Mama Rosa’s Pizzeria Restaurant

I have only ordered from here once, on a Friday for lent so we got a large pie with extra cheese.
WOW! Amazing! Just like Benny Tudino’s Pizza in Hoboken. It was huge! When we order a large, we usually expect about a 16″ pizza, this was probably a 22″ or 24″ and we were pleasantly surprised.
The sauce was great and the quality of the products used showed in the flavor.
They are closed on Sundays and Mondays which I like because it shows that it’s a family owned business and I love that they take that time for themselves.

It’s been a while since we’ve eaten here. Although the dining room was busy, almost full and they seemed to be several take-​out orders; I have to say the quality of the food has gone down. My husband and I both were disappointed in our meals. Another issue I have is they use Clorox diluted to clean the table tops. This bothers me for a couple of reasons; 1) Clorox is a trigger for migraines and 2) you have to wait until it dries before you can be seated. Otherwise you are taking the risk of getting it on your clothes. I had been having a great day and we were making the best of a date night/​anniversary dinner until they cleaned the table behind my husband with the Clorox water. I had to just get up and go outside. I was very disappointed and in much pain by this point. Don’t know if I will be dining in again.

We live in Titusville and would love to patronize individual owned businesses, try to venture away from Pizza Hut and Papa John’s, so we do try the family/​private owned places. We get consistently disappointed and Mama Rosa’s was no exception. I had looked on their web site for prices and when I called was only told that was outdated. I ordered a small (10″ they said) pizza, double pepperoni and extra cheese. When I went to pick it up, I was stunned at the $ 16 price but well, I didn’t ask in advance so just paid it. I agree with another reviewer here about how greasy it was. There was truly a deep puddle of grease over the top. They sent a menu with the order and the price for toppings was $ 3 each across the board, no less for a small which seems just crazy! So no, we will not use this one again. Pizza Hut may be generic, but you know what you are getting and what you are paying for it. Please someone, tell me a good pizza place in Titusville with fair prices, thank you!

We have never been disappointed with Mama Rosa’s. Our pizza tonight was fantastic as usual. If you want good quality, tasty pizza and not the nasty cheap Dominos or the like– try Mama Rosa’s. Yes it is more expensive than the chains but it’s because Mama Rosa’s uses fresh ingredients and fresh hand stretched dough. I would much rather pay the higher price for the better quality. Great job Mama Rosa’s!

Love, love, love this little Italian pizza place. must go place in Titusville we love the pizza

Best NY pizza in town. I always get the giant pie with pepperoni and it always is delicious. Thin crust with tasty sauce and cheese. The salad has iceberg lettuce which is the only downside.

Best white pizza I’ve ever had…
And I lived I lived in Philly and I’ve had a lot of white pizza.
Prices are a little high compared to other restaruants, but well, well worth it.

I’ve eaten here several times on date nights with my husband. The food is delicious and the atmosphere is cozy. And well, the name is quite lovely. ;)

Came here after a long day at Kennedy Space center, visiting from Long Island. Boys wanted Pizza, as it had been over a week since their last Pizza Fix. Saw the great reviews, so decided to stop in.
It was fantastic. Started with Garlic knots, which were the best I’ve ever had — fresh out of the oven, soft and buttery with excellent Fresh Garlic. Boys had a 16″ thin crust sausage and pineapple. Good crust, good ingredients. Sauce was solid. I had the Lasagna, which was the best I’ve had in years.
We finished up with a slice of cheesecake, and wished we’d ordered more than one!
Staff was very friendly as well. We’d definitely stop by again next time we’re in town!

Best pizza in Titusville! Service is always friendly and efficient. We’ve been here many times, and have had both pizzas and full dinners. Equally delicious – it’s the the sauce, yummy!
I’ve seen other diners with deep dish pizzas and always thought they looked good, crispy corner, lightly browned cheesy goodness dripping off the sides. But when I cast carb overloading guilt aside and finally ordered one, I wasn’t really a fan. The crust was kind of a mix between soggy and stale. I don’t know if it was a bad night, or what, but I’ll just stick with their regular pizzas because they are truly delicious. They taste exactly like a pizza is supposed to. Don’t forget dessert! Their cannollis are fresh and a must try also.

Consistently excellent Pizza. Would suggest to anyone. No other local place compares.

Visiting Titusville and decided to try Mamma Rosa’s. So very glad we did. The service was fast and efficient. The food was incredible! Prices were so affordable. We will go there again when we’re here again.

A great little Italian pizza shop tucked away on the side of the road! You can tell that it’s family owned, which is absolutely fantastic when it comes to food like this. Their pizzas are huge and delicious, with a rich sauce that was quite tasty, and their pastas are the same. Their salad and garlic bread are the perfect compliments to the meal. Would love to go back next time I’m in the area!

What? This place is beyond horrible. The great reviews on Unilocal are nowhere near my experience.
Our silverware was caked with dried food; both sets. The salad was wilted and spotty. The calamari was absolutely horrendous; this odd discolored rubbery pseudo-​squid was inedible to anything shy of a starving dog.
The pizza, which is what they should be able to do right, came served in a pool of grease in the center. The crust was so mushy and greasy that it was impossible to pick up without everything sliding off into a oily heap. This is usually a sign of poor ingredients; definitely nothing fresh. The sauce was lost in the cheese and grease so I can’t comment on it but I’m confident it was equally disgusting.
I ate here a couple years ago and it was a decent hole-​in-​the-​wall but now it literally has holes in the wall. The back door had a visible crack under the door that I assume allows any bugs or critters to come as they please. The ceiling had holes and the tables and floors were dirty. Bathrooms were also very unclean and smelled like a port-​o-​john… I just can’t believe anyone would eat at this place which is exceptionally bad, even for Titusville. I’d love to see what a food inspector would say after a drop-​in visit to this place.
Come on Titusville… it’s time to take some pride in the very few eating establishments that are allowed by the City Council from hell. As a long-​time local; I’m embarrassed that this would be considered a hot spot.

Another favorite for pizza and special occasions. We love their pizza and always order their side salad with house dressing. The waiters are exceptional and watching the family work every order to perfection is awesome. We love adding meatballs and ricotta to the pizza with peppers!

Ok so we were missing our papa gusepi but not anymore. I think we found a place with better pizza. Hard to believe but this was on point. Hats off to the chef. Perfection on the meat lovers pizza.

Have visited this location a number a times and am usually quite pleased. Pizzas are huge and, although they can be a little greasy sometimes, the ingredients taste fresh and well-​cooked.
Pasta dishes are what you’d expect — nothing special; though the meat sauce has a good texture and composition.
Desserts are as authentic Italian as it gets in Titusville!
Service is average — sometimes very attentive and friendly, sometimes mediocre.
Prices are very reasonable for the value received.

Found this place on Unilocal and decided to give it a try. We had the Antipasto Salad and a Calzone… we split, and it was so delicious. Our waiter was attentive and personable. I found out later the marinara is homemade and you can tell in an instant it was made with care. The portions are huge and we had lunch for under $ 20…we are full and happy we stopped by!!!

Great pizza! Very fresh ingredients. The cheese steak is also very good and prices are very fair. Great family owned pizzeria. Clean and friendly service.

Enjoyed the pizza. The crust was thin. Thec sauce was super tasty. I would definitely go back.

Locals tipped us off about Mamma Rosa’s. it was great. Mamma is still there and her home made sauce is the best. I had Stromboli, others had Pizza, and eggplant pasta. All were exceptional !
Locals swamp the place. They wait in line for tables and take-​out.
It takes a while to get served or get your check. But relax and enjoy. It is great food.