Brothers Pizza

First time ordering from Brother’s, just want to say we enjoyed the pizza very much! Will definitely be ordering from here again.

Had a coupon so decided to try it. Got the Big Brother, American Dream and Classic Zone. Everything was so delicious. Best Calizone around. Homemade Ranch. Entire family of 5 loved it. Will definitely be back!

I had tried Brothers Pizza years ago and it was awesome but since I live in BA it never came up as an option. I recently rediscovered it when I started working at 91^st and Yale. I ordered pizza for myself and my coworkers and it was a big hit! Lots of cheese!!! I also ordered myself a small Caesar salad w/​grilled chicken thinking I was going to get one of those small togo boxes with a little bit of salad in it. The ‘small’ salad is big enough for a full meal. They definitely didn’t skimp on the cheese and croutons either! I took a salad home to my husband last night and he said it was the best salad he has ever had! They will definitely be getting my business from now on!

Not impressed. Soggy crust, too much cheddar cheese (we had the #1) and not enough meat. We had high hopes based on some of the reviews but this place is just not cutting it with us. Nice staff.

My husband and I came here on a groupon yesterday. We picked a large, specialty pizza to go. It was half pepperoni and cheese with the other half being cheddar, sausage, and hamburger. We also picked up a 2 liter of Dr Pepper.
The service was quick and our pizza was ready in minutes. The price was excellent too. With the groupon, it came to just over a $ 1.00.
The best part? I signed up for rewards and earned a 25.00 gift certificate!

I’m a picky pizza eater, and this place hit the spot! They have a HUGE variety of pizzas, sandwiches, salads, and more, but the pizza and garlic cheese bread is top notch!
Their Ranch dressing is one of the BEST I’ve ever had. It’s so good for dipping the crust in it, even though the crust really doesn’t need it.
The only non-​perfect aspect of this place is that when you call them to place a delivery order, they give you a number to place your order through their delivery service, which is odd. It’s not bad, just adds more time as I had to wait for 5 minutes on hold when I called the delivery service. Also, the pizza is moderately high on the grease factor, but it’s so good! They have desserts, but no pizza desserts.
They delivered to our door in 30 minutes with two pizzas and an appetizer, which was nice because we could pay, including tip, over the phone, so the delivery man just handed us the pizza and walked away!
I will definitely order from them again, great flavor!

Family-​friendly pizza joint with a lot of to go orders. We’ve been here several times originally when the first brothers owned it but since is been sold. The new owners are really nice and try to make you feel welcome.
The TV in the eating area has been broken the last several times we’ve gone, lighting is poor and half working, which leads you to feel more like it’s a to go establishment.
The pizza this last time had so much cheese on it even my kiddos were complaining. They often have Groupon’s but I think I’ll even pass on the Groupon next time. Just way too heavy and greasy I can’t do it.

The Brothers who originally owned the business apparently sold it to someone else. I got a pizza from them a month ago after the change and the recipe had changed, the cheese tasted different, the sauce was watery and hardly any was on the pizza. Most importantly the crust wasn’t nearly as good.
I thought it was maybe a fluke, so I went back a week ago, and unfortunately it was the same thing.
Back before these new owners, the pizza was an excellent value and tasted great. Now, the quality has slipped too much. I guess they figured they could try and squeeze extra profits by changing something. IMO they should have stuck with what works.

Best pizza in Tulsa! I have been searching for great pizza in the area. Tulsa is in need of great pizza. Every pizza place sucks until now. We love it!

I had some Brothers pizza about 3 years ago and remembered it as being very good. I tried it again last week and it was nothing like I remembered. The crust was soggy and the cheese was tasteless. Something has changed. I have had better frozen pizzas.

New owners. Poor representation of the original. Ordered food tonight. 2 teens staffing the restaurant. They had no clue. Portions were very disappointing. The food was ice cold. Don’t waste your time or money.

the best pizza you can get in South tulsa. Though im not a huge fan of the crust and I usually love crust.

Good pizza. These guys are quick and make a good pie. Customer service is a little lacking and I usually get carry out since the place is pretty barebones.

Brother’s Pizza has become our Sunday night tradition. Good pizza. Good sauces. Very tasty. We have never dined in… only carry out.

I wish I could have reviewed the food, but we never got any. We walked in at 12:45pm on a Thursday. There were people finishing up at maybe 3 tables. The woman behind the register told us to take a seat, that someone would be right with us. We sat and sat some more-​no menus, no nothing. Same woman left with a takeout order, and we never saw her again. Finally after 15 minutes, a guy in the kitchen yelled out to us (now the only people in the place) have we ordered yet? We shook our heads no. He went back to his work, and 5 minutes later we left. We never even had a chance to order, but there are only 8 or 10 tables and all were dirty. This tells us that someone had lunch there. We went to Red Robin.*
* Two weeks later, we went back. The service was excellent! The pizza was as good as I’ve had since college. Their crust is that perfect middle-​of-​the-​road that we both love. Not big fat doughy and not a cracker-​crumb crunch. The toppings were plentiful and the sauce didn’t drip. We had half Brothers and half Smokehouse and the large was $ 15. We also tried the cheese sticks and they were yummy-​crisp outside and melty inside. Half of everything got taken home for later. It was a huge pizza! I am converted to Brothers. Five Stars now!

Great pizza with fresh, quality ingredients. A bit pricey if you want to feed the entire family, but the pizza is always good.

Do it !!! Yes it’s that good.

Pizza. Even when it’s bad, it’s good, right? Well, at Brother’s it’s not just good. It’s great. And I think it all hinges on the garlic crust. And their sauce. It’s tangy, but not spicy. And their cheese. It’s the best mozzarella I’ve ever tasted. I guess the best compliment I can give this place is that I can and do eat their pizza without ranch. I can’t say the same for any other pizza I’ve ever had.