GoodFellas Pizza & Pasta

So I ordered the calamari no the greatest so dry. It used to be better I don’t know what happened my wife order the americano panini sandwich I guess they don’t have a panini sandwich maker. That sandwich was not flat I was so puffy and so greasy never again the good part was my kids enjoyed the pie. No worth 30 bucks

Were you hoping for home made pasta, hyper-​local farm to table poultry, authentic mediterranean or even just really good red sauce Jersey food amidst some post-​phidian drapery and old timey b/​w photos from various deCostello confirmation dinners? This place will disappoint you. Just want a perfectly crisp, perfectly sauced (this implies fresh!) cheese slice? Still, you will be disappointed.

The worst place ever. Do not order delivery from this place; wrong items being sent, clueless delivery driver, and awful customer service.

Would be more stars, but their pizza is just not that good and the delivery time is terrible.
Every time I have ordered from here (through Seamless), the quoted time is 40 – 50 minutes. Actual delivery time is ALWAYS twice that and sometimes more. The last order, I called at the 90 minute mark and asked about the delivery. I was cut off and asked my address, then told that it would be there shortly. Called back 20 minutes later (110 minute mark) and was cut off again and told it would be there shortly. When I pointed out that was what he told me 20 minutes ago, he replied that he said the driver was leaving shortly… Just ridiculous. Need to give an actual expectation of when something will be delivered. It’s a major problem when I place an order at 5:45pm and do not get it until 7:45pm.
I’ve ordered from here multiple times because their pasta dishes are great and they include a lot of sauce, which my wife and I like. We’ve tried a half-​dozen different pasta dishes and they are all great.
I haven’t tried the Grandma pizza, but have had the deluxe and the stuffed meat pizzas. Both tasted ok, but there was almost no sauce on the regular pizza and extremely dry and thin crust. The stuffed pizza had almost no toppings inside and was extremely thin. The crust was about 2 inches around the entire pizza, which tells you how far they ‘stuffed’ this pie. NOT worth the price paid. I’ve had stuffed pizzas at a ton of places and this is by far the skimpiest. Better off sticking with the calzones and not the pizza here.

Good pizza. The Grandpa Style pie was very good.

We order pizza from here ALL the time, love the homemade taste, really the best pizza on this side of town.

We just tried out this restaurant this evening and it gets only one star because the sauce is very bland on both the pizza and the eggplant parm. My 7 and 9 year olds had to add plenty of garlic powder, oregano, basil and pepper to make the pizza flavorful. I had to do the same with the eggplant. Unfortunately we won’t return because I expect more taste for the price.

I am in love with their Grandma pie. It is perfection. Normally it is very crispy almost burnt. I hear people enjoy it like that, I do not. When I order it I ask for it not to be that well done. It is super addictive.

I’m not sure what’s up with the other reviews but my friend and I ordered a large pie… half margherita and half pepperoni during the WO St. Patty’s parade (so while they were very busy) and both of us thought the pizza was excellent! Crust was delicious. We ended up ordering later in the night with other friends and pasta fagioli was yummy too.

All I can say is the other posters are right! I went in with a friend to try this place out, we both ordered just one slice of pizza each. We ordered only the one slice each because just looking at the pizza you knew that it wasn’t going to be any good. I’m glad we didn’t waste our hard earned money on a whole pie or a dinner, because walking out with our slices to go, we took a few bites and tossed then in the trash can on the street.

Food was tasteless, overpriced, and gave my entire family food poisoning. Warning do not eat the Goodfellas Chicken! We were unable to celebrate my daughter’s 6^th birthday, because we were all sick and fighting for a toilet!!! Had we known we would have had to forego my kids party due to the vomiting and diarrhea we experienced as a result of this food, we would’ve cooked instead. This place is No Good, Fellas!

Stopped in for a little dinner before a movie. Cute little place with a few tables, though mostly for takeout. Pizza was absolutely excellent! Also had some chicken francaise with pasta, which was very good. Will definitely return when in area.

Ordered pizza and breadsticks. Prompt delivery but after having one bite my girlfriend and I both agreed it was the worst pizza we have ever had. I was incredibly disappointed and tossed the rest. AVOID AT ALL COSTS!

Pizza and sandwiches are ok and price fairly.