Selena & Nick’s Diner

If there were more stars they would be there I promise. This place is absolutely amazing! I was up there just a couple days ago visiting some old friends that lived in the area, and they recommended checking out Selena’s!
This was by far one of the best restaurants up on the mountain. Their food was amazing. The Kathleen was not only cute but funny too! She had me laughing even after she left to attend to other customers. I will definitely be returning to Selena’s as well as recommending it to my friends to check it out!
Thank you for the amazing service and the even better customer service from Kathleen! I can’t wait to see you guys again and try some more of that amazing food!

I would give zero stars if I could this place was absolutely disgusting the staff as well as manager were extremely rude I tried returning my
Food for my money back when I went to feed my daughter and noticed a piece of black hair «my hair is blonde» in my child’s food. gross I will never go back and would never recommend this place.

Came for lunch 8 adults 6children
Staff could not be nicer or more attentive
14 different orders
Came out perfectly as ordered
Food was great
Fresh egg salad
Potato skins. Club sandwich Rx food excellent for diner
Great experience
Recommend highly

I came here two days ago to have some lunch with my family. According to my parents, the pizza was great. I ordered hot chicken wings and although they were not hot, they were still really good. I hope to come back on my home from vacation.

Selena’s is a great diner. Everything I’ve had had been pretty good. Nothing gourmet preparation, but I’ve had good entrees, breakfasts, and their pizza is even good. Everything a diner should be.

Solid Diner.
1) The food is excellent. I got the cajun chicken wrap and fries. Both were wonderful.
2) The price is very cheap. They give you a ton of food.
3) The service was good as well.

Looking for a classic NY diner in this small mountain town? Look no further my friend because this place has what you need. The eggs were a bit overcooked (my scrambled eggs came out more like an omelette) but everything else was solid — try the French toast.
Seeing as we’re in upstate New York, when you ask for hot sauce they give you Frank’s Red Hot. This reviewer approves.

Very nice diner with excellent food and large quantities. Serve breakfast all day. Hash browns were excellent. You can get egg whites or egg beaters. Have wifi, which is nice because cellphone reception is very spotty in this area. Prices are reasonable.

Selena’s is a classic diner that really hits the spot. Low key atmosphere where you can stay as long as you’d like. They offer a lot of options on the menu as well as specials. The food portions are big and everything I’ve ever had has been tasty. Plus, the prices are unbelievably low! This is how a diner should be.
My one complaint would be that I do not like the coffee here. Perhaps I’m a coffee snob though. I feel so/​so about most diner coffee, but this seemed particularly bad to me.

Stopped in on our way home from a weekend at Hunter Mntn. Tons of cars outside so we decided to stop.
Overall, great place. Classic diner décor, friendly waitstaff, good food. I got the Belgian waffle with whipped cream and strawberries and it was probably the best waffle I’ve ever had: perfectly cooked and fluffy with super fresh strawberries (almost too fresh, some were still a little green… At least they weren’t frozen!). My hubby had the biscuits and sausage gravy and home fries which was also delicious. Only minor complaint about the food was that my side of bacon was a little lack-​luster (as I noticed in some other reviews) not terrible though. Bottom line, I would definitely recommend this place (and did!) and return again!

Tasty food and friendly service in this cozy nook in the Catskills. Portions are generous too! Especially loved the breakfast sausage and blueberry pancakes.

Always great food. Everytime I’m up in the area I make it a point to eat here. Breakfast, lunch and dinner, all good. Highly recommend this place.

good place for «standard» breakfast fare; nothing too fancy, the bagel is huge!

It seems impossible to find a decent place to eat in this area. Everything is so far apart, but we managed to find this diner.
Prices are very reasonable since it’s a local diner. I ordered the burger and it was good and juicy. My friend ordered the wings and I was able to try a piece. The wings are amazing! They’re big and juicy. If I’m ever in the area again, I will come back for the wings. Avoid the meatloaf. it’s dry and tough to eat. Sauce will not help.

Absurdly cheap, filling, no-​frills dining close to Hunter Mountain and your lodging therein. Dinner will run you about $ 10, $ 15 if you try hard or order drinks and such. My soup and burger were really solid. Not everyone in the group agreed, but my brother and nephews can be tough customers.
Service was amusingly direct, somewhere between professional and gruff. Best thing about it is the value, and the locals come here for that reason.

A basic, pretty good diner. Especially considering that decent diners (or ANY diners, for that matter!) are literally few and far between up here.
So far, we’ve only eaten breakfast here on several occasions, but the food has been consistently good, portions generous, prices OK, and the service friendly.
I gotta give ‘em props, though, since they know they are the only diner around, and yet, they still try hard to please the customer, even though they don’t have to. Decent food, decent staff. Give it a try.

Just your typical average diner. It is nice that they have one out here. Food is nothing special. I ordered a cajun wrap. When I received it, it was not at all what I expected. Instead of a light peppery, spicy sauce, the chicken was instead covered in a creamy sweet sauce. At least the french fries that came with it were pretty good– thick and crispy. I would only stop here again if nothing else was open.

I just spent the weekend up in Windham where apparently, everything has been wiped out. We had to drive to Tannersville for this diner, about ²⁵⁄₃₀ minutes, but with beautiful scenery. I must say I’m shocked there are reviews on it especially considering that I use Unilocal on my phone and I didn’t even have service here. Even with my epic hangover, this place was worth the drive.
30 bucks for 3 meals that were considerably filling, big plastic cups of soda, small but big enough seating area, and decent, not-​too-​slow service. Had me one a dem grilled portobella shroom wraps with chicken and some YUMMY crispy fried sweet potaters. My friends bacon was not so awesome but edible and still bacon-​y. Besides that, we loved our meals and our bellys were full enough to survive the journey home.
I’d also like to note that the bathrooms were clean.

I love this diner, plus it’s the only one on the mountain top. They always get my order right. I love their fries and Greek Wrap, also the Greek salad. They have great breakfast too, and their pizza isn’t bad either.

Another diner I love. We always stop here on our way back from North South Lake!