Jersey Mike’s Subs

DO NOT get a wrap from here. Every time I ordered a wrap the wrap itself is soggy and completely falling apart. They messed up my order as well one time when I asked for a grilled chicken wrap and they gave me it on a hoagie roll. My most recent visit, the girl working forgot to put mayo on my sub as well. Too many mistakes and under trained staff, will not return.

Went to Jersey Mikes in Wayne after i saw them on the tv show Food Paradise. The subs were very fresh and tasty. the prices on the other hand not to good. Way to hi. The men that worked there very nice and polite. Will go again.

I wanted to provide an update since the owner of Jersey Mike’s sent me a message along with a very generous offer to come back and give his shop another try in response to my original review. Sure, why not?
I did return but I did not contact the owner. I wanted to know if in fact the wrap I received was indeed sub par or if it was ‘typical’ of what they normally serve day in and day out. Would I have really known either way if the owner got involved?
So, I ordered the same wrap and, unfortunately, received basically the same wrap again. Sorry Matt but this wrap, along with the first one, were definitely not ‘piled high with quality meat’ as you can clearly see from the photo. I will not spend that kind of money for basically a lettuce wrap with a few slices of meat in between.

Good subs. Good service. Bubba is great. Good prices too. Good team effort and people are friendly there.

Hey, I wanted to update my review because the owner ended up reaching out to me saying that the coupons were a mistake and they should have been accepted. He was very generous in his message. If I still lived around the area, I’d give it another chance. I love the Jersey Mikes down in my hometown, so hopefully this place is just as good.

Went there and had a buffalo chicken cheesesteak, I asked for the giant size. Total price alone $ 14.93. Sandwich came and it was very large «that’s what she said». But 2 inches on each side was light on steak. It was very good but just got the job done. For that price I expect not to finish it. Vinnys pizzarama next door has a cheesesteak half the price just as good. If I can’t have lunch for under 10 $ I’m out, sorry but I’m poor

I couldn’t wait for this place to open. Mike’s Subs were the subs I grew up with. Back when there were only 2 stores in Pt. Boro, my family stopped at Mike’s for subs to bring to the beach, soccer games, school events, birthday parties, etc., etc. A real Mike’s sub was stuffed with cold cuts and if you wanted it with everything you got shredded lettuce, tomato, and onion with oil, vinegar, and oregano. What is Mike’s way? To me, it is a way to overcharge for bread and iceberg lettuce with cheap oil, a scant amount of cold cuts and oregano. Nostalgia aside, Jersey Mike’s is nothing like Mike’s Subs used to be — not even close, especially the 2 franchises in Wayne and West Orange.
The Wayne store has a more airy interior and more visible management than the West Orange store with it’s Subway vibe, but the quality of the subs at West Orange is better. I ordered subs from the Wayne store for a lunch meeting and I was bragging about how good they are. Turns out the tuna sub (giant size) had about ¼ cup of tuna on the whole sub and was completely soggy due to wet lettuce and too much oil and vinegar, which I asked for on the side. The Chipotle chicken wrap had the same issue, it was too wet due to the wet lettuce used.
I gave 2 stars because management corrected the situation by covering my next lunch order the following week. Again, I brought these subs to a lunch meeting and all of us were in agreement that the quality of these subs is definitely lacking. There are so many delis in the area that make a better sandwich, so I won’t be back and I am so disappointed that the Jersey Mike’s franchise has completely missed the mark of what Mike’s Subs used to be.

Excellent service. FRESH ingedients. Split a 15″ roast beef sub with my husband. We will definitely be back again to try many of their other selections.

Jersey shore up north! The subs are sooooooo good! Meat is fresh, sliced fresh. bread is yummy, and «Mike’s way» tops off the sub.

I have been going since the place opened up. Love the number 6! Mgr Bubba is always friendly and so is the rest of the staff. Love that I control the toppings and I love the Mike’s Juice! If you haven’t been I suggest you give the place a try!

The moment the Wayne Subways has been dreading has finally arrived. Far superior sandwiches for just a little more coin.

Jersey Mike’s has the best subs around no other place compares to Jersey Mike’s when I comes to quality and the pricing of their foodI go to this jersey Mike’s at least twice a week for lunch and it is awesome great environment

Went there for lunch today staff was very friendly and helpful the sub I had #2 was very good and made well best subs around give it a try

Good food, good price and great addition to Wayne. Jersey Mike’s Subs and Firehouse opened about the same time directly across the street from each other and after trying both Jersey Mike’s is definitely the better choice. This is a great alternative to subway, more pricey but worth it for the quality meat which they cut right in front of you. Will be returning often!

This was my first ever visit to a Jersey Mike’s Subs. The location is the former Let’s Yo froyo address. This was Grand Opening weekened. It was packed when I arrived on a Saturday at noon. There were perhaps 10 people ahead of me and then 10 people behind me. I ordered the chicken Big Kahuna Cheese Steak. I didn’t expect too much but it was pretty awesome. I bought a regular size but should had bought larger. I listened to Pharrell Williams’ «Happy» as I ate my sandwich and watched the never ending line. I’m sure the new Firehouse Subs across the street was just as busy. After the local Quizno’s failed, it’s strange to have so many sub shops in the same location now.