Benitos Pizzeria & Restaurant

We stop here on the way back from Minerals or Action Park pretty often. The pizza is great and the antipasto id very authentic — not a typical pizza parlor antipasto. It’s not fancy but the staff is friendly, the food is great, and the prices are reasonable so what’s not to like?

Every once in a while we order a pie from here. I don’t know why we keep on doing this. Their pizza is not very good. It’s usually over cooked and has an off taste that I can’t describe. I think the dough is a little sour or something. The other food on the menu is pretty standard fare for a pizza joint. If you want a decent pie go to Pizza Express in Florida NY.

This is our go to family pizza place — consistently good pizza and eggplant parm. The counter staff is always pleasant, as are the people making the food. Twenty years of consistently good food for us at this restaurant.

Best place on the face of this earth to dine or have a pizza! We frequent there quite often!
Staff is very friendly, service is great, Silvio and Benny make fantastic soups and dishes!
C U @ Benito!

Decided to order a pie while visiting family. Had found this place on google and called in for a large onion and mushroom pizza. I picked up the pie to find out that they only take cash. No where on their website did it say that (probably don’t want to lose customers, because I wouldn’t have ordered from them if I knew). They had an ATM, which takes several fees out without always getting authorization (which took up more of my time because I had to call my bank to let them no I didn’t authorize all those fees).
So already, before even eating this pizza I’m feeling like it wasn’t worth it. I get back to the house and have a slice and it was awful! The mushrooms were not fresh but obviously canned. The pizza was so salty that I couldn’t even stomach it. I wouldn’t recommend this place to people I hate. For the price I paid for the pizza, I expect fresh ingredients and pleasant taste, but that wasn’t something this place was capable of.

I was looking for a place to eat some real food after a day of apple picking. My friend and I stopped here because it was open and on our route home. I was a little skeptical when I saw that it was cash-​only, but they do have an ATM for those in need. I ordered a chicken parmigiana hero, my friend ordered ravioli in vodka sauce, and they told us to have a seat while we waited. It was pretty empty, so we had our choice of tables. Being mid-​October, there were some great Halloween decorations up. While we waited they brought our drinks and some warm, soft bread — we each got our own small loaf. The meals themselves were bigger than I’d expected, and really, really good. All in all, I’d say we made a lucky find!

My wife and I were going around town trying all the pizzerias in Warwick hoping to find a place closer then Franks in West Milford, this was our last stop for the day. We only got the pizza lots a cheese and the dough was a thin and crisp potentially our new go to pizza place until I took a bite. Where was the sauce? All I tasted was cheese and dough, so weird. I see the sauce but I just don’t taste it. So sad people my knows speak so highly of this place.

Call me spoiled because I live in NYC and literally have access to the best pizzerias that exist, both regular pizzerias and good old fashioned spots like Grimaldi’s where you have to wait an average 45min-​1hr. Like i stated in previous reviews, I used to live in Warwick and in all fairness I don’t really like any pizza joint in the area (sorry J&J, and Franks). I mean I don’t even think this place is decent AND on top of that you don’t take debit cards??! Joints like this just get me mad, bring your establishment into 2015 and upgrade to take cards! Conveniently there is a machine right there to take cash from… real coincidence right? Anyway, if you are a pizza lover like myself or have standards for pizza don’t waste your time, if you are from out of town and find other spots nearby to dine. Main street aka «town» is about 6min away with other options. With this being said, I suppose living in a small town there aren’t that many options besides this place and two other spots which aren’t on their A-​game either. Warwick needs a LEGIT pizza spot and I’m sure they would thrive. I rather get D’gorono from ShopRite frozen section but that’s just me.

Perfect spot for a casual Italian meal. Very friendly service, awesome pizza and pasta. Their sicilian pizza is one of my personal favorites.

A celiac friend of mine recommended that they had gluten-​free pasta & pizza here, but the experience was disappointing. The combination of awful premade crust (which tastes like apple cider vinegar) and cheap cheese (which tastes like rubber) combined with meager toppings to make a frustratingly tiny (maybe a thin 6-​inches?) and unsatisfying pizza which will cost you more than $ 11.
The regular pizza (I’ve been told) is salty and mediocre, but at least you get a decent portion.
Pay the $ 3.50 for a bob’s mix, buy some sauce/​cheese/​toppings, and make two HUGE tasty home-​made pizzas the way you like them (and actually have leftovers!) You’ll be happy you did.

Honestly, for my money, best pizza around. Nothing fancy just good eats! My family has been going there for years and they’re all very friendly. I’ve even had them cater two parties we’ve had. I try not to leave Warwick without getting a couple slices and some garlic knots.
And yes, cash only.

Yummy place to grab a quick slice or sit in the dinning room to grab a casual Italian meal. No matter what kind of pizza you get you won’t be disappointed. The wings aren’t to shabby either. Oh and if you want to grab some pasta, try the penne a la vodka. It super creamy. Just don’t forget to bring your cash — they don’t take credit cards :-(

A great little italian & pizza place just outside the village of Warwick. Pizza to go, or sit in the dining room. Garlic knots and personal pies are very good. Cash or check only. No delivery.