Toast Inc

Wow super salty Tuna salad. Wrap was nice and soft and veggies fresh. But omg that was some super salty tuna. Sodium city.

I should have walked out when two customers came back to complain about the spoiled milk in their coffee while I was in line to order my ice coffee. The owner was very very rude. He did not apologize to anyone but instead gave the customers a nasty look. After waiting for another few minilutes, (again, no apologies for making ppl wait) I got my coffee for $ 3.75 and it tasted DISGUSTING… It tasted like burn coffee from a week ago. I have to say it is by far the worst ice coffee I ever had in my life. The combination of the rudeness of the owner and their quality in coffee, left me with a very bad taste in my mouth. Avoid this place.

The bagels were stale and almost inedible. The workers were so slow and inefficient that in a line of around 5 or 6 it took me 20 minutes to get a simple order in. Would not recommend, try celebrity bagels around the corner for much better service and food.

Great service and decent food.
I’ve been to Toast a couple of times over the past few years. My go-​to when I’m in town visiting my boyfriend’s family is Celebrity for bagels and cream cheese and Tenafly Hot Bagels for their breakfast sandwiches. We decided to go to Toast to «change it up» recently. I got a sausage, egg, and cheese on an «everything» bagel, while my boyfriend got a bacon, egg, and cheese on a sesame bagel. I only really like «everything» bagels and was very disappointed when they didn’t have it in the flat option (they only had sesame). So I ended up taking out some of the extra fluff of bread, but overall was pretty satisfied with my choice. Their coffee was decent too.
I have to say that even though their food was just «okay,» compared to the other bagel shops in the area, I really enjoyed the service they provided us with there. It was a nice change to unfriendly, rushed service I get at the other bagel places.

Great bagels, nice place to sit, quick and decent service. The guy at the counter was a little rude but who isn’t at 5am? Definitely coming back again.

Good bagels and salads for NJ. I grew up on the best of the Brooklyn Bagels.
The staff and the manager could use some serious improvements.
He is either the manager or the owner and could use some personality training. Gives a big perfunctory hello and does not even look at you. Seems like he thinks rude is an good attribute. It is convenient when I visit my kids and it annoys me every time I go in there. All the workers need a better role model and should learn better English and what a bakers dozen is. Just sayin.

I love this place. The lunch I had here was terrific and the service/​hospitality was even better. I live in Manhattan, so I’ve had a lot of bagels, and mine at Toast was great. But also, because I was waiting for a kid of mine to take an exam nearby, I had 3 hours to spend. I went for the lentil soup, too. Delicious.
I noticed that the place was busy but not too busy. The perfect kind of bustle. Everyone treated well.
The Toast staff was very gracious as I sat, nibbled, sipped, and used my computer and the wifi available. It was just what I wanted.
A few weeks later, I had a special project that I enlisted their help on, and they couldn’t have been more helpful. I will be back whenever I’m in the area.

This bagel café is ok. Nothing exciting. Seemed to wait a long time for a toasted flagel when the shop was only a little busy. Guy had to check with me twice to make sure I ordered butter. Didn’t think the order was too hard to remember. If you need a bagel and you’re in Tenafly but just can’t make it over to Cresskill… stop in. If you can make it one town over, got to Cresskill bagels.

Love these bagels. I come here particularly because they have whole wheat everything bagels. I live in CA now, but come here whenever I’m home. My mom will occasionally ship a batch to me. Delicious! There are several bagel shops in town, but until they have everything whole wheat available, I can’t say they’re a favorite.