Aggie’s Bakery & Cake Shop

Outstanding French butter cookies and pecan butter cookies. I happened past this bakery via a detour from the interstate. I purchased a half pound of the pecan butter cookies, a ¼ lbs. of the Turtle cookies and ¼ lbs. of the French butter cookies. I tried the Turtle cookies first and thought mediocre. What I did not expect was the buttery, crispy, and tasty flavor and texture of the French butter and Pecan butter cookies. They are simply amazing. They are pricey at $ 15 a pound but well worth it. For butter cookies, this is the place to go. Although the price seems high for these little marvels of taste, they are on par in price with my favorite place for other cookies — Sciortino’s on Brady Street.

Went for Sunday ham and rolls and was very impressed. I really enjoyed the fresh rolls and gourmet ham. They were busy and the service was still very quick. I have found my new favorite Sunday stop.

Aggies is the place to go when you want good coffee, great bakery treats, friendly staff, and a welcoming environment. We have been there about 6 times now, and everything has been consistent. The other coffee places may have larger drink menus, but can’t compare to the extraordinary treats in the bakery case. The pastry rack behind the register has less expensive donut type selections, which we have tried, and are good, but treat yourself to a turnover, tart, or any of the picture perfect pastries.

My wife’s aunt introduced us to Aggie’s on a recent visit to West Allis — we stopped 2 more times before leaving for Arkansas. Great customer service, great bakery and awesome coffee!
Get your own soon!

I read about your shop awhile ago and never made it down. My hubby just went out for donuts with our son and surprised me with YOURS!!! I cannot tell you how awesome it was to just look at your donuts in the box. They are beautiful and just scream «I WASNT MADE FROM A PROCESSED BAG OF JUNK.» They look homemade and taste like it too. I love love love this! Ate too much but I’m seriously so excited about you guys. Thank you for existing! We will be back very soon… but not too soon… ill get a big butt!

I didnt have time to grab a lot of items, only a couple glazed and I was out. The donut was standard nothing socks-​blown-​off-​ish I could be wrong I would need to try other things. The people working were really nice and pleasant. I did see what looked like a peanut bacon strip long john. I dont eat bacon but if I did im that it would be awesome. Im sure Elvis is working his way back threw the earth to grab that donut. I’ll stop back and you should as well.

What a wonderful find! Thanks for moving to West Allis and bringing such beautiful cakes done by incredibly talented decorators (Sara– thank you), and the cakes are as delicious as they look! We really needed a uniquely and diverse bakery ! You will not be disappointed from doughnuts to pastries to special occasion cakes– this is your go to !!! Absolutely delicious!!! They even have fresh brewed coffee!

Aggie’s is one of mine and my husbands favorite places! I could eat everything in there, especially the mini cheesecakes! Always accommodating every visit we’ve had, but specifically our last visit! Anna was the BEST!!! She was not only extremely helpful, but funny as well! And she went above and beyond for my husband and I! I would like to thank her and Aggie as well for helping us out! We would recommend this bakery to anyone!

This place is great. Aggie is a very nice person. Me and my wife were treated so well by Anna and Aggie. They go above and beyond the call of duty. Would recommend their chessecake cupcakes and amazing pastries.

Their talent is far beyond most bakeries in Milwaukee. Check out the picture. It’s an amazing casino cake which was a piece of art to take in… unfortunately, because I love cake so much… I had to sacrifice art for my stomach. Delicious… If you’re looking for a specialty cake– go no other place.

Best apple fritters ever!
I’ve eaten many apple fritters and these are so delicate and delicate. Apple chucks crunchy. Just the best around. Go here and buy many.

We got our wedding cake from here. It looked beautiful and tasted great! Staff is very helpful and easy to work with. I definitely recommend Aggies

For our wedding last year, we decided to get our cake from Aggie’s. They were great to work with – although they switched locations since. When we purchased the cake last year, they told us that, on our one-​year anniversary, we could get a complimentary cake. Our one-​year anniversary was this year and, even though we didn’t have a receipt, and also called in to order the cake two weeks late (and were late picking it up!), they had had our cake ready. It was BEAUTIFUL! I didn’t think they would go through all the trouble to decorate it, but they did a great job. I was pleasantly surprised. Definitely would recommend Aggie’s! Great cake, great service, very flexible!

I love Aggie’s! I tried a bunch of cake places before going to Aggie’s for my wedding and was thoroughly disappointed. I wanted a beautiful cake design but I also wanted it to taste good. The minute I walked into Aggie’s I knew it was going to be great. The ladies who work there are fantastic. They have excellent customer service and really took the time to speak with me about my ideas and what they could do for me. And the cake! It tasted so amazing on my big day. The design was flawless and they were so easy to communicate with. I highly recommend them for any event! There prices are very fair and they are just wonderful people. People were raving about the cake! Thanks again for making my event a night I’ll never forget.

Beautiful new store, reasonable prices and excellent cake! Plus you can’t beat a place that will make you a novelty cake on less than a day’s notice!

Best cupcakes in Milwaukee. It’s a cute shop with a good selection. The only downside is there is no parking lot.

Trouble… with a capital T.
Why? Because it a few blocks from my house, and i simply love it. I’ve now picked up a dozen of donuts for the office (everyone loved them, the only complaint was that i only got one long john… and everyone knows that i get the long john, so next time i’ll get more long johns). But a great selection, the service is great, everyone is so friendly.
I can’t wait to order one of their cakes.
I keep getting this cinnamon crumble thing (it has some frosting, crumble, its like muffin shape). its great.
Ham and rolls on Sunday, gonna take advantage of that sometime soon!
Another great addition to a slowly reviving and exciting downtown West Allis. Thank you Aggie’s for joining our great city!
OH! they serve Stone Creek Coffee. period… space space.

I went there to order a cake for my housewarming celebration. When I arrived to order the cake there was a lot of people waiting to order which was fine. When it was my time, I told the lady I wanted to place an order for a cake. The lady asked a young girl if she would like to take my order, she bluntly said no. I was immediately taken back and was about to walk out. I thought it was so rude and unprofessional. I decided to stay because I know how great the cake taste. I never order before. I tried the cake at another family function. So they lady finally came over and offered me coffee and asked if I could have a seat and wait about 5 minutes. I told her no I knew exactly what I wanted to order. She was not happy about taking my order. She did and once done she said you did know what you want. It was a bad experience but the cake was beautiful and tasted great when I returned.

My husband and I decided to check this location out because we always went to the south side location.
This location is definitely bigger than their south side location. There was a lot of different bakeries to choose from that I had to take a long time to figure out what I wanted. I ended up settling on the mini fruit tarts and they were delicious. My husband got several donuts and he said they were yummy.
Their other baked goods (cakes, etc) look delicious too — I will be back to try the others.
It was nice to see that hey had a separate area for wedding cake tasting and all stuff wedding related.
**We had them do our wedding cake & cupcakes and we were very happy with the work they did.

Stepped in just before they were closing and grabbed a box of doughnuts. They were super delicious! I’ll definitely be stopping in again!

I ordered a cake on a Thursday for a Saturday. All that was available is what they refer to as a «quick» cake. Really, how many days in advance should really be necessary to order a cake from a bakery? I opted for vanilla with raspberry filling and buttercream frosting. I wanted it decorated but was shocked that the little bit of decorating I requested added one third of the cost or, $ 15 to the cost of the cake. Total price for a quarter sheet cake was just under $ 50, a bit pricey! The cake was most definitely from a mix and incredibly dense, the butter cream was unremarkable and most guests left it on the side of their plates and the raspberry filling was very gelatinous and obviously came from a container at a cake supply shop. I was told the buttercream was «homemade» but I find that hard to believe. Nothing at all remarkable here except for the price paid for a below average cake that I went way out of my way to get. I wanted the day to be extra special and this cake in no way helped me achieve that outcome! There have to be better bakeries in town with cakes that are made from scratch and taste delicious. Aggie’s is most definitely not one of them!

Yes, Aggie’s Bakery made a mistake on my quick cake order. Did Aggie’s Bakery have the customer service that we all pray for in a bind like that? Most definitely. Unfortunately, the cake I ordered based off of the website was a different cake than the one the employee was looking at on her in-​store computer. I walked in at 11:00 and my cake was fixed by 11:25. I relieved an apology and an offer for some sort of throw-​in to settle the score. I politely declined because I was so pleased to have the cake I ordered in my hands so quickly after what I thought was going to be a disaster. Oh, and the taste?! It was decadent: moist chocolate cake with a sweet chocolate buttercream. A giant hit at the party. Thanks, Aggie’s for the fix! But please, fix the website to match your move and new cake numbers.

Experience– I arrived around 5pm on a Tuesday. The storefront was very clean and kept. Greeting my wife and I immediately was one of the owners, I assume. Brunette in her 40’s. Seemed desperate for a sale while watching my every move. Unfortunately, it was uncomfortable to even look at the selections. Despite the pressure I purchased a chocolate bliss cupcake, salted caramel cupcake, mini cheesecake, and a mini éclair. The cupcakes tasted no better than store bought mix. Hello Betty Crocker. The éclair was ok. And my wifes reaction to the mini cheesecake, «Meh».
Damn! I really hoped for more!
Pros–
Inexpensive.
Clean and inviting.
Local business.
Family friendly.
Cons–
Low quality product.
Pressure to make a purchase.
Unprofessional staff. (the gent appearing to be reconciling one of the registers swore during an exchange with me about Home Depot experiences.)
Sweet Perfections in Waukesha is my bakery of preference. It’s twice the price of Aggie’s. But, you’ll understand why once you try it!

I was in the area and was looking for a coffee shop in the area. While i failed to find the coffee shop called Hawthorne coffee which led me to this address, i am soooooooo happy i saw this bakery.
First of all this place is very nice as you walk in. Clean and trendy!
I took red velvet cupcake, cream cheese muffin and chocolate dome like thing .
Loved everything except the chocolate dome ((can’t remember the name)
Btw, they also have coffee. I tried a late and it was of high quality.
I would recommend trying out this place if you are in the area.
I also saw a lot of beautiful and modern wedding and tiered cake on display so if you are looking for custom cakes looks like they seem to do a great job!

I almost don’t want to give a review to keep the crowds away! However, I want people to go to keep this wonderful place in business. I stopped in here a couple weeks ago and return every week. The prices are so affordable and everything is SO good. My favorites are the apple fritters (best that I have had) and the paczki for Fat Tuesday.

I went here yesterday for the first time and had a pleasant experience. The selection was great, even in the hour before close. I bought a selection of items from the bakery. There was donuts, including custard filled and frosted, flavored crumb cakes, pecan fingers (my favorite), cupcakes, cupcheesecakes, and eclairs. Everything we tried was superb! The flavor was rich and nothing tastes dry or stale. When visiting I heard about hot ham and rolls on Sunday. I returned this morning to buy some and included a couple more bakery items. Once again, everything was amazing. Ham was savory and juicy. All of the bakery items are just so good! Not to mention the customer service was fantastic! Both times I had great conversations with the employees.
While my diet is out of luck, I am happy to see Aggie’s here! Let me be the first of many that will say, welcome to West Allis!