Broadway Bagel & Deli

I started going here a few months ago, all of the other bagel eateries that I know of are just mediocre. Things are starting to fall apart here. the prices are a little high but I don’t mind as long as it is worth it. The last time I sat and ate, they forgot to put ham on my sandwich. The the 3 times I have called ahead to see if they have bialeys, all 3 times there were none at 8:30 am. You would think that you would increase your bagel production as business warrants it.
Anither thing they do which is strange, they take your order then you pay after you get the food. Instead of the confusion, they should take the order, finish the transaction and that way when the food is done, your on your way
The inconsistency of not having what I like will keep me from going back.: (

Nice location, very difficult to park in the area and there isn’t a parking lot anywhere in sight. Walked into a well organized store front only to find out that none of the organizational skills were being used instead customers just have to huddle around the cash register and wait to be called on. Food was OK but nothing to go crazy over.

Great place! We take a long morning bike ride each weekend and always make a point to stop by for a coffee and some breakfast. The owners and staff are always friendly and make a point to connect with their customers. This is great attribute to have and refreshing to encounter such hospitality this day in age. The food is always good and the bagels are the freshest around. We highly recommend this place.

NOTE: This is now Broadway Bagels. I am willing to give them a chance since Bagel Brothers in gone and out of business. I picked up a half dozen Bagels to go and the bagels were very good! The service was friendly. Hopefully they will have a good supply of bagels.
Bagel Brothers offers a really good bagel… if you can get them. I have stopped by on numerous occasions, especially on Sundays around 10AM only to be told they were out of bagels. Who runs a BAGEL shop that runs out of bagels by 10AM? It must be real poor business management. I believe the shop, as others have said, has changed hands and it only seems to be going downhill. Only the early bird gets the bagel at this shop.

They have some nice seating outside by the fountain. They are like a counter-​service deli with good sandwiches (a little too much meat on them), sides, and yummy muffins.

Food and service used to be great. I paid 9 dollars an omelette to get treated like mc donalds. Gave them 5 dollar tip on a breakfast that was 25 $ should be 15 $ at a place like this. And they couldn’t bring me my food like they used too. They changed there sausage in there sandwhiches. Taste like crap. Only takes up half of the bagel. Needless to say I used to love this place. They charge way to much for there food. Asked for hot sauce I got two drops. Asked again they rolled there eyes. Took ten minutes to get and I was half way trough my meal. Prices are not like this in New York at your neighborhood bagel shop. The only thing done right left is they way the eggs are cooked on the bagel sandwhiches. But not worth my money anymore

Delicious Reuben sandwich, the ingredients were very fresh and the bread exceptional. The deserts were eye popping and just as tasty as they looked. Outside seating is great during the spring.

Aggravation from the confused untrained people that work there, doesn’t make it worth it.
Thanks but ill pass…

I love these bagels because I have TMJD and havent had bagels in a long time because of it. My boyfriend brought me here and i was nervous that my jaw was going to pop out because usually bagels are very firm and the hardness of bagels irritates my jaw. I was very very happy that their bagels are soft but not like Einstiens. Im giving them 4 stars because I wish they had a better beverage selection, I’m a tea drinker and they only had crappy Lipton tea

I agree with other reviewers regarding the pleasant surroundings and excellent service.
I was, however, disappointed with the bagels. The bagels here are light and «bread-like»…much like you would get at a place like, say, Einstein’s. I call these «BINOS» (bagels in name only).
This is not to say that the bagels are bad… just not what I would regard as «authentic». I expect more from a place with «New York» in the name.
One other issue… I think that $ 3.50 plus tax for a single bagel with cream cheese is a tad steep.

This is the best Bagel shop and Sandwich shop in the area. I have been back three times and will go back many more great service short wait even at lunch rush.

Bagel Brothers is a great place for breakfast or lunch. The Stuart location is located in a quaint storefront next door to the courthouse. The building has outdoor seating situated around a beautiful fountain with lots of brick and greenery.
The quality of the food is above average. They have a nice selection of bagels and a full deli cabinet. There is also a cabinet with pastry & cookies.
Today, I stopped in for a bagel and cream cheese (they have really great Philadelphia style cream cheese) but opted for a turkey sandwich on multi grain bread with swiss cheese and chipotle mayonnaise. This sandwich was awesome! It came with a small side, I chose the fresh fruit salad, and pickle wedge.
I’m not a coffe drinker but others friends say the coffee is good. They have a self serve soda machine serving Coke products and a case with a wide assortment of bottled drinks including Natalie’s juices.
The only thing that is a bit odd is how they take your order and when you pay. There is no rhyme or reason as to who or where you place your order even though its marked. This isn’t usually a problem if your the only one in line (there is no line) but if it is busy, it causes a lot of confusion.
Also, they take your payment after your food is served. You place your order and then go sit down and when you are called, you come back to the counter to pick up your food and pay. Just one more confusing step, especially if its busy. It would be so much more organized if the person taking your order would just take your payment.
Overall, one of the better bagel places.

I’ve never ordered a bagel because I can’t get past the sandwich case. These sandwiches are amazing. The eggplant sandwich melts in your mouth. Crunchy bread on the outside with the cheese and eggplant warm and melty on the inside. Sometimes I stuff it or take half home for the next day, whichever mood I’m in! This what a New York deli is all about, if anyone was wondering.

Excellent. Huge sandwiches, heroes and the best potato salad I’ve had. The bagels are the real deal. Get here for breakfast too.

This place is amazing! I had an everything bagel and it was fantastic! Super friendly owner as well! I would be here everyday if my waist could handle it.

Delicious coffee and good tasting bagels. Nice place with outdoor seating.

Great deli, portions are obscene. I don’t believe the owners are Jewish though, the amount of lox on an open breakfast bagel just doesn’t make economic sense. As a result I am skipping both lunch and dinner and, for all practical purposes, am in a lox induced coma.
Great place, will be back, will be more careful ordering, may be get half a bagel next time

I had a bacon cream cheese everything bagel. It was a little salty, but yummy.

Wow! Really good bagel and egg sandwiches. It’s in the old Edelweiss deli location on East Ocean. They offer healthy options like egg whites/​fruit/​yogurt and have great coffee. The menu is a little confusing at first because they do a la carte and combo deals, so it may take you a few minutes to figure out what you want. Nice option to sit outside, too.