Magdy’s

My husband and I went to this restaurant for the first time last night, the menu was very limited in selection. The restaurant is very small and seating makes you feel like you are in a hamburger joint. Definitely not what I was expecting after all of the reviews I had read.
The staff was friendly but rushing customers out the door due to no seating and over booking reservations.
The food is most definitely not the best in Terre Haute, my husband and I both ordered filet that was pounded out and tenderized to point it was beef roast. I have been sick all day today on Valentines day with what appears to be food poisoning after eating here.

When asked out by my friend, Pam, for a birthday dinner, we met at Magdy’s, a resturant I was not familiar with and of course I really didn’t know what to expect. I was warmly greeted, seated with my friend and I knew that my first experience at Magdy’s was going to be great. The waiters were friendly and attentive, our glasses were always filled. Our appetizer and dinner not only looked and smelled great, but it was excellent. Magdy’s is one of the best restaurants in Terre Haute. If looking for a
quaint resturant with exceptional service and food, Magdy’s is a restaurant that should be considered, you will not be disappointed. Visit their website, read the reviews and look at their menu. You will not be disappointed dining at Magdy’s.

My family and I were excited to try Magdy’s, and it exceeded our expectations! The service from Xavier was top notch, and the food was delicious. We enjoyed fresh bread and salads, and pasta and seafood dishes. Our only complaint was that it was hard to decide what to order because there were so many things that looked good on the menu. The wine list also impressive. We will definitely be back!

The beef wellington was great and atmosphere as well. This was an enjoyable experience. The staff was very friendly and welcoming. It appeared that many guests were regulars who enjoy a relaxing dinner with friends or family. This is not a place if you are in a hurry… they encourage you to stay and enjoy yourself and your company. This was pleasant in comparison to other restaurants that try to turn guests as quickly as possible. I will go back.

I have been to the old location a couple of times. As quaint as it was, the new location is much better! The restaurant feels much roomier and more elegant.
I visited this restaurant for a catered event last week of about 40 people. Good and service was great. Our server made sure we were satisfied and always had something to drink. In a big group like this service can always be a little on the slow side, but everyone was friendly and made it a great evening!
Personally, I love the lamb chops. My colleagues rave about the beef Wellington. I have only visited on such hosted occasions, so I can’t speak to the regular menu. But I always leave more than satisfied and I love the new atmosphere. Now that it’s easier to locate, I have no excuse not to go back for date night!

Quaint small restaurant in Terre Haute. Nice, simple décor, makes you comfortable in a tie or jeans.
When I arrived it took a while to greet me and seat me. Finally just said «sit wherever you want». That shouldn’t have taken so long.
Waiter was nice. I ordered a Chardonnay, Caesar Salad and Salmon in Dill Sauce.
Caesar salad was awesome, dressed nicely with a hint of lemon. Very good and nice sized (not too small, not too big, just right).
Salmon arrived after a short delay. The Salmon was cooked just right. However, it seemed to be over sauced (see pic). I pushed much of the sauce aside and it was good. The rice and green beans were done perfectly. I enjoyed my meal.
In general the menu here is small. The chef does a good job and everyone seemed to like/​enjoy their food. I did notice lots of sauce left of plates, but pushing sauce aside isn’t too bad.
Service is nice, but a little slower than most places. Prices are consistent with a nicer restaurant. Salmon $ 22.

The service was excellent, several specials, great menu.
Reasonable wine menu.
Seafood fresh and tasty.
Good value too.