Park Street Pizza

I read an article on this restaurant in Ohio Magazine and it sounded like a sure bet destination when down in Amish country and it did not disappoint. The pizza was OUTSTANDING, certainly the best we have had in a long time! Loved the light crispy crust a nice change from the doughy, soggy crust you get in so many other places. We look forward to going back often and trying other menu items.

Wish I could have tried their food. Down in Amish country for a thanksgiving getaway, stopped by to have lunch at noon. Closed for Black Friday gift card sale? Not open until 3 pm? FAIL

I am always in search of excellent pizza. In fact, I keep a pizza «bucket list.» However, today I found myself in an unfamiliar location and hungry for a late dinner. The clerk at the front desk of my hotel suggested Park Street Pizza. I was pleasantly surprised. Delivery took only ~30 minutes. I ordered a pizza with old world pepperoni and black olives. The crust was yeasty, not too thick but not not too thin. The sauce was slightly sweet with mild spices. The old world pepperoni was about 1 inch in diameter and had crispy edges. Pepperoni flavor was not overpowering. Decenc amount of black olives. Pizza arrived hot with melty cheese. I hoped for an OK dinner but instead found a great pizza place!

Hubby and I stumbled on to Park Street Pizza because it was highly recommended on Unilocal… you hardly EVER find 5 stars on anything in a smaller town. Immediately I thought it was a franchise in this area of the country (we’re here on vacation from Arkansas), but it’s a one of a kind!!! After the delicious kale and quinoa salad and a RUEBEN pizza, I asked and everything they use is locally grown. Fabulous! It’s a good thing I don’t live here, because I would just move in!
A must if you’re anywhere within a 50 mile radius… seriously, it’s that good:)

Best pizza around. Food is fantastic and service is excellent. This is a favorite among locals!

Vacationing with the family in Amish country for the weekend and where did we decide to have dinner? A pizza joint. Ha! Why did we choose to forego the mashed potatoes, fried chicken, and cherry pie? Because of you guys! I relied on Unilocal to tell me the best place to eat while we’re down here and you chose a pizza joint! However, I now know why…
This is the absolute best pizza I’ve had in a long time! I live in the Cleveland area and we have hundreds of places to get pizza from. I think I’ve tried just about all of them too. Amish country has maybe 2 or 3 pizza places?
If you are a pizza traditionalist like me, the standard pepperoni pizza is a thing of beauty here. The crust has a slightly crispy outside with the chewy middle. The sauce has a perfect balance of sweetness and spice. But the best part of the pizza is the pepperoni! Look at the pictures, please. It’s how pepperoni should be done. Thinly sliced and cooked on top of the cheese so that it gets crispy.
I wonder if I can convince the family to go here one more time on our trip…

Happily we live only a few minutes from Park Street. Of course the pies are spectacular, the ingredients are fresh and locally produced and the salads are meals in themselves! The real hidden gem is the manager — all the locals know Rocky and his wife Corey as loving and caring people who do so much for the communuty which hopefully comes back to them tenfold! A must stop when visiting T County!

While visiting Amish Country and staying at the Carlisle Inn @ Berlin (which we highly recommend), we went to Park Street Pizza for dinner on Saturday night. We got there later, past 9pm but the staff were welcoming and didn’t mind the time we came. The food was awesome and so was the atmosphere. Really clean, super cute, trendy, modern restaurant that serves appetizers, pizza, salads, subs– all delicious! At a great price!
What a gem!
Thank you. Nice work!

AWESOME find!!! Went solely on reviews & the Unilocalers nailed this one! Not to mention, one of the only restaurants open on Sundays in this area. GREAT pizza, bread sticks, wings & salad. Reasonably priced, good service & very clean! Super busy!

My favorite pizza place. I recommend to anyone visiting Sugarcreek. Great pizza, salads, seasonal items. Fresh local ingredients and passion for great pies makes all the difference.

Yum! Salad was fantastic and the pizza was really good. You could tell they use fresh ingredients. I will be visiting there again soon! Give it a try, you won’t be sorry!

Park Street is a must for anyone in or around the area. Well worth the drive to experience the food and service Rocky and his crew offer.

Quinoa Kale salad the best. Great pizza and clean, friendly atmosphere. Top notch pizza place.

Park Street is a must visit anytime my wife and I visit her hometown (Sugarcreek). Top notch pizza! Fresh locally sourced toppings, good sauce, and a perfectly done crust. The restaurant has a really cool atmosphere and the staff are friendly. Give it a try, you won’t be disappointed!

Great pizza. It’s a must do when we are in the area. Beautiful décor, friendly staff and great menu options. The salads are wonderful and we asked for thin crust so they made it thinner to our liking. You won’t be sorry for trying this place out. We were thanked on our way out. I love that!

Such a wonderful pizza restaurant. Excellent food, great service, and sparkling water on tap! If you come to visit this restaurant, make sure you use the bathroom. They are incredible. Don’t believe me? Stop in to find out for yourself. I will definitely be returning to this stop in the future. Sparkling water on tap, sparkling clean restrooms!

You wouldn’t expect to find a pizza place like this in Amish country. It rivals any other pizza I’ve had. They always have a variety of seasonal pizzas and salads. It’s a 45 – 60 min drive for us, both totally worth it. Also check out some of their house made sodas.

Who knew such a find was waiting in Sugarcreek, Ohio? Not me, that’s for sure.
Good salad, great pizza. Friendly folks. A cozy (under construction at the time of this writing) pizza shop is nestled off a back road (aren’t they all back roads) in Sugarcreek.
We had the Chicken Pesto pizza and it was definitely something to write home about. Fresh ingredients, house made delicious pesto and big chunks of white meat chicken. It was extremely delicious. I can’t believe I the whole thing.
If you’re in Sugarcreek looking for a bite, you can’t beat Park Street. Yummy!

All around great quality food. Fresh ingredients prepared right on site! Something for everyone.

The best pizza ever ever! There’s always a long wait but it’s so damn worth the wait. A must eat if in that area