Paulee’s Pizzeria

Needs work
1. Don’t sell drinks from a pop machine.
2. Make more food from scratch instead of Frozen and bought by a different company.
3. Make sure napkins and utensils are provided for your customers.
4. Employees should interact with customers instead of just acting as order takers and disappearing into the back.
5. Sell slices… it will bring in a lot of revenue.
6. Use the better ingredients and recipes, it will pay off in the long run.
7. Quality before quantity with low prices brings more business.

Pauline’s is our go to pizza place in Wonder Lake. We order from here at least once a week. Great crust and sauce. The breadsticks and chicken wings are excellent as well.

Been ordering for delivery here quite a bit for over a year. That ends today. The food isn’t that great, but it’s convenient when I’m tired and don’t feel like cooking.
Tonight was one of those nights. I ordered a a Cheesy Beef, Onion Rings and a 14″ thin crust pizza with extra cheese, pepperoni and sausage. $ 34+. When I tip the driver (cause I’m not a jerk) we’re close to $ 40. That my friends is ridiculous. Farewell Paulees. My hard earned money and I are leaving…

NOT recommended! I’m not one to write a negative review, I’m a pretty easy going person, but after what my husband and I just experienced, this time is a must. We had ordered what we order, everytime. a large double dough cheese pizza and a side of cheesy bread with marinara sauce. After bringing it home, we come to find they gave us a thin crust pizza and no marinara sauce. No biggy, mistakes happen. We simply call and nicely explain the situation, and got nothing but attitude and them telling us we’re wrong and they gave us the right pizza. We were offered a 50 cent credit towards our next order. Wow. Offering nothing would have been better. All we wanted to do was raise awareness about a mixed up order, to prevent future mixed up orders. Needless to say, the pizza crust is like eating tough cardboard, the breadsticks way over cooked…$ 20 later, my husband is on his way into town to get other food.

For the limited selection in the area, this pizza is great. The crust on the pan pizza is so thick and delicious. Prices are fair and you get several coupons with purchase. We will be back!

There are very few choices in wonder lake for pizza by delivery and this place is my choice when I order pizza from wonder lake. It won’t be the best pizza you will ever have but it does satisfy your pizza craving and delivers throughout wonder lake. I’ve ordered about 3 pizzas from here when we have friends over and everyone seemed alright with it. So if you need a pizza delivered in a timely manor this is the place. Otherwise I would just go into Woodstock and pick one up to go.

paulees is excellect pizza. Similar to fox hole but almost half the price. I read the reviews the other night and decided I had to try dustys on the other end of town because of those other reviews and I felt ripped off. Its twice the price and not half as good. You cant beat the taste of paulees pizza and the only thing that beats the price is little ceasars

I only order thin crust pizza and I really like Paulee’s it’s almost as good as the late Armand’s Pizza Place on 74^th Ave. and Grand in Elmwood Park from years ago.
I just wish the Township would spring for some lights so I can find the place at night!
Shame on them they leave all of East Wonder Lake in the Dark!

Great local pizza place for delivery or carry-​out. I personally wouldn’t dine-​in but the pizza tastes great and prices are good. Definitely better than Dustys… yuck.

The pizza here is too salty, not a lot of taste. Lots of deep fried stuff. Everything is just okay. I wouldn’t choose to eat here if it was my choice. If you are looking for good pizza in Wonder Lake, Dusty’s is a lot better.

Ok, I’m confused as to where my original review went. I’m guessing the reviewer before me hasn’t had different pizza from different places all that often, because Paulees is most definetely NOT that good and the prices are NOT reasonable. I had ordered two x-​large pizzas for some movers that helped us– the price was over $ 30 and the pizzas weren’t that big and boy were they thin! I could have sworn you could almost see through the pizza. The pizza was good, but for the price and quality, it left a sour taste in my mouth. I tried ordering a small ‘Wonder Lake special’ another time, and it was cold upon getting it home (I live not 2 minutes away), and that small was around $ 13! Tell you what, if you want good pizza, head to Dusty’s across the neighborhood– the price matches the pizza you get– or better yet LEAVE WONDER LAKE and go elsewhere!

Paulee’s was my go-​to pizza place my entire time in Wonder Lake. I’ve ordered at least 50 pizzas from Paulee’s in the last three years. Every pizza has been great. They’re gracious with the toppings, have a nice blend of pizza spices, and make a really delectable crust. In addition, their appetizers are good and their drivers are friendly. And their prices are also VERY reasonable.
If you live in Paulee’s delivery area, this place should be your go-​to pizza place also. They are, without close second, the best pizza shop in Wonder Lake and the surrounding communities.
I even enjoy their thin crust, which makes them one of only two pizza places with a thin crust pizza that I enjoy.
My only detraction about Paulee’s is that they don’t sell 20 oz. bottles of pop, only cans and one-​liters. One liter of pop is WAY too much to drink and leaving it over night makes it go flat.
My favorite pizza from them is a deep dish with extra cheese and bacon. This is not a meal you should eat every night, but after a day moving a friend in, cleaning your place, or fixing up your car or something, this is a perfect reward dinner.
You should order from Paulee’s.