Cobbetts Pond Pizzeria

Great local pizza place! If you’re swimming in the pond this place is close by and is locally owned and operated!

The pizza here was terrible. I was so mortified at a restaurant would even Serve such a terrible dish. The pizza looked disgusting and I had to drain the grease off The slice of pizza that I took. Not to mention the burnt bottom of the pizza. Their prices for out rages for a pizza that didn’t even taste good. The only thing that was worth eating was The chicken tenders that my little baby cousin ordered. I would stay clear of the restaurant good luck.

Cobbetts Pond is our go to pizza place. they have fresh salads and make good pizzas. Options are limited in the Pelham/​Windham area and this is the best we’ve found so far. They deliver to surrounding towns which is also helpful

Such a great place! My husband and I just moved to town and after trying a few pizza places, this is most certainly our favorite! Great salads and pizza. Great service as well, especially Danielle!

Sorry. See Wyndham house of pizza.

OK, so while we were exploring the neighborhood searching for our new home, we came across this place. I really was hoping it would be full of East Coast pizza goodness, but alas, it was not.
I ordered a large half pepperoni, half mushroom to go and as soon as we opened the box, we saw the first sign of trouble… canned mushrooms. Ugh. I know that’s more convenient, but dang… it does NOTHING for the taste of your pizza and screams lazy. That’s good for relaxing in a hammock on a sunny afternoon, but not for making pizza.
The dough itself was just plain… nothing special at all. The toppings… we already went over the mushrooms and the pepperoni and cheese was just alright. It was the canned mushrooms that earned this place one star; otherwise, I would have given them two.

Ordered from here a couple times. First time i got the steak tip salad and my husband got the grilled chicken salad. Grilled chicken salad was tasty and chicken was tender and juicy… steak tip salad… salad part was good, steak part, not so good. Steak tips tasted like bad lamb.
We ordered a cheese pizza for delivery last night. Being from bklyn, ny… there is no such thing as good pizza anywhere else… and this place proves that theory. Their sauce has sooooo much sugar in it that is un-​appetizing. We asked for light on the mozz and it was more like we got extra cheese.
Gonna order from here again to try the subs… seems like they should get that right

Place is great… BBQ chicken blast pizza was awesome!

Awesome subs and speciality pizzas.

Fair warning… I’m a Cobbetts Pond Pizzeria Regular.
We order from Cobbetts weekly, typically I get the small steak and cheese with extra onions — delicious. When we’re not deep in sandwiches, we frequently get the grilled chicken marinated pizza. The crust has a nice edge the cheese blend is exactly what I look for.
While you can order and eat-​in, we find Cobbetts to be great take-​home or order food.

Decent local pizza place located in a strip plaza next to the Lobster Tail. The place is very casual with table seating and the order counter towards the back. The menu offers pizza, calzones, subs, burgers, fried chicken, steak tips, salads, Italian dinners, Greek items (gyros, spinach pie, baklava), and Coke products. The prices are lower moderate here, a small sub is $ 5.95, large gourmet pizzas are $ 16.95, and most dinner/​pasta plates are ($ 8.95-$ 10.95).
I stopped here for lunch recently during the middle of the afternoon and decided to order a small cheese pizza ($ 7.51 with tax) instead of slices. The cheese pizza was already made and put in the oven for 10 minutes.
The hot out of the oven pizza had lots of bubbling mozzarella cheese over a soft firm crust, thick edges, similar to another «Pond» pizza place in town, except more cheese here. The pizza was good enough to eat in one sitting with no leftovers. The size a bit small for the price paid, but in line with other places in Windham.