The Sticky Elbow

The food will NOT disappoint! Very modern atmosphere, prompt service, kid friendly and high quality food. We had fried broccoli, French fries with cheese and bison chili, Elk tenderloin, wings, corndogs and for dessert. White chocolate crème brûlée. Everything was amazing! Cooked to perfection. I will most definitely go there again and highly recommend it. It was pretty expensive and the only reason I didn’t give it 5 stars. Food was well worth paying more.

Nice find in Williamsport! We had rabbit, steak tacos, halibut, sushi and the meat loaf to name a few. All of the items were very good to excellent. The sushi is all tempura so if your actually looking for sushi this isn’t the place but what they do offer is very good. The bacon wrapped meatloaf with the Mac and cheese filling was off the chart. We also had some raw elk and holy $&!@ was that good. Great food and good service made for a 5 star visit

Best Williamsport dinner restaurant I’v eaten at. We had two different sushi entrees, gyro, and a shrimp salad. We loved them all. Great flavor and presentation.
Draft beer selection extensive.
It took us a long time to order with so many great sounding choices on the Menu.

OMFG The noise ruined the evening worst choice we could have made.
The Duck breast was cooked properly the sunny side up duck egg too the Orzo with apricot good but the Kim chi overwhelmed everything
My wife got stuffed meatloaf it was great except it was cold.
I think we would have to try it on another night to see if it was just a bad night.
It wasn’t even packed but the noise just kept increasing a table near us was full of Penn State butt holes.
Maybe for lunch?

Have been to Sticky Elbow several times over the last year and have always been impressed. For the area the food is inventive and well executed. This time I had beef tips and bacon over pasta with arugula cream sauce. It was nicely done with just a hint of spice to keep it interesting. The wine list is adequate but their infused liquors are where it’s at. If you are in the area you should definitely check this place out.

I ate at The Sticky Elbow with two other people. We each ordered something different, and none of us were impressed. Our waitress was great, but that doesn’t make up for what was mediocre food. My boyfriend got the T-​bone and he said the cut was poor so he had little meat. His sides were wonderful, but the price of the meal wasn’t justified by delicious potatoes and broccolini. I had the bacon burger. I wanted to like it, how can you go wrong with a burger and bacon? I found it to be so-​so, despite wanting so badly for it to be awesome. Perhaps it was an off day since they have so many great reviews. We don’t plan to go back though when there are so many options in the area that have not disappointed us.

My fiancé and I went on a Sunday night to avoid the crowd. The ambience was great. The staff was great the outside dining with fireplace was great. However the three stars is because of the food and the prices. I like how they have a variety of unusual foods for the area but that don’t mean anything if the food is only mediocre. It had no «wow» factor. Maybe I was expecting that because of the prices. I guess because we went during off peak hours that they didn’t have there prime chef working. However, if your just going out for drinks this is a nice safe pleasant place to go.

This was our first time eating food from The Sticky Elbow, we were in town for the night and saw the Unilocal Reviews and figured we should try it.
What a HUGE disappointment, I would have been better off eating at Burger King next door. We ordered a Caesar Salad with grapes and a toasted croûton. It was horrible and bland, there was no grapes, and the salad was wilted and gross. The croûton was soggy and bland with no flavor at all. I’ll post pics.
The Bacon Burger was a horrible failure as well. We asked for medium rare and got a burnt patty where all you could taste was burnt meat.
The pork belly tacos were just a tiny bit better but the Asian slaw was not good, it tasted and looked like it had been sitting out all day.
I want my $ 50 back. Too bad I will never be through this part of PA again as we are just driving through. I can’t complain to anyone as we picked up our food and they are now closed.
We seriously regretted not ordering Burger King next door the minute we saw the food. The food here wasn’t edible.

Bacon burger with smoked gouda, bacon and bacon aioli. Lots of fat and calories, but it’s worth it. The beef is cooked to a juicy medium rare and the smoky flavor of the gouda complements the bacon well! One of the best burgers I’ve had!
Braised rabbit with basil mashed potatoes is tender and delicious! The meat fell right off the bone.

Baseball Families… we were in the area for a tournament this weekend and stopped by here; Great food and a lot of it if ur hungry! had a wonderful veggie panini w/​great fries (like ya get at the beach), son had a huge plate of nachos (done to perfection), and my husbands wings were great, of course he had a beer with them! Nice and friendly waitress with great smile and good service! definitely try this place out!!!

This place ROCKS!!! Great food and excellent staff. I got the
SWEET POTATO BURGER
House made sweet potato and white bean patty topped with sliced avocado, lettuce, creamy dijon, and swiss cheese
You will not be disappointed if you try this!

Excellent restaurant. Very updated and relaxing bar area. Inside and outside dining. Full bar menu and great food menu. Great service.

What a find in Central PA! This Chef and menu could easily succeed in NYC. The seared scallops over cheesy grits with boisenberry sauce were perfectly cooked and seasoned, as was my duck breast. The crisp, slightly sweet Brussell slaw complimented the woodsy oyster mushroom sauce and risotto-​filled dumplings. Also on the menu is rabbit — hard to get around here — and everything from sushi to sandwiches. It was our servers first night, and she wasn’t as familiar with the menu as I would have liked, and she left the table empty handed without removing empty glasses/dishes…pet peeve. Beautiful neon deco bar with 2-​tops and high-​tops. We went at 730, noise level fine. Not sure about earlier, as there is only a partition between bar and dining area with booths and tables.

Based on other Unilocal reviews, decided to stop here for dinner on our way home from the Finger Lakes. Apps, soup, dinner… All delish! We started with the Drunkin corn dog and calamari. Hubs had the spicy duck wonton soup (very flavorful, but a bit salty). For dinner I had the filet (cooked perfectly) over a mushroom risotto and he had the hanger steak with basil mashed. We were waaayy too full for dessert, maybe next time. A definite must stop if you’re in the neighborhood.

My girlfriend and I wanted to go somewhere good to celebrate my new job, so we decided sticky elbow. Best choice! The ombiance was a nice surprise that you wouldn’t expect from the outside. I got the duck wonton (amazing) and the bison ribeye (incredible and perfectly Cooked [Pittsburgh rare, not many places can do that]). My girlfriend got the dry aged new York strip!!! It was HUGE!!! 2 inches thick easily! And again perfect cooked to order (mid-​rare)! We also got the fondue sampler as an appetizer… «Melting Pot» worthy!!! «In some ways I feel they put melting pot to shame”-My girlfriend. The drink were amazing! They have their own infused liquors that were perfect. They are very creative with their drinks. Our server who was also the bartender was very friendly and informative. She knew every item on the menu. No «let me go talk to the chef».
All-​in-​all I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking to have good food and leave full after a great meal!

My sister and I had a very nice time having dinner for a girls night out. We had very relaxing atmosphere in the upstairs dining area. The waitstaff was helpful when we were unsure about the menu selections.
The food they helped us choose was delicious.

Great selection of infused liquors, but beware of the pricing. Somewhere on the liquor menu, I believe it says that the price you see is per shot or ounce. Something like that. So when you order a drink made with it, it uses 2 – 3 times that much liquor and therefore, your drink is 2 – 3 times the price.
The atmosphere is great. Everything seems modern and clean. I’ve never had bad service here and there are always new, strange but delicious, specials to choose from. The Stick Elbow is great for trying something new and exotic or just an old favorite with a delicious new spin.

Found the restaurant on Unilocal… went because of reviews. I had the calamari which was great. Salad with roasted beets was ok… but, don’t advertise it as roasted beets and then give me beets from a can. Yuck. I asked for a substitution for the goat cheese… Server said it now came with blue cheese; they just hadn’t updated their menus. Nope-​salad came out with goat cheese, and I am not a fan.
Menu was interesting. Lots of choices and not run of the mill. I just thought it was ok.

Went for lunch with the family. Service was outstanding! Friendly… helpful…quick. OK… OK. When I am eating dinner, having a meal quick is not that important, but for lunch during the workday? Quick can be an issue.
We had a peta bread and jalapeño dip appetizer that was just yummy. I had a kangaroo burger that was very tasty. (one of the reasons we went was to try some of the wild game)…daughter had bison quesadillas… wife had a great Cobb salad, while the mother in law had just a good old fashioned hamburger. Everything was good.
Nice thing about the place is that although you can order some very unique meats, you don’t have to. The normal fare is good to.
Place was casual, clean, and very new looking. Someone has put some money into it and it shows.
We will be sure and go back many times.
P. S. decent selection of craft brew too!

Been here a few times and I absolutely love it! Such a hidden gem in Williamsport with a creative and sophisticated menu featuring foods you don’t see everyday. Great to find a place with a great burger or wings but also offering duck, shark, elk, quail, and bison too! Love their specialty cocktails (try the sticky arse!) and different infused alcohols (sour patch infused vodka). And ask for Tuesday or Michelle as your server!
So fun how they offer cream cheese tortilla rolls with a sweet chili sauce instead of bread and butter! My favorite appetizers have got to be the seafood scampi flatbread, lobster dip, and sticky fondue (with broccoli, pretzel bites, and lobster tempura!). The lobster bisque also has nice big chucks of lobster meat in it. I was also impressed with their kale salad, beet salad, and strawberry salad. For entrees my filet mignon was cooked perfectly, my date loved the crab stuffed lobster tail, and the mac n cheese stuffed meatloaf wrapped in bacon was incredibly rich and delicious! Portions here are filling so I’ve been too stuffed to try dessert yet but hopefully I will soon!