Flyers Pizza & Subs

You ever hear the saying «It takes a lot of balls to golf like me.» Well, it takes a lot of olives to charge $ 20 for a pizza this awful. If this pizza was free I wouldn’t be upset, I would say «you get what you pay for.» however, for this money… shut this place down. Our pizza had a tangy, really sweet taste that overpowered everything. If you put a gun to my head and asked me to reverse engineer the pizza sauce, I would say ketchup with white sugar and a whole lot of screw-​the-​customer. Save yourself the money. A frozen pizza is world’s better.

This location is HORRIBLE compared to other locations. Absolutely no customer service. We were never brought chips, other people’s food sat cold when they picked it up. They didn’t even have the tvs on. Will not come back to this location.

We’ve lived in Hilliard and now West Jeff. And Flyers has always been our goto pizza/​wings/​salad. I must say we ordered the trio the other night and the pizza was the most outstanding pie we’ve had in West Jeff to date. Their sauce is always rich and slightly sweet, balanced with the freshest veggies & quality sausage. Their ingredients don’t get dumped from a can. The crust is always consistent and cooked perfectly. We usually have our orders delivered and they always beat the time given at ordering. Eat flyers and be Happy!

I’m not entirely sure what’s going on at this location, but the pizza I had here was NO where near what I was used to eating from Flyers in the past.
The pizza I got was some cheap pepperoni and processed cheese on top of a thick layer of water down sauce (practically ketchup) on a floppy square cut crust. The pepperoni had WAY too many spices littered on them to be considered appetizing, and I left here feeling pretty bad I just paid that much money for crappy pizza.
Service here was lacking and the girl forgot part of our order and then yelled back in the kitchen as to where our order was, which was then followed by a redneck sounding «Wut?»
Yeah… not a good sign, so we took a refund.
The only thing going for this place was the subs were decent, and the place was pretty clean a spacious for families and the décor is neat for aviation enthusiasts, or kiddos who have an interest in planes, but I would much rather hit up one of the other pizza places in town, then ever come back here for pizza.
I am still perplexed how they got this «Top 100 Pizza» award they tout on everything including their plastic cups… I’m thinking it must have been for Ethiopia, because their pizza really did not scream «Top 100» in my books. Such a disappointment.

Aw Tonni’s Pizza now known as Flyers. I grew up on this place. I have to say they have the best Hawiian Pizza ever. The subs are very tasty but a little expensive for the little amount you get. It has a nice dine in area, free drink refills, and is located in a great town. Any time I am in West Jefferson I stop here and eat.