Supreme Pizza & Pasta

Ordered two dinners. The first one was linguine and white clam sauce. It was OK, if you like canned clams. The second dinner was a Stromboli. It was sitting in a pool of grease, so much, it was inedible. It was so greasy, the dough was actually floppy and limp. I posted a picture of the Stromboli. I called supreme pizza, and was told that they had just closed and wouldn’t remake it. The counter girl informed me that the grease was from the meat inside. I have ordered many Stromboli’s in the past and had never seen something this disgusting. I really can’t express how much grease was really on this Stromboli. It got thrown away, and I had McDonald’s instead. If you are going to eat here, don’t order the Stromboli. Apparently they can’t figure out how to make it right without a puddle of grease and per the counter girl, this is normal.

As close to real New York style Pizza as you are going to get. I almost thought I was back in New York. Great sauce not sweet, just right. Hands down best pizza in Stuart. Can not wait to try their other entrees.

Solid quality pizza, not quite the best in town but still above average. Solid choice if you are in the southern part of town. Good toppings.
Not a very big place to sit and eat, better for pick up.

I never write reviews but I feel they deserve it. Great Pizza! Will be back very soon to try some of their dishes. I am so glad I found this place when I was driving by!!!

Their cold turkey sub was fresh and delicious. My parents split a mushroom and sausage pizza that they enjoyed. That special that night was chicken Françoise that came with a side of spaghetti and a salad. The chicken was delicious! My brother had a meatball sub that was cooked to perfection. The prices were reasonable, pleasant wait staff. Would definitely go back.

Excellent quality for New York style pizza. The sicilian is beyond reproach! The ingredients they use are top notch. Eddie, Chris are the best. They treat you like family whenever I arrive. Don’t be fooled by other pizza joints, big apple, big slice, Salerno they all skimp on the quality of ingredients and use screens under the pie while baking. They will say it is to cook the crust evenly but that is a an excuse to not brush and properly clean the oven. Don’t be fooled Supreme is the best in Stuart.

I live locally and have in fact bought at least one pizza from everybody in the business, including corporate.
I really like the «Supreme Pizza» because of the good mesh of flavors. Cheap, no. But if I eat any more than 3 pieces I’m rolling around and ready for bed. Because of the leftovers I divide the price accordingly.
I like the place and have been served well on every visit.
I’ve brought this pizza to many gatherings and everybody always asks me where I got it… I have bought the «cheap» pizza on Monday and Tuesdays and it actually is very good. Only problem is I can devour the whole thing and there is nothing leftover.

I love pizza — anytime, anywhere it’s rare that I find a pizza I don’t like. This was not good pizza. NY style with soft thin crust (not a fan of that to begin with). Mushrooms were from can (yuck) and sausage was in a strip — unlike any I ‘d ever seen. If you stick with plain cheese or pepperoni you may be alright but I don’t think we’ll be back any time soon. Papa Johns better.

DELICIOUS! Best pizza ever, best shrimp parm ever, best pasta… really nice guys in there, great service, amazing prices! :)
I’m a loyal customer here!

Ok let me start off by saying that the food here is great BUT… the owners and workers are a-​holes!
I think they are trying to give off the feeling of an authentic NYC pizza joint, which includes the rude waitstaff and all around hostile environment.
There are all these lame limitations like you can’t pay with a credit card if your order is under $ 15 and they will refuse to deliver to your house if your order is under $ 10.
If you plan to visit this establishment, keep in mind that you WILL be treated like crap. At best, the workers will be gruff, at worst they will be downright mean (annoying New York accent included!!)
I don’t think they understand that they are no longer in New York but are in fact, in South Florida, where the way of life is a lot more easy going.
To sum it up, their food is very good but you WILL experience high blood pressure from dealing with the folks who work here. Is it worth it? I’ll leave that up to you…