for some garlic knots, caesar salad and veggie pizza! They have outside seating that they will let you sit with the furry family!

Sat on the front porch for a couple hours using wifi, sipping excellent brews and eating pizza.
Atmosphere is relaxed and very mountain town. Food is great and staff is friendly.
I would definitely go back by myself or with friends.

Not a bad place by any means. The pizza wasn’t great but by no means was it bad either. They had quality toppings and GREAT, friendly service. Pizza is ³⁄₅ stars but it was the cleanliness and great service that bumped this place to an extra star.

Pizza was alright. Ordered Canadian bacon and banana peppers– topping were quality tasting but the cheese was not my thing, and the sauce tastes WAY over seasoned with dry Italian herbs. :/​and the crust has a burnt taste that masked much of the other flavor a. Won’t be my first choice (or 5^th) when eating out…

I just left this place! I’m appalled how rude these people were! Not only did we have to wait an hour for a PIZZA, but when we asked for status of the pizza, they just shrugged and said we were would get it when it’s done, they are too busy! I wish I wouldn’t have tipped $ 10 when we ordered out meal. They don’t deserve a cent!

All I have is pizza to really yel (p) about — trust me on this one. I’m very glad I found this place — 3 visits for to-​go pies in 1 month and I don’t even live in Woodland Park.
Delicious New York-​reminiscent/​Long Island style pizza — inexpensive for the flavor and texture, and the owner is back there flipping pies with the rest; all friendly staff, informative/​quick service, eager to please, they all seemed to be in good spirits even late at night and making me a quick to-​go on the way from Gold Hill Cinemas (love that place).
They’ll make your pie the way you want it… and this suggestion seemed to be agreed upon by all who work there and who tasted it after to be an ideal way to get it if you are from the East Coast and not Chicago:
EXTRA thin (not normal, not ‘thin’ — it’s a smaller dough pulled large)
Extra crispy — it will be perfectly cooked /​*
*way better than other options in the area /​not half-​cooked soap tasting abominations slapped out of oven by half-​hearted-​staff with-​way-​too-​much-​rotation

Excellent garlic rolls! Best I’ve ever had. Bought extra to take home since we live in Denver. We got one thin crust w. white sauce & meatballs, excellent! And a regular crust garden veggie which was also delic! The reg crust reminds me of a mix between a Chicago & San Francisco style crust. We all loved it! I highly recommend this place and will definitely be back when in the area! If it was in my neck of the woods it would be our #1 pizza place :)

Best pizza in Woodland Park! They have two large TVs and allowed me to change channel to watch playoff basketball. There is also a good wifi connection, which is hard to find in Woodland Park area. You just have to ask them for the password.
Their staff was super friendly and relaxed. But in the end, it’s really the fantastic pizza that brings me back. A notch above the average chain restaurants.

I live in an area where people think pizza is an exotic treat I suppose. Pies usually cost 25 bucks and taste bland. This place was a pleasant find. Fast, fair and friendly. If they only delivered next day air I’d be a regular.

I thought about lowering my review to four stars because they’ve seemed understaffed the past two times I’ve come but I can’t because the food is that good. As far as food goes it’s all good except the cinnamon bread, yuck! It’s the wrong kind of bread for it and way too much cinnamon. We got cinnamon breadsticks though, maybe the knots are better? Also you can pass on the wings, they’re too fatty and messy. O and you can pass on their salad too cuz it has weird stuff on it like mushrooms, olives, tomato and onion. Would be better with cheese, tomato, carrots and croutons.

Disappointing. We have given this place a few tries. the first time we went in and ordered for carry out and was told it would be 20 minutes, it ended up being and hour and 20 minutes. The pizza was okay that time, the jalapeño poppers were great.
The next time we ordered delivery and was told it would be an hour, it ended up being 2 and a half hours. The pizza that time was so doughy I could have literally formed it back into a ball and re-​rolled it.
The final time we called in an order and was told it would be 20 minutes, knowing better, we showed up after 50 minutes just to find out that they hadn’t even started our order yet, it was still 5 orders back. I told the guy to forget it then, he just shrugged his shoulders and said okay and moved on to the next person in line without an apology to us for even wasting our time.

Good pizza, made fresh, went twice while we were in town I nice was fast, Friday night there was no where to sit and it took a while… But it was Friday night.
Got the butcher shop pizza, excellent! They serve beer and wine, have fat tire and Batch 19 on draft yum!
Check this place out if you are in Woodland Hills CO, or anywhere between divide and COS.

Meatball pizza with plenty of garlic butter to dip it in is where it’s at. I have the best garlic breath right now and it was totally worth it!
I meandered over here while waiting on my ride to come scoop me up after an appointment at the nail salon in the same shopping center, and was asked to pick up a pizza while I waited. So, I placed my order for a large pizza (half garden and half meatball, thin crust, size large) and a regular sized caesar salad (which is enough for two people). I also got a draft beer (GREAT beer prices!). All in all, the price was really reasonable (independent pizza chains in Dallas tend to run about $ 40 for two people and this was half that), and I even got beer while I waited! Score!
They were REALLY busy when I came in, so my to-​go order kind of got lost in the shuffle, but I got it while it was still piping hot and trotted my happy butt out the door.
Be aware that they have no A/​C, which really isn’t a bummer in a mountain town where the temperature doesn’t really get above 80 degrees, but with that stone oven going, it gets pretty cozy in here. I’m cold natured so I was loving it, but the walking furnaces among us may not enjoy the warmth.
Staff was so nice and friendly. Next time I am visiting family, I am definitely coming back!