Market Street Grill

We were in town for a baseball tournament and love to try local places, this place had some good reviews so we decided to give it a try:(very disappointed! We were set down immediately and brought water which was nice but then our main waitress was very slow and distracted we ordered an appetizer of onion rings and our meal was delivered before the appetizer we were almost done eating our meal and we stopped our waitress and asked to cancel the appetizer, she came back to our table and said unfortunately the onion rings are done now so we can’t cancel, we will box them up for you though, uhhhh NO lol we then explained we were done eating our meal and they were supposed to be appetizers? She eventually came back and said they would go ahead and take them off the bill??? Really? The drunken chicken was terrible! If you like more breading than chicken and soggy at that, you might like it? The menu says its in a wine sauce? It tasted more like cream of chicken soup to me? The strawberry butter and blue cheese dressing wedge salad was very good. My husband got the bourbon pork chops, they were tough but good flavor and his baked beans were good. Overall we wish we would have went to Twenty across the street:(!

Great dinner before going to a concert at Honeywell. Drunkin Chickin didn’t disappoint, nor did the Hoosier fav of tenderloin. Our friends both had rib eyes which looked delicious. We even came back after the concert for dessert. Cheesecakes of all kinds. We shared the peanut butter pie which was delicious and rich. Fresh decaf to boot. Suzanne was our server and she was charming, funny, and efficient. Sweeet little place.

Food quality is a little less each time. Only thing still great is the Long Island. Love that no children are allowed, take them elsewhere. Adults are allowed to have some alone time.

We were in town for a special event and tried to eat here but they wouldn’t serve us. They are «adult only» dining and we had a baby in our party. What a crappy policy in a town with very few restaurants. We could have ordered food to go but I would rather go to Pizza Hut than give my money to this establishment.

Stopped by here last month during a business trip. Quaint little spot right in the heart of downtown, plenty of booths to sit at and a nice looking bar area. The restaurant is filled with tchotchkes but had a great nostalgic feel to it. Server was super-​nice and very friendly when taking our order and serving our meals.
We all started off with a specialty of theirs… BLT soup. It was creamy and really did taste like a BLT sandwich!
For dinner several of us tried the drunkin’ chicken (I had mine with a side salad). The salad was large and full of «typical» veggies, their ranch dressing was just fine. The chicken breast they served was HUGE! It was breaded and deep fried, then covered with their mushroom cream sauce which had a bit of a tang to it. The flavor was nice, but the dish turned out to be a bit monotonous.
Overall, a nice place for a meal in a very comfortable atmosphere.

Drove out of my way only to get there and be told by a rude staff that they are closed at 2 and will reopen at 5. Very disappointing to know that customers are not important to them. At least I know not to bring my customers here for dinner.

If you’re in Wabash or coming here for a concert give this place a try. Quick service and great portions.
Leslie was our server and had a great knowledge of the menu and made some excellent recommendations. The Pulled Bacon BLT WAS AMAZING!!!

Sub par food and service. Their Greek salad wasn’t Greek by any means, and the food was expensive for as little and as greasy/​sub par it was. Probably won’t go back. We were very disappointed. Not to mention our waitress was only nice to us when she brought out bill. Save your money and go somewhere else!

Every now and then, especially after a mediocre experience, we think that perhaps we’ve taken Burger Quest far enough. But then something wonderful happens! That wonderful something today was Market Street Grill in historic downtown Wabash. Formerly an industrial business in days of yore, the building has been renovated into the jewel it is today with its rich woods, memorabilia from all over the country, and classic but classy, cozy atmosphere. We had just stepped through the door when we were welcomed by our server who led us to a comfortable booth on the side opposite the barroom. In no time flat we had menus, a «specials sheet» and 2 ice cold beers and it was time to get to the business of ordering our beefy conquests. The Grill’s lunch menu offers 3 styles of ½-​lb. hand-​pattied steakburgers: Marcy’s Market Street Grill Burger ($ 9.50), Create Your own Burger ($ 7.99), and a Veggie Burger ($ 7.99). Each comes with the customer’s choice of a vast array of side dishes at no extra cost. I requested Marcy’s Market Street Grill Burger which was covered with Swiss & American cheeses, Marcy’s own relish, lettuce, onion, tomatoes, dill pickle, mayo, ketchup & mustard. Altering this burger is NOT an option. You take it as it is or you don’t get it. But we wondered why anyone would think of adding or omitting anything from this work of art. My wife chose to create my own burger, dressing it with bleu cheese, red onion, bacon and dill pickles on an onion bun. Although I couldn’t find any exposed meat on my sandwich my wife’s customary «bare burger bite» proved that this was among the highest quality beef we’ve had in all our travels as Burger Hobbyists and her topping choices enhanced it beautifully. Even through the mass of toppings on Market Street’s signature burger I was amazed and quite pleased that the bold bovine flavor came out on top. We’ve raved about chargrilled burgers in previous reviews, but these burgers tasted as if they had actually been cooked over charcoal, our favorite cooking method, and were a true carnivore’s dream. We highly recommend Market Street Grill and can’t wait to return to try such temptations as the Market Street Reuben, and Beef Brisket. It was well worth the approximate hour-​long drive. FYI: Full bar service is available and smoking is prohibited. No one under 18 is allowed. our server was extremely friendly and efficient and the restaurant is very clean. Life is good!

What a great find! Was traveling for work and needed a place for dinner. Looked at Unilocal to see what was near and decided to give this place a try. Will definitely come back when in the area. Had the Prime Rib and stuffed mushrooms-​awesome choice! Service was tremendous!!!

This used to be a great place to go. Not anymore!!!
Whoever is running this place needs a lesson in humility. The rudeness runs amuck!!! If this Is the way they are taking advantage of the new law that just went into affect, then my patronage will be withdrawn. Discrimination at its finest!!! All that was expected was an heart felt apology!!!

While working in Wabash for a day my electrician recommended this place. So glad I came for dinner at the end of a long 14 hour day. Folks on street said ribs or rib eye is tops. they were right Sheryl convinced me. They are presidential category!. Wonderful fall off the bones… Thanks chef!

Market street grill is your typical small town anything goes restaurant/​pub. Small town America has so many of these that look like they were trying to remodel as a faux Applebee’s in 1994. Aside from the some-​gimmicky /​some-​authentic wall flair that recalls the towns rich railroad history, it’s a very modest place with a bar that divides three rooms where you can dine. The menu is far reaching though don’t expect many fresh items or anything straying off the beaten path. I had a burger which was above average though nothing else piqued my interest. Onion rings were also good.
They have more than bud light and miller light but not a whole lot. Actually, they spotted one tap with New Holland and another with Sun King beers which was nice. The owner was helping behind the bar and was friendly and chatty. Seemed like a good dude and said he’d only had the place a year.
I can’t say a whole lot more than that and the food that I had there pre-​dates the new ownership. Maybe one day I’ll return.
Not many non chain options in town. May As well support a locally owned business.

This is a great place to eat. Service is generally good, quality of food is high, large portions, and a good value. Most of the time I can make two or even three meals out of my dinner at market street.

We are locals and every date night is a Market Street night. We love the prime rib and stuffed mushrooms. Their famous orange butter with the rye bread is my favorite. Best place in town to eat by far! I always thank the owner, who is the big guy at the bar (you can’t miss him) before we leave as the food is fabulous! Thanks for making our date nights yummy!!!

Wow, what a horrific experience. Aside from the hostess, we were treated with disregard like no other place ever. They were slightly busy so we sat at the bar to wait for a table, got ignored for half an hour, almost ready to leave when hostess struck up a conversation, then 15 min later were seated. Got our order after an hour and it was so disgustingly inedible we paid our crazy inflated bill and left. The drunkin’ chicken they are famous for? Who made it famous? People with no taste buds? Yikes and shame on you Market Street Grill !

The pork tenderloin sandwich is huge! And, it’s excellent. Friendly service & clean ladies room. Fun & funky décor. Just passing through between Indy & northern Indiana. Would do this again!

Best food in a three county search — plus there’s a no kiddie clause! Ohhh, imagine an excellent meal with a special someone and no screaming, crying or loud children to disturb you. This isn’t McDonalds so don’t complain about not being able to take your «mature» children! REFRESHING!
Big fan of BLT soup, drunken chicken and chili!
Good service, friendly folks and prices are decent for the quality and quantity of the meal.
Not only was this THE place for our first date, but we celebrate family birthdays and anniversaries there since!
And when they catered a business function, the food was just as good as having it at their restaurant! With plenty of leftovers!!!

I had lunch today at the Market Street Grill. What a treat! I had a breaded tenderloin on a Kaiser roll (very fresh) and a bowl of their chili.
The tenderloin may have been the best tenderloin I’ve ever had and the chili ranked right up there with the best. The Market St. grill service staff was very attentive and the ambiance of the place is worth the trip by it’s self. I met a friend there having driven up from Fishers, IN. I would do it again just for the experience/​food. Highly recommend if you’re in the Wabash area or want a great meal with drive.

If you visit the Market Street Grill, you must try the following:
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato Soup. It’s unique and refreshing. Enjoy it with a fresh loaf of bread.
Drunkin’ Fish is a treat and you must try it when you are visiting. Comes with a couple of sides (you can have the BLT soup again!!)
Dessert is just a treat and a half. Everyone at our table had a different dessert so we could try three different options. Not a bad choice on the menu!
Ribs were marginal. Atmosphere is delightful with a full bar. Go and enjoy a great meal in a small, midwestern town.