Alfredo’s Pizza

This review is for the customer service. They are not friendly at all in this pizzeria. It’s possible they think they don’t have to be because the pizza is on point.

The regular pizza was good, the Fried sampler dish was nice with a few different things in it. The Baked clams were good with a bit too much stuffing for me. Next to taste will be the Tortellini Alfredo.

I picked up a pie from Alberto’s and had them make it very well done, just the way I like it. I have grabbed slices from there on my way to the 50 Yardline before, many times.
This being the first time I’ve gotten a whole pizza I can now say they make a very tasty pie. You can’t go wrong with them and I know the owners and others who work at The 50 order dinner from here weekly and rave about it.

This is my favorite pizza place in Suffolk so far! I LOVE their Eggplant Rollatini pizza with the ricotta… it’s so amazing! I could eat it every day. Yum!

I’m a regular, I’m originally from Brooklyn and I love their pizza I couldn’t give a shitless how they cut it I’m eating it all anyway

Pizza is eh. Flavorless. Cooked well, but no flavor. Garlic knots seem to be reheated from a frozen state. Pinwheels are just gross. I ordered one, got two jammed in the bag with the knots. I wasnt sure what they were at first, since one looked nothing like the other. Online ordering was a great convenience, but there was a $ 2 delivery charge, and its simply not worth it. My two year old had three bites and didnt go back for more. Sadly disappointing.

Pizza is great for the price but they can’t cut a pizza if their lives depended on it. Every time we get a pizza, the slices are uneven and sometimes some cuts overlap causing random mini slices. It’s rarely ever cut all the way through either. But that’s a first world problem. The pizza tastes great and it’s super cheap. :)

Their pizza is good for the price, but they seem to have issues cutting the slices when you get a pie. Perhaps it’s time for a new pizza cutter. Other than that they are pretty good. They always have good deals.

I order there meatball pie atleast 2x a week. Fast super fresh. They also have good pasta dishes too! I changed my review because they delivered to the wrong address and the last couple times forgot things.

One of the better pizza’s I have had on Long Island. I recommend keeping it simple.

Their pizza isn’t the best but they have great wings. That’s what I mostly order from them.

This is one of the better pizza spots on Long Island, when not busy. I tried it three times and three different visits each time. The pizza is very good as is the chicken rolls. If you are really hungry the stuffed slice (meat or veggies) is a great pick.
Ordered Baked Zitti w/​sasuage, a fav of mine, on the first visit, it was by far the best I have ever had. Got it again the second time, but they didnt add ricotta, when I asked why they guy said «you didnt ask» so I told him I had it like that the first time without askind and h said, «must have been a mistake». There was no trying to fix it. Got it again the third time and asked for ricotta, but it tasted like my 10 yr old made it. The sause was like water and the sausage was tasteless.
I give the pizza and every thing in the front an A+ Hot food gets an F as does the customer service when they are busy.
If you have time and are ordering counter food only this is a good spot, I will give the internet offers a shot.

Still not the best pizza around, but it has improved lately. We like it for a pick-​up pie on the way home. I find their Sicilian pie to be better than their regular pie, which is skimpy on the sauce, for sure.

Oh my god we order from here at least 3 to 4 times monthly we usually get the holy cow it’s a great special

good chicken rolls, good pizza best part is the meal deals on the website …