Aj’s Heavenly Pizza

AJ’s will always have a special place in my heart — I actively judge other pizza places against it. It’s relatively local, and a favorite for larger parties with their jumbo and jr jumbo coupon specials. Like other reviewers have noted, the sauce is sweet, so if that’s not your thing then it may not be for you. Other than outer crust pieces, it also tends to be a thinner crust more naturally (which I also love). In the grand scheme of things, it’s probably not ‘to die for’ and the ‘heavenly’ aspect of the chain is a little heavy-​handed, but still my hometown favorite and a must order whenever I visit family!

Very good pizza. Good value when you get the bigger pizzas. Their wings are decent, need more choices for the wings though. Good salad with AWESOME house dressing. Best pizza in town.

Since Tiffin is flooded with pizza shops, I tend to be picky about my slices. A.J.‘s heavenly serves up a unique dough that is moist and tasty. The sauce is slightly sweet, and has a great finish. They use premium cheeses on their pies, and you can tell the difference. This is one of the few places where I eat the crust, because it is so delicious. I highly recommend this place for its price, taste, and service. They have always been prompt and friendly, but make sure you’re prepared for a long line at lunch and dinner times. This place is extremely popular in the Tiffin area!

Great place to get pizza! Lots of options and the jumbo pizza is great for a crowd, you have to try the pepperoni rolls… AMAZING!!!

In a town filled and I do mean filled with Pizza options, AJ’s Heavenly Pizza is hands down the best pizza in town.
I judge a good pizza on its crust and sauce. The toppings are important but at the end of the day it all comes down to two things, crust & sauce.
Their pizza crust has the right amount of crunch and warm, chewy consistency. It is not too thick or too thin. Their sauce is perfection. It has a delicious robust tomato flavor with a hint of sweetness and they are generous with it but not to the point where sauce dominates the crust or leaves it limp and soggy. They have a large variety of toppings as well as various other Italian-​American dishes if you don’t pizza.
The staff are always super friendly and welcoming. They take pride in their work and it shows. Dollar for dollar this is the best pizza in town!

Oh ajs how I miss your delectable pizza sauce and raspberry vinaigrette dressing. Your pizza truly is heaven sent!