Hot Bagels

Nastiest bagels in town not sure why it’s called hot bagels they are cold and soggy undercooked the owners are rude steer clear to many other good options

Once in a rare while I venture over to West Islip for the bagels in which I have set my standards by since I was a teenager.
Turns out this place was not even on the Unilocal map yet! I am astonished by this. It is so befitting and such an honor to be the one to add them.
Know what I think? West Islip is protecting their little hidden diamond where the bagels are so gooey and warm that all is right in the world with a bite. Its just not fair, we all should have these sexy simple classic bagels.
Fancy cream cheeses and salads they are not– this place is old school. They do however do egg sandwiches, which I cant even think of right now or I will stop writing and head back in for one and Im way to full already. My buttered bagel was 2.67 with coffee– There are no tables but your bagel will not make it out if the parking lot alive I assure you.
If you come in here tell em I sent you– they wont know who you are talking about but the shy 14 year old inside me who has adored this place since the doors opened back in the early 90s will feel honored.