Anthonys Coal Fired Pizza

My party called in an order today at the Pike Creek location and was helped by the most incompetent restaurant employee I have ever had to deal with. I was a little relieved to learn that she was a brand new employee but that is not any excuse for the way she treated our party. The only reason I am giving this establishment 4 stars is because when talking to another employee I was able to calm down a bit and she had the best customer service I have ever witnessed. I will admit my party was very upset and may have been out of line at times, but she stayed calm and treated us with so much respect that so many other employees (like the new employee…) would not have bothered with. Her customer service is the only reason I will ever get food from Anthony’s again.

Love the roast beef sandwich. Atmosphere is nice, excellent service. Pizza tastes great, but slightly on the pricey side. Good beer selection.

My favorite place for pizza ever! Great beer selection, and wine too! The wait staff is always friendly and on top of everything. The salads are great and the wings are awesome! I’m in there at least two or three times a month, and the place never disappoints. My favorite time to go is Wednesday night for meatballs & martinis night. You sit at the bar there’s martini drink specials and they serve free hors d’oeuvres. It’s always crowded and it’s a fun group!
The restaurant is always clean, the bathrooms are clean and that is a really important factor when I go out to dinner. if you’ve never been to Anthony’s coal fire pizza, you’ve had never had to good pizza!!!

We stopped by for lunch on our way through town and had a great experience. The servers were very professional, helpful and friendly. Our kind waitress gave us suggestions to help us in making our selections best fit what we were looking for. We got the small salad which came with two huge pieces of focaccia bread and the best Red wine vinaigrette dressing I’ve ever had. It was definitely the perfect size to split between two people. We then got the meatball and ricotta pizza and the eggplant pizza both in personal size. A personal pizza is plenty for one person and it worked out perfectly for us so we could try two different ones. I love how this place emphasizes how they make their pizzas well done (how they all should be). They were both crispy with some of the eggplant on mine having a crisp to it. The meatball and ricotta lacked sauce and our waitress didn’t hesitate to get us some extra sauce for us. They even heated it up which I find never usually happens at pizza places. Cold marinara on a pizza, no thank you.
I love how this place is just like a pizza joint I grew up going to. There is only one type of salad and the ambiance is casual. There is a wide variety of craft beers, wine and cocktails. I’m not a huge fan of the pizza because I’m pretty picky about what I think makes a good pizza but these were good enough for a lunch spot and I liked that they were thin crust so we weren’t super stuffed afterwards.

Good place with nice friendly staff. I mostly order take out. The ribs are great, but a little salty in my opinion. Same with the wings. Their Italian salad is of good size!

Good food here, a different take on pizza that I enjoy. Only problem I have is price,$ 16.49 for a large cheese pizza is crazy so if they don’t lower these damn prices I recommend you don’t go here unless you’re on a wolf of wallstreet wealth level.

Great food! We had the tuna sandwich and roast beef sandwich. Good size portion, great, taste, cooked just right. We sat near the indoor fire pit which felt great. Our waitress was friendly and helpful. We will be back!
Only suggestion I could make is to have a drink menu. This would help customers decide all the drink options outside of the few written on a chalk board.

This place is great. It can get a little crowded and seating is limited. The pizza is super tasty and the have amazing wings, meatballs, and salad. You won’t be disappointed by this place. Portions are large and everything is reasonably priced. Only annoying thing is they don’t have fountain sodas, they serve bottled soda worn a cup of ice. Otherwise this place is a favorite. They have a notable beer list and full bar.

Amazing Pizza!!! Wings and Tuna Sandwich are also on point… one of the best places ever!

Best pizza around, the wings are also a must try. It’s always crowded but the wait is usually only 5 – 10 min.

I really enjoy this place food wise, I usually go for the lunch specials and really like how everything is made fresh and tastes good and is affordable. I am a huge fan of the red sauce, the meatballs, the sandwiches and the pizzas. I also always request fresh garlic and basil and it is fresh as can be and I love this. What I do NOT love and what I do NOT understand is their nonalcoholic drink options. This is the only restaurant that I know of that if you order a Coke or Iced Tea they bring you a bottle of it. I am a person who loves fresh brewed iced tea and I can’t get my head around why they give you Gold Peak bottles. As a business major, I see so many problems with this when it comes to (1) cost to your business and (2) recycling. I might be weird, but it drives me crazy every time I go. Just make fresh iced tea and lemonade would be good too so that my options aren’t tap water or pellgrino.

The restaurant is nice & cozy and always plays great music! We always order 10 chicken wings and a small pizza. Their white pizza is sooo good! But my favorite item at Anthony’s is their wings. 5 stars just for chicken wings alone! They are THAT GOOD! We’ll be back again soon!

So I know this is a pizza place, but I really wouldn’t recommend their pizza. However, their meatballs are amazing. They are these giant, delicious creations with a very good marinara sauce and a little scoop of ricotta. The ricotta goes really nicely with the meatball and makes it even better! They also have really delicious bread.
I do not eat wings or ribs, but anytime I have ever been here with someone who has had them, they always rave about how great they are and how uniquely prepared they are.
I would not recommend this place on a Wednesday. I came here with friends not knowing about their special for meatballs and martinis. Coming here on a Wednesday is a mess unless you are looking to pick up a drunk 45 year old while elbowing your way to the bar. It is also super dangerous as I was leaving and was almost hit by two separate individuals who both definitely had more than a few $ 5 martinis.

Delicious food, clean restaurant, and friendly staff. This is my family’s go to pizza place! Thin, crunchy crust with many toppings to choose from. The wings appetizer is a must! Crisp wings seasoned with rosemary and other herbs, topped with grilled onions and served with warm seasoned bread. My husband and I have a weekly date night here, and we always get wonderful service and food. Enjoy!

Enjoy coming here! I am not a wing fan but LOVE their wings with rosemary, garlic and onions! Order their salad — very fresh. I love their white pizza add chicken — so good. My husband likes the sausage and mushroom. Their pizza is thin crust style. I just wish they would expand their menu.

Must order their cheesesteak pizza. It’s the BEST pizza I’ve ever had. It’s full of steak and caramelized onions and the seasonings are perfect. The family style salad is also a must have. It’s loaded with eggs, tomatoes, onions, and chickpeas with a vinaigrette dressing that’s delicious!

The wings are to die for! They are roasted and caramelized. The pizza is amazing. I love the martini specials on Wednesday nights – $ 5!

I am not a fan of pizza… and I am so picky on it .but this place make me change my mind .they make absolutely good pizza and good drink too
I love the way they make cocktail. real good. My friend oder it for me and I don’t know what the heck is name .
After took 20 minutes think what I want then I decide I want try pizza… lol because pizza place .
I Oder a calzone and my friend got salad chicken. My food was real good but not spicy thought I told them add more hot chilli lol. I would like come back gain and try other pizza

It didn’t suck. Let’s face it. Coal fired is superior pizza. But … at 15 bucks for a small pizza with one topping it needs to be amazing and it’s not.
Our pizzas had multiple over burned spots. I can ignore some charring on a slice or two but there was too much to avoid. Maybe due to being it being evening the dough was a bit stale too but overall it was underwhelming.
My gf is vegan and when attempting to order her pie we got a snide response from what appeared to be a high school girl working at the take out register. Asking for no cheese seemed to incite snark by then needlessly re confirming my pepperoni pizza could have cheese.
It didn’t help that a couple staffers seemed snooty which to me a busy building doesn’t mean you’re better than your customers. I don’t expect humility, I expect a welcoming attitude.
Overall not everyone should expect this experience but in the end it’s overpriced pizza.

Overall a decent pizza place and general, and much better than comparable pies in the vicinity.
We stopped in on a busy Saturday night and all of the tables were filled. Anthony’s has a (kind of loud) main dining room with a bunch of wooden tables, a bar area, lots of TV sets, and a small more intimate patio with a large fireplace thing in the center of it that looks like it came from one of the Hellraiser movies from the 80’s with a lot of little flames rising up. It looked intriguing and as much as I wanted to sit there with flames to my back and pizza to my front, all of the tables were filled up so we took home a pizza.
The menu itself is fairly limited and we chose one of their traditional pies which consists of Italian plum tomatoes, romano cheese, basil and olive oil. Overall the pizza was very good. The sauce was decent, the cheese was good (alas no buffalo mozzarella here) but I couldn’t detect much basil. The crust was a bit thinner than other places in town but not as thin as what you’d find at places like Zavino or Pizzeria Vetri in Philly. It was very charred on the bottom and a tad bit burned on the crust but it added a lot to the flavor. We really enjoyed the pizza and we would order it again. They also have lunch specials and a few other things on the menu but it seems somewhat limited.
The staff were very youthful and helpful, even offering containers of parmesan cheese and red pepper for the pizzas and opening the door for me when I left.