Flour Girl Cakes, Inc.

I wanted to like this place so badly. I’m always on the hunt for great baked goods and I gave this place a go. Unfortunately the cupcake I got was dry and crumbly and the frosting «cap» kind of cracked off when I took one bite. Didn’t seem fresh. I got a small box of mixed stuff, knowing not every place will have the best of everything.
I was surprised to see cake pops still holding on as a trend. So I bought a couple of those and they weren’t terrible but the chocolate had a wax-​like film leftover in my mouth. They seemed dry too.
Their prices were a bit high for Long Island but I’ll say a lot of the stuff looked pretty but I just got the feeling it looked more processed by a machine. The icing on a couple of other cupcakes I got was also very sugary beyond what I’d expect.
I won’t give up on this place completely yet, because I know there’s more to try but I honestly wouldn’t make a special trip at this point. My best advice would be if in doubt about freshness throw it out.

I work down the street and someone always brings in their crumb cake. Its so delicious. Must try!

We stumbled on Flour Girl while driving around looking for a bakery, and felt like we hit the lottery! Absolutely beautiful presentations of seasonal and other cookies, cakes, cupcakes, chocolate and more. It was hard to settle on just a few things, since everything looked beautiful. And we confirmed later that it all tasted just as good. The black-​and-​white cookie in particular was terrific. We’ll plan to stop here whenever we are in the area.

The Crumb cake is delicious! co worker brought it in today, I had four pieces already.

Bought 6 assorted cupcakes — terrible terrible terrible ! They were stale and dry worse than packaged tasty cakes ! Rainbow cookies were good though.

Stopped in today for first visit and was super impressed! The store smells delicious and so do all the baked goods. Peanut butter cookie was heavenly, crumb cake was impressive and apple turnover was superb. Staff was friendly and professional — a nice change from the prior bakery.
Welcome to the neighborhood!